Holiday rentals in Lancaster

This cabin is in the perfect location.. private and peaceful. We had a wonderful time ice fishing on the lake right outside the cabin. The house had everything you could want and was super cozy with the fireplace. We’ll be back for sure!

We like to travel for vacation and this place by far is our favorite. We keep coming here for 5 years and hope to come again. It feels like home and exactly what we need when we’re away.

We loved staying at the Riverside Cottage. It was so peaceful and Lorraine and John were so lovely and accommodating. The soup that was made for us upon arrival was so delicious!

Absolutely loved the place very homey, beautiful views of Titus Mountain perfect for my family ski vacation. Denise is so responsive and flexible. We will definitely rent again when we need to stay in Malone NY.

Loved our stay at this cute little cottage! The views were stunning—perfect for morning coffee or just relaxing at the end of the day. The place was super cozy and had everything we needed. Andrea was really responsive and made everything easy. Would totally come back! The views from the living room were amazing. We watched the ducks and geese swim by all while sitting on the couch.

Third stay at Butternut Bay, and it truly does feel like a home away from home. We have such special family memories because of Butternut Bay and its owner, first Jeanne, and now Meagan who is continuing her legacy--and it really does feel like that. Meagan cares that your time at Butternut is one you will remember. We thoroughly enjoyed her sharing of the St Lawrence Seaway map online, so we were able to track and learn more about the ships that were passing, day and night! Looking forward to our next stay, and more amazing family moments. Thank you Meagan!

Wonderful cottage. The property and layout was perfect for our family group of 10. Thanks again :)

Josée is an amazing host, accommodating, responsive, and extremely welcoming. She came to visit us when we arrived to introduce us to the place and tell us about her history. She took the time to explain everything clearly and answer our questions. ☺️ The cottage is absolutely beautiful, fully equipped, spacious, warm and very comfortable. We were 11 people for the party to my boyfriend and we had a nice time with friends to be able to enjoy the different advantages of the accommodation: spa, fire pit, magnificent river view, board games, etc. I highly recommend visiting this place, it is extremely clean and we feel all the love put into the details to make the cottage a friendly and welcoming place for its visitors. Thank you Josée for the beautiful welcome and the beautiful memories that were created within your haven of peace. ❤️ PS: We will be bored of the beautiful Nino!!! 🐈

We loved David's home and felt at home during our stay. The area is beautiful, peaceful, and quiet. We felt the hosts were responsive, accessible, and helpful. The home is clean, comfortable, and cozy. We would definitely stay again!