Skip to content

Top store recommendations from locals

Bakery
$
“Its always packed because well it is that good. the line moves fast just be patient and you'll see. Best Coffee on this side. ”
  • 36 locals recommend
Market
“Round Swamp Farm is easily the most famous and visited Farm in The Hamptons and for good reason. Every piece of produce is fresh and delicious, but their fried chicken and chocolate chip cookies cannot be missed. It's reputation precedes it though so be prepared to be amongst a swam of visitors.”
  • 42 locals recommend
Coffee Shop
$$
“Want to drive over old Montauk highway and take a trip out to Amagansett for some coffee in a beautiful open town square? Grab a cup sit on a bench or enjoy a 10 minute walk down the road to the beach.”
  • 19 locals recommend
Coffee Shop
$$
“in case you have withdrawal and golden pear or Mary's Marvelous doesn't do it for you”
  • 6 locals recommend
Corner Shop
“A bit of a hike and better accessed by vehicle but new clean and with complete grocery assortment ”
  • 14 locals recommend
Corner Shop
“1 mile from house you can grab those essentials in a familiar large scale store”
  • 8 locals recommend
Bicycle Store
“The best bike shop ever... we will connect you and get you a deal on renting bike”
  • 6 locals recommend
Farmers Market
“There is a Balsam Farm Store in Montauk across the street from the 7/11, next door to the IGA _ amazing fresh produce and local products ”
  • 12 locals recommend
Grocery or Supermarket
“So close, Maidstone Market has a limited supply of essentials and a good deli.”
  • 8 locals recommend
Store
“Another good place for breakfast treats, sandwiches and take out salads. Pick up goodies here for a day at the beach.”
  • 5 locals recommend
Deli / Bodega
$
“Breakfast or lunch sandwiches to take to the beach or when you don't want to cook at home !”
  • 7 locals recommend
Restaurant
“Late night ice cream - and early morning fresh Dreesen's Donuts, made before your eyes and hot from the oven. Have a couple there and take home a dozen. Yum!”
  • 13 locals recommend
Bar
“Nordic cuisine in the heart of the Hamptons. Swedish meatballs are fantastic!”
  • 7 locals recommend
Grocery or Supermarket
“Walk to grocery store that has everything you could need and great prepared foods”
  • 6 locals recommend
Miscellaneous Shop
“Our local wine shop has a limited-but-great selection and a friendly staff. If they have the Wyatt Cabernet in stock, get it!”
  • 7 locals recommend
Health
“Wonderful to-go Breakfast Items Juice and Smoothies Gluten Free, Dairy Free, vegan Options ”
  • 8 locals recommend