Skip to content
Show Map
Enter dates and number of guests to see the total price per night.

51 places to stay

Hotel room
Rating 5.0 out of 53 reviews
Fire Island Hotel and Resort, So Close - So Calm
2 guests · Studio · 1 bed · 1 private bathroom
Wifi · Pool
Entire loft
Rating 5.0 out of 59 reviews
NEW! Cozy Fire Island Studio - Steps to the Beach!
2 guests · Studio · 1 bed · 1 bathroom
Wifi
Hotel room
Fire Island Hotel and Resort - Best Kept Secret
4 guests · Studio · 2 beds · 1 private bathroom
Pool
SUPERHOST
Room in boutique hotel
Rating 4.86 out of 536 reviews
#19 - SeaShore Condo Motel
2 guests · 1 bedroom · 1 bed · 1 private bathroom
Wifi
Room in boutique hotel
Best Kept Secret on Fire Island
4 guests · 1 bedroom · 2 beds · 1 private bathroom
Wifi · Pool
Private room
Rating 4.78 out of 518 reviews
Fire Island Condo
2 guests · Studio · 1 bed · 1 private bathroom
Wifi
SUPERHOST
Room in boutique hotel
Rating 4.83 out of 512 reviews
#22 - SeaShore Condo Motel
3 guests · 1 bedroom · 1 bed · 1 bathroom
Wifi
SUPERHOST
Entire apartment
Rating 4.93 out of 570 reviews
Bay view Studio/Condo in Ocean Bay Park
2 guests · Studio · 1 bed · 1 bathroom
Wifi · Kitchen
SUPERHOST
Entire apartment
Rating 4.81 out of 532 reviews
Studio Condo Ocean Bay Park, FIRE ISLAND, NY
2 guests · 1 bedroom · 1 bed · 1 bathroom
Wifi
SUPERHOST
Entire cottage
Rating 4.77 out of 531 reviews
Seneca Surf Shack
5 guests · 1 bedroom · 2 beds · 1 bathroom
Pool · Kitchen
Entire apartment
Rating 4.60 out of 55 reviews
Beachy apartment in the heart of Ocean Bay Park - dogs welcome!
4 guests · 1 bedroom · 2 beds · 1 bathroom
Wifi · Kitchen
SUPERHOST
Room in boutique hotel
Rating 5.0 out of 519 reviews
Two Bedroom Suite - SeaShore Condo Motel
7 guests · 2 bedrooms · 2 beds · 1 bathroom
Wifi · Kitchen
Entire cottage
Rating 5.0 out of 513 reviews
Ocean Bay Park Fire Island
10 guests · 3 bedrooms · 9 beds · 2 bathrooms
Wifi · Kitchen
SUPERHOST
Entire house
Rating 5.0 out of 58 reviews
Beach Beach Cottage with Jacuzzi & Pool
12 guests · 4 bedrooms · 10 beds · 1.5 bathrooms
Wifi · Kitchen
Entire flat
Rating 4.96 out of 527 reviews
Seashore Condo Motel Unit 9
2 guests · Studio · 1 bed · 1 bathroom
Wifi · Kitchen
Entire house
Rating 5.0 out of 54 reviews
New pool/hot tub in a tranquil outdoor area w/ amazing master suite
10 guests · 3 bedrooms · 7 beds · 2 bathrooms
Wifi · Pool · Kitchen
Entire house
Rating 5.0 out of 53 reviews
LIFE'S A BREEZE AT THE BEACH - Sleep 16
16+ guests · 5 bedrooms · 16 beds · 3 bathrooms
Wifi · Kitchen
SUPERHOST
Entire house
Rating 5.0 out of 521 reviews
Villa Etoile - Fire Island Getaway!
6 guests · 3 bedrooms · 5 beds · 1.5 bathrooms
Wifi · Kitchen
118 of 51 Rentals
Enter dates to see full pricing. Additional fees apply. Taxes may be added. Free cancellation only applicable within 48 hours from booking.