Places to stay near Brotherhood, America's Oldest Winery

Book unique holiday rentals, homes and more on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals near Brotherhood, America's Oldest Winery

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Top guest favourite

A charming two-story cottage is surrounded by vibrant landscaping, featuring a mix of colorful flowers. The exterior is painted in green with maroon shutters adorning the windows. A wooden staircase leads to the upper entrance, while a welcoming front door is accented by a small planter.

Guest suite in Montgomery

Garden View Guest Cottage

Located under 15 min. to Stewart Airport...1 mile to City Winery , nearby Angry Orchards , 1/2 hour to West Point Charming cottage setting located in the village of Montgomery, NY, Come for the day or stay for a few to take in all this historic area has to offer. Walk to some of the best restaurants in Orange County or simply read a book in the gardens... Truly a great value since it's a true "apartment " like setting..not just a room, with all the conveniences and sleeps up to 4 people.

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 585 reviews

Superhost

An aerial view captures a sprawling landscape at sunset. Lush green trees frame open fields, while a river snakes through the background. The sky is filled with warm hues of orange and yellow, creating a tranquil atmosphere over the countryside.

Farm stay in Salisbury Mills

Rustic Ranch w/ Fire Pit, Trails & Grazing Horses

Escape the city and wake to the sound of grazing horses. Nestled on a 50-acre equestrian property, the Carriage House blends cozy charm with eclectic design and wide-open skies. Sip morning coffee with views of the Moodna Viaduct, then hike our private trails or explore Storm King Art Center. Unwind by the fire pit, or book a hands-on horse experience with our gentle herd. Nearby: wineries, hiking, farm markets,& MetroNorth (NYC in ~90 mins) Ideal for couples, small families, or solo retreat

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 110 reviews

Superhost

An indoor heated swimming pool is featured, surrounded by wooden paneling and illuminated by colorful LED lights. A hot tub is positioned beside the pool, with two lounge chairs placed nearby. Large windows offer views of the exterior while maintaining a cozy atmosphere.

Home in Newburgh

Entire Home, Private Indoor Pool

This unique specious and tranquil getaway private home includes an indoor heated swimming pool, hot tub, an outdoor space of 34 acres for you to enjoy nature, work out equipment, movie theater. Complete eat in kitchen, outdoor grill. washer and dryer, three bathrooms. Huge open space basement equipped with LED changing color light. Rooms have Wi-Fi LED light to connect music. The place sleeps 8 guests, in beds. Two additional twin mattresses.16 guests maximum. Hot tub take a while to heat up.

4.81 out of 5 average rating, 136 reviews

Guest favourite

Home in New Windsor

Historic Cornwall Farmhouse w/ Sauna & Hot Tub

Welcome to The Storm King Farmhouse! Experience the best of upstate living in this beautifully renovated 1800s farmhouse located 50 mi from NYC. The property features a heated pool, Finnish sauna, premium hot tub, pickleball & basketball court, fire pit, pond, and more! Located close to exciting Hudson Valley activities - Storm King Art Center (1 min), West Point (15 min), Legoland (25 min), hiking trails, breweries, etc. This is the perfect place to relax with family & friends! Pet friendly!

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 107 reviews

Top guest favourite

A spacious outdoor area features a modern pool surrounded by wooden decking. Lounge chairs are positioned under large umbrellas, providing shade. The two-story home is visible in the background, showcasing large windows that enhance natural light.

Home in Putnam Valley

Heated Pool, Ultra Modern Home 5B, hot tub, sauna

Secluded, luxurious 5Br/3.5Bth home an hour from NYC, nested on a 9-acre property with the Appalachian trail running through. Modern-rustic design, floor-to-ceiling windows, custom kitchen, state-of-the-art appliances, balconies. Dip in the heated pool (seasonal) or the hot tub, sauna, dine alfresco from the BBQ and watch the stars. Guests can enjoy morning coffee on the private deck or evening cocoa in front of the wood-burning fireplace or the fire pit, outside, overlooking a private pond.

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 177 reviews

Guest favourite

A serene view of Walton Lake captures a wooden dock extending into calm waters. The setting sun casts a warm glow over the landscape, reflected in the lake. Lush greenery frames the scene, enhancing the tranquil atmosphere.

Cottage in Monroe

Cozy Lake Cottage

Make wonderful memories on pristine Walton Lake. 1 hr from NYC . This ALL INCLUSIVE Waterfront Cabin is like a mini resort! Rustic, rugged, off grid feel yet 2 miles from town. It has 2 docks, over water hammock & fire pit🔥. Enjoy sunsets in any temps from inside or out, or coffee in the tree hut! Hungry? Paddle🛶 across the lake for tacos🌮 & drinks🍸. Inside has retro & antique decor, modern appliances, fireplace♨️, & strong WIFI. Includes COMPLIMENTARY Firewood, NO CLEANING/PET FEES🐕

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 209 reviews

Superhost

A spacious living area features a comfortable gray sofa, accented by festive throw pillows. A light-colored coffee table sits in the center, surrounded by cozy armchairs. A large flat-screen TV is mounted on the wall, with natural light streaming through the nearby window.

Home in New Windsor

Farmhouse Getaway - 13mi to West Point

Gather with friends or family at our 1900s Hudson Valley farmhouse. This 3 bedroom unit offers one-level living with just one small step to the back deck—ideal for guests who prefer no interior stairs plus your own Hot Tub Bliss under the stars. Can accommodate large groups with 2 Kings, 1 Queen, plus 2 Queen sleeper sofas, twin daybed, twin trundle & floor mattress. Near Schunnemunk Mountain, Storm King, West Point and Newburgh waterfront. Fast Wi-fi, desks for remote work, free parking.

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 101 reviews

Guest favourite

A cozy living area is showcased with two accent chairs, one in a warm terracotta tone and another in vibrant red, featuring a playful design. The wooden floor complements the inviting atmosphere, while framed artwork adorns the walls, adding visual interest to the space.

Guest suite in Chester

Serene Victorian Guest Apartment with Clawfoot Tub

Escape to a stunningly renovated private 3rd-floor apartment in a 6000 sq ft. 1883 Victorian Manor in Blooming Grove, NY. Designed for 1–4 guests, this light-filled space offers comfort and classic charm in a peaceful country setting. Includes luxe beds, a clawfoot tub, French-door shower, and kitchenette with sunny breakfast nook. An ideal sanctuary. Views of wildflowers, quiet country, and cows next door. 3rd Floor up two staircases, rewarded with a stunning space and elevated views.

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 412 reviews

Top guest favourite

Guest suite in New Windsor

The Loft Your Private Retreat

You'll be the only guests in this totally private second-floor space with your own exterior entrance and foyer. The Loft features a very large room with 12-foot ceiling, AC, heat. Two queen-sized beds, writing desk, bistro table, books, 42 inch TV - plenty of room to relax, work or simply unwind. Enjoy morning coffee/tea and morning muffins. Step through the sliding glass door onto your private east-facing balcony, a lovely spot to start the day. Private. Spacious. Comfortable. Peaceful.

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 314 reviews

Guest favourite

A modern kitchen area is presented with open wooden shelves displaying dishes, glassware, and decorative items. Below, a gas stove and black refrigerator are complemented by a light fixture and a collection of utensils, offering a functional and organized space.

Cottage in Goshen

Relaxing Farm Cottage Escape, 10 Min from LEGOLAND

Picture this... You escape to a relaxing, picturesque, and peaceful country cottage and enjoy some of your favorite convenience amenities like 1 Gig Wifi and your favorite streaming sources. Just 10 minutes to LEGOLAND, 3 miles to the famous Orange Heritage Trail, and less than 20 minutes to America's oldest winery, Brotherhood, this cottage has something to offer for everyone. You'll be minutes from conveniences like Target but taking in the views, you'd never know it.

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 386 reviews

Top guest favourite

A serene lakeside view is captured at dusk, showcasing vibrant hues of orange and purple in the sky above a calm water surface. Silhouettes of trees and lanterns frame the scene, offering a peaceful ambiance as the last light fades.

Cottage in Newburgh

Cozy Lake Cottage

Cozy cottage in residential lake community, adjacent to historic fine dining restaurant. There is an approximate 150 yard walk down to the lake to enjoy the spectacular sunsets . Centrally located in the Hudson Valley near everything there is to experience. Located in our area Many Local Wineries ( Angry Orchard) Woodbury Commons Outlet Mall Historic Newburgh and Waterfront Culinary Institute of America US Military Academy New Paltz and Mohonk Mountain House

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 261 reviews

Guest favourite

Barn in Mountainville

Renovated Red 1890’s Hudson Valley Barn

Renovated barn in Mountainville, NY at the base of the Schunnemunk hiking trails. 1 mile from Storm King Art Center. 3 miles to Cornwall. 10 minutes from Woodbury Common Premium Outlet. 15 minutes to West Point. Private stairs & balcony leads to 500 square foot second-story space. You get the entire upstairs to yourself. The NYS Thruway does run between the house and the mountain. There is highway noise. TV has a ROKU. Strong WIFI.

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 168 reviews