Café
Stars Cafe
22 locals recommend,
Tips from locals
Alexander
October 7, 2021
A Shelter Island Heights standby, Stars is locally-owned and has good sandwiches, coffee, and surprisingly good Mexican cuisine. Open til afternoon, it's also open year-round (including when Marie Eiffel is closed). Try the rugelach, mahi sandwich, and turkey avocado sandwich!
Suzette
August 5, 2020
Great coffee shop. Very local. I love the rice and beens and avocado.
Lidia
August 6, 2020
Enjoy an easy breakfast and a nice coffee from Stars. Our breakfast favorites are the Morning Burrito and the Devil’s Burrito.
Virginia
October 20, 2016
Good food and rockin' espresso drinks
Dawn
June 3, 2015
The best for breakfast burritos, hearty lunches and fab coffee. Not open for dinner. In town short walk from North Ferry.
Unique things to do nearby
Locals also recommend
Location
17 Grand Ave
Shelter Island Heights, NY