Skip to content

Top bar recommendations from locals

Bar
$$$
“Fun live music venue. Gets really crowded on the weekends in the city. Week day show might be a better bet.”
  • 43 locals recommend
Pizza Place
$$$
“PIZZA & BEER! (And salad if you want balance) New Haven being known for the best pizza, this is one of my favorites. Super thin. Make a reservation or go during the week if you don’t want to wait! ”
  • 48 locals recommend
Caribbean Restaurant
$$
“Take a complimentary boat ride between Rumba and Cowfish for a unique dining or drinking experience”
  • 53 locals recommend
American Restaurant
$$
“The best restaurant for steaks! Absolutely delicious! Reservations accepted.”
  • 49 locals recommend
Seafood Restaurant
$$$
“Great location on the beach, perfect for a drink at happy hour or great seafood dinner. Right on the water. Sit inside or out. They also have an area for kids to keep them occupied :)”
  • 33 locals recommend
Seafood Restaurant
$$
“This and Bostwick's On the Harbor off Gann Road in Springs are def favorites for Seafood!!! The Harbor has incredibly beautiful sunsets and great happy hour specials. The Chowder House is casual and fun w extra delish seafood! Warning: ALWAYS CROWDED!”
  • 37 locals recommend
Seafood Restaurant
$$
“Better known as just "LUNCH" this is probably the most famous lobster roll in the Hamptons. 20 minute drive and sitting just off Montauk Highway, it's hard to find a better lunch than lunch.”
  • 37 locals recommend
Beach Bar
$$
“Awesome for dinner and/or drinks, there is also a small beach with lounge chairs.”
  • 29 locals recommend
Burger Restaurant
$$
“Love the burgers and brunch! Usually can get a table without much wait. Wonderful shakes. Great for families. Reasonable prices. ”
  • 25 locals recommend
Italian Restaurant
$$$
“Excellent Italian food right in the heart of the village on Newtown Lane. I've never had a bad meal here and the bar is really lively!”
  • 28 locals recommend
Hotel
“Classic Hamptons place for a drink on the porch with a view of the harbor. Fireplaces and great atmosphere in the bar. Year-round option.”
  • 23 locals recommend
French Restaurant
$$$
“Creative versions of French bistro classics & local seafood in a cozy space with a bakery up front.”
  • 28 locals recommend
Bar
$$
“Our favorite brunch spot in Sag Harbor and (in our opinion!) the best lobster roll in the Hamptons. On a nice day you can sit outside looking out over the Sag Harbor Marina.”
  • 28 locals recommend
Bar
$$
“Tappas. Wine. 50% bottles on sundays! Always a favorite, never disappoints! ”
  • 22 locals recommend
American Restaurant
$$$
“Vine Street Cafe is an excellent restaurant with an outstanding menu. The Food is excellent, and Staff is incredibly professional. ”
  • 21 locals recommend
Italian Restaurant
$$$
“Pricier options for those looking for 5-star flavor and quality. Tutto is definitely a special restaurant, offering some of the best-tasting food in the village.”
  • 22 locals recommend