Skip to content

The Lord‘s Cottage on the Water

Entire house hosted by Maghnus
4 guests2 bedrooms3 beds2 bathrooms
Entire home
You’ll have the house to yourself.
Enhanced Clean
This host committed to Airbnb's 5-step enhanced cleaning process.
Maghnus is a Superhost
Superhosts are experienced, highly rated hosts who are committed to providing great stays for guests.
Great location
100% of recent guests gave the location a 5-star rating.
Cozy, quiet, newly renovated cottage on the picturesque Menantic Peninsula. Located on a Shelter Island historical landmark (The Lord's Shipyard), and perfect for families or couples looking for a quiet paradise nestled in nature on the sea. 5 minute walk from the Island Boatyard and excellent restaurants, and a 5 minute drive from Sunset Beach. Sea views from every room and bathroom. Stunning sunsets every evening visible from the back porch.

The space
Brand new space, renovated this year (2018). Central air-conditioning and heating in every room, screens and shades on all windows/doors. Located on a 7 acre, seaside estate with sea views from every room.

There is a brand new Bosch washer and dryer!

Places for sleeping

Bedroom 1
1 king bed
Bedroom 2
2 single beds

What this place offers

Beach access – Beachfront
Free parking on premises
TV with standard cable/satellite
Washing machine
Air conditioning
Patio or balcony

Select check-in date

Add your travel dates for exact pricing
Add date
Add date

4.85 out of 5 stars from 47 reviews


Where you’ll be

Shelter Island, New York, United States

Quiet residential area nestled in nature, with quaint restaurants, beaches, and cafes. Great for biking, walking, swimming, and relaxing.

Hosted by Maghnus

Joined in February 2016
  • 54 Reviews
  • Identity verified
  • Superhost
I’ve visited and been a resident of Shelter Island my entire life. I love to travel, ski, hike, be in the water, and spend time with my family.
  • Aimee
During your stay
Available by text, or AirBNB message.
Maghnus is a Superhost
Superhosts are experienced, highly rated hosts who are committed to providing great stays for guests.
  • Languages: English, Español
  • Response rate: 100%
  • Response time: within an hour
To protect your payment, never transfer money or communicate outside of the Airbnb website or app.

Things to know

House rules
Check-in: 17:00 - 00:00
Check out: 10:00
Not suitable for children (2-12 years)
No smoking
No pets
No parties or events
Health & safety
Committed to Airbnb's enhanced cleaning process. Show more
Airbnb's social distancing and other COVID-19-related guidelines apply
Carbon monoxide alarm
Smoke alarm
Security Deposit – if you damage the home, you may be charged up to £1078
Cancellation policy

Explore other options in and around Shelter Island

More places to stay in Shelter Island: