Skip to content

Top bar recommendations from locals

Bar
“Callicoon Brewing Company started in the old Callicoon firehouse and has made its way to the historic Olympia Hotel diagonal from its origin. Fun...very local bar that the whole family can enjoy. Great place to take pictures from the porch!”
  • 32 locals recommend
Gastropub
$$
“A lovely little restaurant with occasional live music. Check in advance if reservations are needed.”
  • 26 locals recommend
Resort
“The Tavern is much the same now as it has been for the past 50 years. Guests will find friendly, warm and lively service and a menu that embraces comfortable accessibility and local ingredients including trout from our world famous rivers. There is a pool table, jukebox and spontaneous singing is encouraged. A deck just outside the sunroom offers cocktails and full tavern fare, weather permitting.”
  • 31 locals recommend
Bar
“Delicious Brick Oven Pizza, outdoor seating and beer garden overlooking white lake.”
  • 30 locals recommend
Bar
$$
“A charming restaurant that serves simple but elegant flare with a twist of local history. Live music on weekends and Live Jazz Brunch on Sundays.”
  • 30 locals recommend
Pub
$
“Great spot in Livingston Manor for excellent pizza, wings and cocktails. The outdoor area has a great bonfire and a gelato airstreamer!”
  • 28 locals recommend
Wine Bar
$$
“Amazing winery with delicious food and live music on the weekends! 9 miles away!”
  • 16 locals recommend
Distillery
“Great local distillery. You can do a tour, tasting and they have plenty of bottles for sale. Plus they have an outdoor bar and live music on the weekends. ”
  • 21 locals recommend
Bar
$$
“[BETHEL-approx. 15 min drive] Great food and an outstanding distillery conveniently located across the road from the Woodstock Museum. ”
  • 18 locals recommend
Bar
“Fresh, authentic Mexican food as well as fresh guacamole made before your eyes...need I say more. This place never fails...great food and fantastic service.”
  • 12 locals recommend
Wine Bar
$$
“Adgacent to Robins wine store is a fantastic little tapas bar that has great outdoor in the summertime. You can sample the 2 star Michelin chef's amazing array of tapas along with a great selection of wines to pair. ”
  • 23 locals recommend
Bar
“Farm to table gastropub with craft beer menu, featuring live music on select nights. Located in Hurleyville, NY, near the Sullivan County Historical Society. Casual. www.pickledowl.com”
  • 8 locals recommend
Bar
$$
“Great place for lowbrow fare done right. Lively bar is a popular hang out in winter months!”
  • 16 locals recommend
Bar
“A relic from pre-Civil War times, Rohman’s Inn + Pub is billed as one of the oldest dive bars with a manual 4 lane bowling alley. ”
  • 10 locals recommend
Restaurant
$$
“A great newer edition to the area. the boys at the Firehouse serve 7 days a week and have a staple menu that ranges in price. there is something for everyone. Great Cocktails too. Recommend the rice & Beans the s'mores and the Trout. oh the Mac and cheese too.”
  • 14 locals recommend
Bar
$$
“This is a great place to grab dinner after a long day of exploring the area.”
  • 10 locals recommend