Skip to content

Top cafe recommendations from locals

Bakery
$
“Its always packed because well it is that good. the line moves fast just be patient and you'll see. Best Coffee on this side. ”
  • 36 locals recommend
Bakery
$$
“Quaint cottage whipping up cakes, cookies & other baked goods, with vegan & gluten-free options.”
  • 30 locals recommend
Café
$$
“Mattituck (North Fork) Good spot for brunch and a change of vibe. Feels far, but only 25-30 minutes away. ”
  • 32 locals recommend
Coffee Shop
$$
“Want to drive over old Montauk highway and take a trip out to Amagansett for some coffee in a beautiful open town square? Grab a cup sit on a bench or enjoy a 10 minute walk down the road to the beach.”
  • 19 locals recommend
Coffee Shop
$$
“#1 Breakfast Item: Smoked salmon platter. The golden pear is a Hampton's favorite with an assortment of baked goods made fresh every day, organic coffee, and a great selection of hot foods and breakfast platters.”
  • 17 locals recommend
Café
$$
“Must eats : best lobster roll in the Hamptons (if you ask me), the mussel & clams dishes are also yummy”
  • 21 locals recommend
Café
$
“Excellent coffee, breakfast, lunch. Casual. Outside tables too. Right in the center of the village”
  • 19 locals recommend
American Restaurant
$
“Family owned luncheonette and old-fashioned soda fountain dishing up American classics and ice cream treats.”
  • 14 locals recommend
Café
$$
“Seattle's finest! Don't forget to set your mobile order location, it can get a bit hectic here!”
  • 5 locals recommend
Coffee Shop
$$
“in case you have withdrawal and golden pear or Mary's Marvelous doesn't do it for you”
  • 6 locals recommend
Coffee Shop
$$
“Just good coffee. They also make a mean pour over and have other locations. This is their smallest location and there other locations offer table service lunch or have really cool spaces; Watermill (lunch), Southampton and Aquebogue (Riverhead).”
  • 8 locals recommend
Donut Shop
$
“Start your day with a smooth cup of coffee and the best apple cider doughnut in the Hamptons at Grindstone. The shop is impossibly cool you'll be hard pressed to find a better coffee/doughnut combo.”
  • 12 locals recommend
Café
“Best breakfast in town. Highly recommend the Beso wrap or the heart and healthy wrap. Hidden gem in the heart of Hampton bays.”
  • 10 locals recommend
Café
$$
“The original Hampton Coffee location. One of my favorite places to go for brunch. Not only do they offer their own freshly brewed coffee (which is delicious), but they also have an extensive brunch menu with traditional options like omelets, french toast, pancakes, etc. and also a wide variety of Mexican style items like breakfast tacos, chips and guac, chorizo skillet, and much more. Whatever you get though, make sure it comes with home fries - I don't know what they do to them, but they are one of a kind.”
  • 8 locals recommend
Coffee Shop
$$
“High end cafe and take out spot. Baked goods, soups, sandwiches, salads and great tasting coffee ! Great place for a quick coffee and muffin !”
  • 7 locals recommend
Restaurant
$$
“Cafe, pastries, breakfast and lunch, friendly service, also found in Southampton, East Hampton, an Bridgehampton”
  • 10 locals recommend