Supermarket

The Milk Pail

11 locals recommend,

Tips from locals

Vanessa
January 7, 2018
Possibly the best apples in all of New York. They also make delicious and fresh apple cider donuts.
Cybele
April 1, 2016
Local apples. Try to get the fresh apple cider donuts. Kids love to wash them being made.
Brittan
June 21, 2022
fresh veg & fruit along with local baked goods and small selection of prepared foods. run by a longtime local family.
Steve
May 26, 2020
Need local apples, cider wine etc... Stop here (Closed Tuesdays) for your fix on amazing food ready to go
Monika
June 24, 2021
Local shop serving the worlds best cookies. They also sell wine, veggies, ready made frozen meals, and have a food truck outside if you fancy stopping by for lunch.

Unique things to do nearby

Taste The Hamptons with Private Chef Nick
Taste The Hamptons with a Private Chef
Enjoy New York City and The Hamptons With Private Chef Will

Locals also recommend