Café
Stars Cafe
22 locals recommend,
Tips from locals
A Shelter Island Heights standby, Stars is locally-owned and has good sandwiches, coffee, and surprisingly good Mexican cuisine. Open til afternoon, it's also open year-round (including when Marie Eiffel is closed). Try the rugelach, mahi sandwich, and turkey avocado sandwich!
Enjoy an easy breakfast and a nice coffee from Stars. Our breakfast favorites are the Morning Burrito and the Devil’s Burrito.
Locals also recommend
Location
17 Grand Ave
Shelter Island Heights, NY