Skip to content

Top cafe recommendations from locals

Pizza Place
$$
“Best restaurant in the neighborhood, one of the best restaurants in the city! Get the capacolla pizza or anything else; you can't go wrong! This place started small (and I was one of the first customers!) and now it takes up half the block! It's still good though and you'll agree: Saraghina is a great restaurant! ”
  • 623 locals recommend
Gourmet Shop
$$
“When visiting Flatiron building, this is a place to have some coffee or food :) I would not recommend restaurants inside, just grad some pizza or a sandwich..”
  • 354 locals recommend
Diner
$$
“Great diner. Fun scene. Outdoor seating Memorial Day through Indigenous Peoples Day. Not the usual fare.”
  • 193 locals recommend
Bakery
$$
“They do much more than sweets, but it's the sweets that you'll get in line for. There's wild Maine blueberry pancakes and caramelized banana French toast for breakfast, plus loads of pie, cake, and milkshakes. But, if you insist on eating real protein (as fans of the bakery did years ago, pushing the owners to expand to other meals), then you won't be disappointed. Go for the fried chicken!”
  • 245 locals recommend
Gift Shop
“A great maritime museum with lots of story telling and magnificent boats all shapes and sizes. A historical educational village that takes you back in time... A great family day trip!”
  • 70 locals recommend
Café
$
“Long time favorite coffee jaunt featuring Counter Culture coffee. Every oat milk latte is perfection. They serve breakfast and lunch all day long! Forget about working here cause they're always packed! Still love them though!”
  • 224 locals recommend
Café
$
“Jacobs Pillow offers a variety of open air dance, drumming and shows throughout the summer season.”
  • 96 locals recommend
Brewery
$$
“Great place to spend an afternoon. Their beer is sold all over New York State and this is a must-try for beer enthusiasts visiting the area. They serve food as well and there is always something going on there, whether it be ice skating in the winter or a concert in the summer. Definitely check this place out if you’re headed toward Cooperstown!”
  • 45 locals recommend
Ice Cream Shop
$$
“Their lines can be long but the ice cream sandwich on a fresh baked cookie is totally worth the wait”
  • 103 locals recommend
Diner
$$
“Old school NJ diner known for having amazing pancakes. Featured on the food network.”
  • 37 locals recommend
Bar
$$
“Live Music every night, most amazing cocktails and small bites. Check out their Gospel brunch on weekends!”
  • 157 locals recommend
Coffee Shop
$$
“Really, really delicious coffee. And in the summer, they brew the iced coffee for 16 hours. What?!”
  • 171 locals recommend
Mexican Restaurant
$$
“Sceney Mexican spot with no-frills taqueria, cafe & exclusive basement brasserie/tequila bar.”
  • 170 locals recommend
Breakfast Spot
$$
“ One of the neighborhood's most famous brunch spot, they serve simple but awesome egg dishes with ingredients that come from their own farm upstate. We recommend to get there before 12 / 12:30 to avoid the long lines.”
  • 141 locals recommend
Café
$$
“A great place to stop for breakfast! Absolutely love their Donuts prepared by Dough! ”
  • 131 locals recommend
New American Restaurant
$$$
“Grab a beer and and appetizer at the wonderful bar at sundown, while watching the Sawkill Creek roll under the deck. Then sit at a table in the main dining room, or on the deck in the summertime, and enjoy a romantic dining experience with great food. ”
  • 93 locals recommend