Island holiday rentals in New York

Find and book unique island rentals on Airbnb

Top-rated island rentals in New York

Guests agree: these island rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Top guest favourite
A cozy interior features a spacious bed with a textured blanket, surrounded by framed artwork and plants. A wooden dining table is positioned nearby. Large glass doors allow natural light to fill the space, providing views of the surrounding greenery.
Tiny home in Brantingham
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 87 reviews

Stabbin Cabin #2 on Grant Island-HotTub,Boat,Pets

The Stabbin Cabin #2 was created with couples in mind & featured on ABC. Here's some of the reasons why: * Island Life experience * Dogs can run free * Electric Boat * Great Fishing * Steamy HotTub * Large Screen TV w/Stereo * Guitar Hero Setup * Private Balcony w/ BBQ Grill * Fast Wifi * 420 Friendly * 20% off Vehicle rentals: ATV, Jetski, Pontoon Boat, Kayaks, SUPs * Beautiful Bathroom & Shower * Beach Area with Diving Board, FirePit & Beach Toys * Memories for a lifetime * IG: @grantisland

Top guest favourite
A wooden dock extends over calm waters, bordered by lush greenery. Two Adirondack chairs sit on the deck, accompanied by small potted plants. A rowboat is moored nearby, reflecting the serene landscape of trees lining the opposite shore.
Yurt in Greig
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 32 reviews

Island Glamping w/ Boat, HotTub and Pet Friendly

Last chance before we close — 2-Night Finale Deal ends Nov 10. Get ready for the world's ultimate glamping experience on Grant Island, Brantingham Lake featured on ABC. Heres some reasons why: * Electric Boat & Freedom to explore * Dogs can run free * Romantic Lighting * HotTub * Private Balcony w/ BBQ Grill * Wifi * 420 Friendly * 20% off Vehicle rentals: ATV, Jetski, Pontoon Boat, Kayaks * Large Screen TV * Beautiful Bathroom & Shower * Great Fishing * Beach Area-Diving Board & Fire Pit

Superhost
A wooden dock extends over a tranquil lake, with a silhouette of trees visible in the distance. Morning mist rises gently from the water's surface, and a rustic chair invites peaceful contemplation.
Home in Greig
4.85 out of 5 average rating, 20 reviews

Island Waterfront w/Pontoon boat, HotTub, Dogs Lv!

Get cast away on Grant Island with up to 8 friends/family and give your family pets the freedom to run free all day. With your own private pontoon boat included, you'll have the freedom to come and go whenever you please. Use it to explore Brantingham Lakes magnificent natural environment, go fishing, birdwatching or sit in the middle of the lake stargazing our amazing dark skies. Next, hop in the hot tub and grab a drink, and later, make some smores for a lakeside camp fire. Come visit!

Guest favourite
The exterior of Mrs. Otis cabin is showcased, featuring a rustic green facade framed by tall trees. Natural light filters through the branches, casting soft shadows on the nearby grassy area. A stone chimney adds a traditional touch, complementing the surrounding woodland.
Cabin in Paul Smiths
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 24 reviews

Mrs. Otis's Cabin with Woodland View

In the tradition of the Adirondack Great Camps - magnificent rustic compounds of comfort built a century ago by the rich and powerful on wilderness estates. White Pine Camp offers a year round restful retreat in unparalleled natural surroundings. Here, in the heart of the Adirondacks the largest protected wilderness in the continental United States, guests receive the key to peace and tranquility, a place to recharge the spirit. As a guest, you have your choice of 13 distinctive cabins

Top guest favourite
Bungalow in Greig
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 127 reviews

The Stabbin Cabin Grant Island w/Boat, HotTub, Pet

Last chance to stay on Grant Island before we close — 2-Night Finale Deal ends Nov 10. The Stabbin Cabin is a unique private bungalow on Grant Island, Brantingham Lake featured on ABC & Buzzfeed. Heres Why * Experience Island Life * Dogs can run free * Steamy HotTub * Electric Boat Included * Great Fishing * Beach Area with Diving Board * Beautiful Bathroom and Shower * 20% off Jetski, Boat and ATV rentals * BBQ grill & utensils * Fast Wifi * TV with Roku (Netflix) * 420 friendly

Guest favourite
A gazebo is illuminated by string lights, providing a warm ambiance over a wooden table with several stools. The tranquil lake reflects the evening sky, while gentle hills and trees frame the serene water view, enhancing the outdoor experience.
Island in Pine Plains
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 94 reviews

Private Island on Twin Island Lake

Embark on an off-grid luxury glamping adventure in the heart of Hudson Valley, discover one of Twin Island Lake’s private island with 360 degree views.. Reconnect with yourselves and nature in a Safari style tent furnished with a queen size bed. 13x10 gazebo with outdoor kitchen amenities. Park on the mainland next to the dock where a canoe awaits your arrival. This sweet escape is a once in a lifetime experience you will remember forever.

An aerial view reveals a tranquil island surrounded by calm waters. Lush green trees and rocky shorelines create a natural setting. Two structures are visible, one with a red roof and the other with light walls, offering a peaceful retreat in a scenic landscape.
Guest suite in Redwood

Outback Cottage Located on Island-Goose Bay!

Boaters, fish enthusiasts, & adventurers are all welcomed here at the Wintergreen Isle cottages! Enjoy a beautiful and relaxing scenery with this 2 bedroom & 1 bath private cottage w/ porch, BBQ grill, fire pit, & outdoor activities. Kitchen and kitchenware is available for your use. Must have a boat if you plan to rent as you will need to use it to cross from the mainland to your private getaway (dock space & parking included)!

Guest favourite
A modern seating area features a glass fire table with flames visible above sparkling glass stones. Two glasses stand on the table. The background showcases a serene view of the water and distant islands under a cloudy sky.
Cottage in Fishers Landing
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 62 reviews

Private Island & Pet Friendly ~ The Sea Angell

The Sea Angell is a 1.2 acre PRIVATE ISLAND (just you will be on it). There is DEEP water docking, electricity, modern plumbing, WiFi, and great cell service. And, yes … this property is dog friendly! The island is very easy to find, located just offshore in a prime location near Foxy’s Restaurant, and has a charming vintage cottage dating back to the 1870’s!

Top guest favourite
The waterfront apartment is visible from the dock, surrounded by lush greenery. A spacious deck spans the upper level, offering ample outdoor seating. The blue sky and sunlight reflect off the water, enhancing the serene atmosphere of the setting.
Home in Riverhead
5 out of 5 average rating, 16 reviews

Bayside Bliss - 2bdrm Lower-level Apartment

Escape to the serene beauty of Long Island's East End with our charming 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom waterfront apartment, nestled perfectly between the North and South Forks. This idyllic retreat offers guests a unique opportunity to experience the best of both worlds – the tranquil beauty of Reeves Bay and the vibrant culture of the Hamptons.

Superhost
Home in Southold
5 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews

Shorecrest Beach House + Beach Front + Ocean views

Located on a bluff overlooking the Long Island Sound with it's own beach, stunning sunsets and panoramic water views, this newly renovated, spacious house offers a tranquil getaway in bucolic Southold on the North Fork of Long Island's Wine and Farming Country.

Guest favourite
Guest house in Shelter Island
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 27 reviews

Sleek and Chic cottage/Pool House

Unwind from the city craziness in our pool house cottage, take advantage of the nature around you being surrunded with beutiful specimen and fruit trees.

Popular amenities for island rentals in New York

Destinations to explore