Best Places to Eat
Our Favorite Restaurants
Most of the best places to eat on the island just happen to be with walking distance of our place. We hope you enjoy them as much as we do.
Probably the most liked, local's secret hangout on the island. FANTASTIC Margaritas and fresh Seafood and Mexican food. This is our go to place that is always a crowd pleaser. Be warned however. It is popular for good reason and lines can form quickly. Go early and take CASH; they do NOT take credit cards.
32 locals recommend
La Playa MEXICAN GRILLE
222 Beach StProbably the most liked, local's secret hangout on the island. FANTASTIC Margaritas and fresh Seafood and Mexican food. This is our go to place that is always a crowd pleaser. Be warned however. It is popular for good reason and lines can form quickly. Go early and take CASH; they do NOT take credit cards.
Tied for best romantic dinner. The history and ambiance are hard to beat. The well executed menu of traditional steakhouse and seafood is well worth the slightly higher prices.
10 locals recommend
Roosevelt's
200 E Cotter AveTied for best romantic dinner. The history and ambiance are hard to beat. The well executed menu of traditional steakhouse and seafood is well worth the slightly higher prices.
Winner of best new family friendly bar. They have a number of bar games that our kids loved. The small but well thought our selection of bar classics make it a cool place to hang out. Good music too!
21 locals recommend
Lelo's Island Bar
212 Beach StWinner of best new family friendly bar. They have a number of bar games that our kids loved. The small but well thought our selection of bar classics make it a cool place to hang out. Good music too!
Great Sushi! Legendary local master "Sushi - Dave" hand crafts deli shish unique sushi rolls. Check website for days and times
14 locals recommend
Blue Water Cowboy Saloon & Mercantile
229 Beach StreetGreat Sushi! Legendary local master "Sushi - Dave" hand crafts deli shish unique sushi rolls. Check website for days and times
Irie's Island Food
200 W Avenue GBest Sandwiches and Lunch. A local's favorite.
Coach’s island grill
505 Tarpon StBest Breakfast on the island