Dining Room on the waterBeach

Entire home/flat

7 Guests

4 Bedrooms

5 Beds

Entire home/flat

7 Guests

4 Bedrooms

5 Beds

Please set the number of adults.
Please set the number of children.
Ages 2 - 12
Please set the number of infants.
Under 2
7 guests maximum. Infants don’t count toward the number of guests.
You won’t be charged yet
You won’t be charged yet

About this listing

Beautiful waterfront home, private beach, stunning sunsets, 4 BR, cooks kitchen, Steinway p

The space
Bathrooms: 2.5
Bedrooms: 4
Beds: 5
Check In: Anytime after 1PM
Check Out: 1PM
Room type: Entire home/flat


Extra people: £40 / night after 4 guests
Cleaning Fee: £121
Security Deposit: £804


The space

Double height living room, unique house, right on beach with amazing sunset views

Guest access

Bikes, beach, beach towels, linens, Steinway baby grand piano

The neighbourhood

Beautiful beaches and light. Great for bike riding. Peaceful.

Other things to note

No parties
No smoking
There is a separate building that is an art studio that is not part of the rental.

House Rules
No smoking
No parties or events
Check in is anytime after 1PM

This is our home, please treat it with care



Cancel up to 7 days before your trip and get a 50% refund plus service fees back.

Safety features
Fire extinguisher
Smoke detector

3 nights minimum stay

4 Reviews

Check In
Diana User Profile
August 2016
You cannot believe the location. You are not near the ocean, you are next to it! The views are astounding, and the sunsets amazing. In addition to being adjacent to the Bay (which you can walk into right out the kitchen door), the house has a lovely yard perfect for oceanside lawn games. It was a dreamy week.

Constance User Profile
July 2015
Paradise on the Beach is an accurate and appropriate name for this beautiful and spiritually rejuvenating home of two accomplished artists who live full time on Shelter Island. The sound of the waves lapping onto the beach provide a sense of auditory peace and tranquility. The reclaimed wood and farmhouse atmosphere set the tone of warmth and life. The whole house is filled with soul, character, and evidence of a life well-lived. If the owners open up their home to you, please consider it a privilege and an opportunity to share in the home and the life of a clearly extraordinary couple.
Margaret User Profile
Response from Margaret:
What a beautiful review! Thank you so much! We are so grateful to have had such thoughtful guests here- hope you can come again sometime.
July 2015

Our host Margaret was wonderful... very accommodating, answering all our various questions cheerfully and promptly. The house is very warm and inviting, very much a home that is lived in with lots of character and charm which we loved. The location is spectacular. The house has lots of windows with lovely views of the bay and beautiful neighborhood from every room. And plenty of room in the yard to chill or play. There are many beautiful places to walk to from the house but one does need to drive to get to any restaurants or shops. Because it's a couple of miles from town, it's quiet and peaceful during the day and night. We had a hard time leaving!

Leslie User Profile
July 2015
What a warm, wonderful house! It's a unique , open barn that is filled with the breeze of the ocean and beach around you. You feel like you are floating on the water from every room. Views from every room, all the amenities you could want, and a host that leaves your recommendations from where to view fireworks to which restaurants need reservations. Although we did not use it, our host even made her herb garden available to us! We used the bikes to explore the island and felt like we had it all to ourselves. Shelter island is a gem, and this house is the crown.
Margaret User Profile
Response from Margaret:
Thank you, Leslie! You guys were our first guests and set a great standard! Hope you will visit again sometime.
July 2015

Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States · Joined in April 2013
Margaret User Profile
Response rate: 80%
(past 90 days)
Response time: within a day

Exact location information is provided after a booking is confirmed.