Holiday rentals in Findlay

Game Room | Hot Tub | Fire Pit @ Lake Shelbyville

Sitting just one mile outside city limits & 2 minutes to Lake Shelbyville, is this beautifully appointed home waiting for guests to enjoy all of its amenities; pool table, fire pit, grilling area, corn hole set, and hot tub. Inside, nothing was held back when it came to decorating this home for a truly relaxing experience. All the amenities of home are here just waiting for you to arrive, relax, and enjoy. We are sure you will rest easy in this boutique style home located at Lake Shelbyville.

Elk Ridge

Come and enjoy yourself at Elk Ridge, the first B&B of Wildlife Manor! Located within Aikman Wildlife Adventure, we are home to over 240 animals. This retreat offers the scenery of wildlife inside or outdoors. You have the chance to see zebras, bison, camels, and much more! Elk and water buffalo love to take a swim in the pond that Elk Ridge overlooks as well. Enjoy the natural scenery in the evening around a firepit on the waterfront deck. This will be an overnight adventure you won't forget!

Ultimate Country Home!

The Hideaway at Lake Shelbyville LLC is a privately owned, secluded shed house. This house can accommodate multiple boats and trailers of any size. It is a perfect house for a weekend getaway or a weeks' vacation in the heart of Lake Shelbyville. This country home is only 2 miles from Lone Point, 2.8 miles for Coon Creek, and 6 miles for Eagle Creek Boat Launch. This amazing house also has a 4,800 sq ft shed with a pickle ball court, badminton, corn hole, basketball hoop, and much more.

Charming Victorian Getaway by Lake Shelbyville

Nestled just 1.6 miles from Lake Shelbyville, this restored Vintage Victorian is the perfect retreat for families and friends. With three cozy bedrooms, a full kitchen, and a relaxing patio overlooking an old brick road, it is made for unwinding and making memories. Shelbyville’s history, parks, shops, and scenic trails offer endless exploring. Located 116 miles from St. Louis and 209 miles from Chicago, this charming home blends comfort, character, and small-town beauty for every guest.

The Caboose on Mayberry

Welcome to our mid 1900s caboose TP&W 527 and step back in time. Unwind and relax as you settle into your retreat. Enjoy the view from the cupalo as you browse through one of the books on board, or sit at your dinette and enjoy a board game. Sit out back in one of the adirondack chairs around your own private fire pit and enjoy s'mores, or just a peaceful evening. The caboose has been completely renovated and many modern convienences added. You'll love this unique and romantic escape!

Lakefront Cottage • Dock, Kayaks, Fire Pit & Beach

Welcome! Imagine waking up ten steps from the water, kayak paddles already calling your name. The Lake House on Lake Sara puts you right at the edge of the lake — with four kayaks, a crackling fire pit, and a sunlit enclosed porch to come home to. The Lake House is located just a short walk to the Beach, Pinky’s , The Rusty Reel Bar (below Pinky’s) and The Marina. The beach offers a beautiful playground, pavilions, exercise equipment, pickleball courts and a frisbee golf course!

The Bin at No Bad Days farm

The Bin at No Bad Days farm is a newly constructed grain bin. As you walk in checkout the beautiful craftsmanship on the ceiling! There is a loft upstairs where you will find a king size bed. There is also an oversized chair that converts to a small bed as well. Main floor has a sofa sleeper for two. There is a kitchenette and full bath. We know you will enjoy the rustic look of this unique property. We are 5 minutes from Lithia Springs Marina and we have room to park a boat!

Down to Earth Findlay apartment

This upstairs apartment is located in downtown Findlay, the heart of Lake shelbyville. It’s within walking distance to tailwinds steak house, the winery, and the R&K one stop. Just minutes to Findlay marina or the Eagle Creek golf course. There is plenty of parking for a truck and boat across the alley from the apartment. The apartment has been renovated and has a that country charm. It’s a great place to stay while visit family or enjoying the surrounding lake and golf course

Charming Yellow House

This home is just 5 minutes from Lake Shelbyville and Findlay Marina! Whether you’re here to fish, boat, hunt, explore, or unwind, this adorable yellow house is your spot. 🍽️ Walk to the café, park, bait/gas station 1+ block 🥩 Dinner or drinks at the local steakhouse or the winery just 4 blocks 🛶 Boat-friendly with side street parking parking on East and South road **unfortunately we do not allow pets anymore **Jack and Jill bathroom shared between bedrooms

Eagle's Nest

Relax with the whole family or friends at this peaceful place to stay. This vacation rental can satisfy all of your outdoor and Lake Shelbyville adventures. Whether you are fishing, hunting, boating, hiking, or just wanting to get in the country to the outdoors, this is the place for you! Come spend a great weekend and enjoy our friendly village of Findlay which is only a 5 minute drive. We have a quaint downtown with restaurants and a winery.

The Findlay House

5 to 15 mins from boating, fishing, the beach and golfing. Findlay offers a great park /playground. The Findlay Fast Stop has bait/beer/snacks and gas. Tailwinds Steak House, & Rosie & Irl's BBQ offer good food/drink. The Dollar General is also at the edge of town. We are now able to accommodate boats and vehicles across the street in a fully rocked pull thru parking lot.Electric available across the street at house with extention cord...

Cottage on Lake Paradise

Welcome to Paradise Cottage nestled on Lake Paradise! Cozy and warm with wood finishes throughout. Includes three-tiered deck/patio, with the lowest level sitting over the water. Perfect for fishing (this lake hosts an annual fishing tournament), canoeing/kayaking, or just relaxing. Great for bird watching, with great blue herons, egrets, ducks, bald eagles, plovers, cormorants, woodpeckers and other species seen daily.