Holiday rentals in Fire Island Pines

My sisters and I had a wonderful stay at Tami's house. This place has sunrise AND sunset views which are absolutely beautiful in a crisp winter sky. The kitchen provided everything needed to cook a gourmet meal and there is no lack of places to eat if you prefer to go out. The location was perfect for relaxing, and the neighborhood felt safe. Tami was responsive and made sure everything went smoothly. I highly recommend this place to anyone visiting the East end and would love to stay there again in the future.

Amber’s place was immaculate and stunning. This was my 2nd time staying and it was just as magical! The place had plenty of space for a family of 3 and the washer/dryer was very convenient. We had a great time and would stay here again!

Mathew was very accommodating and very responsive. His location on the board walk was very centrally located. Walking distance to everything. He allowed late check out which was nice. It was my first time on the island so was not aware of many rules and regulations. I suggest researching before booking.

very responsive and friendly host. listing was just as posted, very spacious and clean.

What a lovely and private place! Madison provided a clean and well-organized home. She even left us a thoughtful gift that my family and I truly appreciated. Thank you Madison!

Clean, easy to access, spacious, lots of amenities, and more. It was worth every penny.

Wonderful house, with every possible thoughtful touch from bath robes and slippers to a popcorn machine! Louis was so kind and easy to communicate with. We would love to come back!

We had a GREAT time on this very special island, and the cottage was the perfect base! It is cosy and comfortable, perfect for two moms plus four kids. The location is great: less than 5 minute walk to beach and less than 10 to town. The house is secluded and adorable, with our own resident deer family chilling in the garden and on the path - so special and adorable. The cottage is basic but comfortable, charming. We loved the outdoor shower! The hosts were responsive and kind. Many thanks!

We really enjoyed our stay at Bellport, it was extremely clean! The kitchen/baths were well appointed. The yard is gorgeous and the pool was delightful. Beds were very comfortable and the bathrooms are beautiful. Such a great place!