Skip to content
BBQ and outdoor lounge guest house50 foot heated pool
Save this listing.
Entire house

Stunning Shelter Island Main House and Guest House

Grainne User Profile

Stunning Shelter Island Main House and Guest House

Entire house
14 guests7 bedrooms5 beds5.5 baths
14 guests
7 bedrooms
5 beds
5.5 baths
Great location
100% of recent guests gave this home’s location a 5-star rating.
Grainne is a Superhost
Superhosts are experienced, highly rated hosts who are committed to providing great stays for guests.
Sparkling clean
5 recent guests have said that this home was sparkling clean.

Stunning Shelter Island traditional over 3 floors with pool and separate contemporary guest house in luxury settings. Short walk to Sunset Beach, restaurants, tennis and golf. Entertaining space galore, movie screen, wrap around decks, fully private gardens. Local Shelter Island License Numb(PHONE NUMBER HIDDEN)
This listing is for the main house and guest house.


Wireless Internet
Free parking on premises
Indoor Fireplace
Cable TV

Sleeping arrangements

Bedroom 1
1 super king bed
Bedroom 2
1 super king bed
Bedroom 3
1 super king bed
Bedroom 4
1 king bed, 1 single bed
Bedroom 5
2 single beds
Bedroom 6
1 super king bed
Bedroom 7
1 king bed
Common spaces
1 sofa bed

House Rules

No smoking, parties, or events
Check-in time is 4PM - 10PM and check out out by 11AM


8 Reviews

Martha User Profile
October 2018
We were a group of old of friends who planned a getaway. This house was beautiful, warm, and equipped all the amenities. Grainne made sure that we were comfortable and introduced the local highlights, including the wonderful farmer’s market. From the nearby beach to fresh herbs i…
David User Profile
August 2018
Awesome! I’ve been renting Summer homes in various destinations for nearly a decade and Grainne & Rory’s place was by far the best. From the size, indoor/outdoor spaces, chef’s dream kitchen, convenience amenities — spectacular pool and guest house — and location (walking dist…
David User Profile
July 2018
Great house. Lots of space, great pool area and very well stocked with everything you need. We hope to return again.
Meredith User Profile
June 2018
When we pulled up to the house we knew we were in for a treat! It was even more gorgeous and HUGE than the pictures. It was a comfortable stay for 14 ladies and we ALL want to find a reason to go back. Thank you!!
Grainne User Profile
Response from Grainne:
So glad you had such a good time... and we'd love to have you back!
June 2018
John User Profile
September 2017
This house is incredible! Super clean, super high tech! It has every single thing you could want or hope for in a house. Huge bedrooms, surround system music everywhere, amazing kitchen with all the cooking supplies you could ever dream of. Amazing pool/ guest house. Towels, shee…
Kelly User Profile
August 2017
We had a fanastic family reunion at Grainne's beautiful Shelter Island home. There was plenty of space for everyone and a chef's kitchen with everything you could possibly need. Our kids loved going to the beach (a very short walk) and then coming home and hopping in the pool. I…
Jennifer User Profile
July 2017
Grainne's place is absolutely STUNNING. It is even more amazing than the pictures. We were a group of 3 couples each with two daughters ages 2-6. It was the perfect space for that size group. The outside area and pool house are so well equipped we hardly even used the rooms o…

Hosted by Grainne

Shelter Island Heights, New York, United StatesJoined in March 2017
Grainne User Profile
14 Reviews
Grainne is a SuperhostSuperhosts are experienced, highly rated hosts who are committed to providing great stays for guests.
Always communicate through AirbnbTo protect your payment, never transfer money or communicate outside of the Airbnb website or app.

The neighbourhood