Skip to content
The original "Toaster House" Guest Wing, designed by architect Andrew GellerFront door entrance.
Save this listing.
4 guests
2 bedrooms
2 beds
2 baths
4 guests
2 bedrooms
2 beds
2 baths
Sparkling clean14 recent guests have said that this home was sparkling clean.
Great check-in experience100% of recent guests gave this home’s check-in process a 5-star rating.
Maribeth is a SuperhostSuperhosts are experienced, highly rated hosts who are committed to providing great stays for guests.

One of the few remaining original Andrew Geller-designed Midcentury Modern classic homes, the Toaster House has a dramatic and playful design, and retains most of its original 1962 features, including a wall of windows, two decks and a 2-story fireplace. The library contains hundreds of books, vintage games, artwork and curiosities; the setting is rustic, comfortable, sunny and serene.


Wireless Internet
Free parking on premises
Indoor Fireplace
Laptop friendly workspace

House Rules

Not suitable for children and infants - Children 6 yrs and older are welcome.
No smoking, parties, or events
Check-in is anytime after 3PM and check out by 11AM


147 Reviews

Michelle User Profile
November 2018
Maribeth’s Toaster House is a destination in and of itself. I can’t think of North Fork without thinking of her place. We stayed with her 4 years ago to date as her third guests ever and she’s managed to keep all the lovely personal touches, details, food treats and amenities jus…
Mike User Profile
November 2018
Amazing place. It's a real treat to wake up in the Toaster House, and it's the perfect place to wind down at the end of the day.
Wendy User Profile
November 2018
Remarkable unique home... cozy, artsy, fabulous. Wood burning fire and high ceilings with big windows looking into the trees. Maribeth was wonderfully welcoming and offered great tips which helped my daughter and I make the most of our time there. Mattituck and area were gorgeo…
Shelby User Profile
October 2018
Maribeth’s home is beautiful and very unique! The fireplace is lovely and the home is very comfortable. The location is super convenient for getting around the North Fork!
Christian User Profile
October 2018
This house is great and Maribeth is an amazing host. The house has everything you may need for a weekend getaway. Not only was Maribeth extremely communicative and helpful but she also left us amazing treats. Thank you!
Pierre User Profile
October 2018
Maribeth’s house makes you feel home from the very first minute. The toaster house is the most perfect nest for a beautiful short break in the North Fork.
Kim User Profile
October 2018
Maribeth was the best Airbnb host I have ever had! She made our stay incredibly special and gave us all sorts of great tips about things to explore in the neighborhood. The house is filled with wonderful little details and is so lovely that you don't feel like leaving it. I can't…

Hosted by Maribeth

Mattituck, New York, United StatesJoined in October 2014
Maribeth User Profile
157 Reviews
Maribeth is a SuperhostSuperhosts are experienced, highly rated hosts who are committed to providing great stays for guests.
Maribeth, a writer, married Tom, an artist, and we've been together for 29 years. Tom is a museum director on the East End, and I work at a local not-for-profit. Our home is casual and our life is full of friends and family, dogs and cats, books and paintings, films and music. …
Response rate: 89%
Response time: within an hour
Always communicate through AirbnbTo protect your payment, never transfer money or communicate outside of the Airbnb website or app.

The neighbourhood