Skip to content

Stacey's Summer Guidebook

John

Stacey's Summer Guidebook

Restaurants on the water
Great food - served family style. Call for reservations.
31
locals recommend
Harvest On Fort Pond
11 South Emery Street
31
locals recommend
Great food - served family style. Call for reservations.
Great place for Lobster and watching the boats go out into the harbor.
29
locals recommend
Gosman's
500 West Lake Drive
29
locals recommend
Great place for Lobster and watching the boats go out into the harbor.
Great place for fresh fish and sushi, also has live music.
7
locals recommend
Westlake Fish House
352 W Lake Dr
7
locals recommend
Great place for fresh fish and sushi, also has live music.
Amazing sunsets, amazing food - call for reservations. Try to get a table on the beach if you can. Usually has live music on the weekends.
21
locals recommend
Navy Beach
16 Navy Road
21
locals recommend
Amazing sunsets, amazing food - call for reservations. Try to get a table on the beach if you can. Usually has live music on the weekends.
Amazing sunsets - great food. It is a scene. They don't' take reservations - first come first serve. It can be pricey. Some of the food is served family style.
29
locals recommend
Duryea's Lobster Deck
65 Tuthill Road
29
locals recommend
Amazing sunsets - great food. It is a scene. They don't' take reservations - first come first serve. It can be pricey. Some of the food is served family style.
Fun place to go and watch the party boats come in around 4:30 and see what everyone caught. Great drinks, fresh seafood, good sushi, great place for lobster.
10
locals recommend
Clam and Chowder House at Salivar's Dock
470 W Lake Dr
10
locals recommend
Fun place to go and watch the party boats come in around 4:30 and see what everyone caught. Great drinks, fresh seafood, good sushi, great place for lobster.
Fun place with a great drink menu. Also located on the docks, great live music in the weekends.
12
locals recommend
Swallow East
474 W Lake Dr
12
locals recommend
Fun place with a great drink menu. Also located on the docks, great live music in the weekends.
Located at star island , this new restaurant from gurneys is amazing. Specializing in locally sourced produce. Pictures don’t do the place justice. It’s a restaurant at a resort. It is a little pricey. Reservations only
Showfish
32 Star Island Road
Located at star island , this new restaurant from gurneys is amazing. Specializing in locally sourced produce. Pictures don’t do the place justice. It’s a restaurant at a resort. It is a little pricey. Reservations only
Amazing Italian food . Views are Incredible. This restaurant is located in a high end resort overlooking the ocean at Gurneys Inn. Make reservations
12
locals recommend
Scarpetta Beach
290 Old Montauk Hwy
12
locals recommend
Amazing Italian food . Views are Incredible. This restaurant is located in a high end resort overlooking the ocean at Gurneys Inn. Make reservations
Beautiful chic restaurant overlooking Montauk Lake. Menu specializes in locally sourced food. Call for reservations.
30
locals recommend
The Crow's Nest
4 Old West Lake Drive
30
locals recommend
Beautiful chic restaurant overlooking Montauk Lake. Menu specializes in locally sourced food. Call for reservations.
This is a local favorite. The sunsets are the best . Local pub style food or just go for the sunset . They often have live music
14
locals recommend
Montauket
88 Firestone Road
14
locals recommend
This is a local favorite. The sunsets are the best . Local pub style food or just go for the sunset . They often have live music
Food scene
6
locals recommend
South Edison
17 South Edison Street
6
locals recommend
Great food . Call for reservations
Muse @ The End
41 S Euclid Ave
Great food . Call for reservations
Pub style comfort food.
Shagwong
774 Montauk Highway
Pub style comfort food.
Local sports bar with great pub style food. The menu has something for everyone.
6
locals recommend
The Point Bar & Grill
697 Montauk Hwy
6
locals recommend
Local sports bar with great pub style food. The menu has something for everyone.
This is a local favorite. Try the mussels - they are the best! Great fresh seafood, pub style food. They don’t take reservations. Not very kid friendly.
17
locals recommend
The Dock Bar & Grill
482 West Lake Drive
17
locals recommend
This is a local favorite. Try the mussels - they are the best! Great fresh seafood, pub style food. They don’t take reservations. Not very kid friendly.
Great market for fresh fish , prepared foods and meats. They will prepare a lobster bake to go fully cooked with potatoes, mussels, clams and corn in the cob. Totally worth it! They also do BBQ to go. Call ahead and order to pick up.
11
locals recommend
Gosman's Retail Fish Market
484 West Lake Drive
11
locals recommend
Great market for fresh fish , prepared foods and meats. They will prepare a lobster bake to go fully cooked with potatoes, mussels, clams and corn in the cob. Totally worth it! They also do BBQ to go. Call ahead and order to pick up.
Great place to buy local produce
Balsam Farms Montauk Market
662 Montauk Hwy
Great place to buy local produce
Prepared foods
Round Swamp Farm
71 S Elmwood Ave
Prepared foods
The Montauk Farmers Market is every Thursday in the center of town on the green - great place to buy from local farmers, fresh fish and flowers and local cheeses.
Montauk Farmer's Market
The Montauk Farmers Market is every Thursday in the center of town on the green - great place to buy from local farmers, fresh fish and flowers and local cheeses.
Fast food seafood
18
locals recommend
Clam Bar At Napeague
2025 Montauk Highway
18
locals recommend
Fast food seafood
Sightseeing
No trip to Montauk is complete without visiting the lighthouse. Climbing to the top is not for everyone. The museum is very interesting. The views are incredible. You can walk around the lighthouse on the jetty in front too
86
locals recommend
Montauk Lighthouse Museum
2000 New York 27
86
locals recommend
No trip to Montauk is complete without visiting the lighthouse. Climbing to the top is not for everyone. The museum is very interesting. The views are incredible. You can walk around the lighthouse on the jetty in front too
If you want to day trip and see other towns nearby , sag harbor is an old whaling village. Great village to walk, shop, have lunch. It’s about a 40 minute drive from Montauk.
69
locals recommend
Sag Harbor
69
locals recommend
If you want to day trip and see other towns nearby , sag harbor is an old whaling village. Great village to walk, shop, have lunch. It’s about a 40 minute drive from Montauk.
If you want to do a sunset cruise on a catarmaran this is perfect. Bring a cooler if you want to bring wine and cheese, pack a sweatshirt if it gets a little cold. Call for reservations and availability.
Sailing Montauk's Catamaran Mon Tiki
59 Star Island Road
If you want to do a sunset cruise on a catarmaran this is perfect. Bring a cooler if you want to bring wine and cheese, pack a sweatshirt if it gets a little cold. Call for reservations and availability.
Fun thing to do if you are like adventure. The views from 500 ft and 1000 ft up are incredible. You can see all of Montauk. Call for availability. Kids can do this too.
Montauk Parasail
470 West Lake Drive
Fun thing to do if you are like adventure. The views from 500 ft and 1000 ft up are incredible. You can see all of Montauk. Call for availability. Kids can do this too.
This is such a fun thing to do. They have 1 1/2 hour beach rides or one hour trail rides. Ride through scenic county park trails to the beach with a guide. I recommend later in the day or in the morning when it isn't so hot. Must make a reservation. They also have pony rides for little kids.
11
locals recommend
Deep Hollow Ranch
1929 Montauk Highway
11
locals recommend
This is such a fun thing to do. They have 1 1/2 hour beach rides or one hour trail rides. Ride through scenic county park trails to the beach with a guide. I recommend later in the day or in the morning when it isn't so hot. Must make a reservation. They also have pony rides for little kids.
If you want to rent a boat for a day or afternoon to go fishing or sightsee around the harbor or lighthouse. They also have boats to rent if you would like to waterski or go tubing in the lake. This place also rents Jet skis. Call for availability.
Uihlein's Marina
444 West Lake Drive
If you want to rent a boat for a day or afternoon to go fishing or sightsee around the harbor or lighthouse. They also have boats to rent if you would like to waterski or go tubing in the lake. This place also rents Jet skis. Call for availability.
Mini Golf in the heart of Montauk on the water.
13
locals recommend
Puff & Putt Family Fun Center
659 Montauk Highway
13
locals recommend
Mini Golf in the heart of Montauk on the water.
Fun place to walk around and see the military bunkers from WW2. Great place to hike or bike ride and sightsee. The trails are beautiful.
Camp Hero
1898 Montauk Hwy
Fun place to walk around and see the military bunkers from WW2. Great place to hike or bike ride and sightsee. The trails are beautiful.
Local Coffee
Just opened in Montauk 2020. Great place for coffee.
Hampton Coffee Company
732 Montauk Highway
Just opened in Montauk 2020. Great place for coffee.
Great place for Coffee
Left Hand Coffee
83 S Elmwood Ave
Great place for Coffee
Ice cream parlors
Just opened 2020 but the docks. A great place for ice cream. They have a large vegan selection of ice creams as well.
Frozen Anchor
478 West Lake Drive
Just opened 2020 but the docks. A great place for ice cream. They have a large vegan selection of ice creams as well.
Homemade ice cream and burgers. Great fast food take out.
10
locals recommend
John's Drive-In
677 Montauk Highway
10
locals recommend
Homemade ice cream and burgers. Great fast food take out.
Homemade ice cream, vegan options, and coffee bar
Pink Frog Cafe
28 South Etna Avenue
Homemade ice cream, vegan options, and coffee bar
italian ices and ice cream
Ralph's Italian Ices & Ice Cream
8 South Etna Avenue
italian ices and ice cream
Spas
Deborah Thompson Day Spa
37 The Plaza
23
locals recommend
Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa
290 Old Montauk Highway
23
locals recommend
This is located in East Hampton. It is only a 25 minute drive from Montauk.
Naturopathica Holistic Health - East Hampton
74 Montauk Hwy
This is located in East Hampton. It is only a 25 minute drive from Montauk.
Pizza
Pizza Village
700 Montauk Highway
They deliver!
Best Pizza & Dive Bar
2095 Montauk Highway
They deliver!
Sausages Pizza & Pastabilities
781 Montauk Point State Parkway
Primavera Pizza
54 South Erie Avenue