Holiday rentals in Reserve

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Reserve

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top guest favourite
A rustic cabin entrance is highlighted by a wooden deck, featuring a small table with four chairs and a grill nearby. A welcoming sign stands adjacent to the door, framed by landscape views of surrounding trees and hills.
Home in Reserve
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 212 reviews

Prod O Lodging Reserve NM Jed & Raine Paulk

This cabin is conveniently located in the Gila Forest, 3 miles North of Reserve on Hwy 12 between New Mexico Game Management Units 16D and 15. We are ½ a mile NE of Eagle Point Lookout turnoff off Hwy 12 (GMU 16D) and 2.1 miles South of Torette Lake RD turnoff on Hwy 12 (GMU 15). In addition, Reserve Sportman’s Club shooting range is 1.7 miles (road travel) from the cabin. If needed, there is plenty of space on the property to shoot your bow (bring your own targets). Hiking,Fishing,Exploring

Top guest favourite
A modest guesthouse is nestled in a scenic landscape, surrounded by rolling hills and open fields. Two large trees provide shade beside the entrance, while a patio area is visible, offering a space to enjoy the outdoors. The sky is bright with fluffy clouds.
Guest house in Reserve
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 177 reviews

Frisco Valley Farmhouse

Come Enjoy our Farm! Set in the Lower Frisco Valley south of Reserve you can enjoy the beautiful Gila National Forest and still be close to town and all its charming amenities. Our 2 bed/ 1 bath guesthouse is located on our working farm. Enjoy your morning coffee on the porch & breath in the fresh air and the green fields around you. Watch the grazing sheep in the field. While we love animals, and the farm cats may come greet you on the porch, we do have a NO PETS policy for the farmhouse.

Top guest favourite
A vast expanse of a starry night sky is framed by the intricate structure of a large, circular framework. Numerous stars are visible, creating a stunning backdrop of deep blues and twinkling lights, suggesting a tranquil atmosphere in a remote setting.
Guest house in Glenwood
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 392 reviews

Behr Art - Cozy Cabin with a Hot Tub

A perfect place to relax, recharge and reconnect. The Cabin is tucked away on an animal rescue sanctuary.There are ponds, shade trees, an orchard and flowering plants. The night sky is very dark, the water is sweet, WiFi is fast, a Verizon tower is close, the Cosmic Campground is up the road a bit & the Catwalk Recreational Trail is 4.5 miles from here. Indulge in the quiet, walk the Labyrinth, lounge in a hammock, visit the animals. Galleries, Art, Curiosities, Shrines & Sculptures are abundant

Top guest favourite
The cabin is nestled within a lush green meadow, surrounded by pine forests. Its wooden exterior features a sloped roof, and large windows reflect the natural landscape. Fenced areas and trees dot the foreground, enhancing the serene country setting.
Home in Aragon
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 36 reviews

Aragon Hunting Lodge

A hunter's paradise in NM Elk Hunting Unit 16D. This 1,680 square foot cabin built from 12-inch logs sleeps up to 9. The ambiance is fascinating - fabulous views through large windows across green meadows and pine forests. From 10x40 covered porch listen to the Tularosa Creek running by the cabin year-round. A great quiet get-away where you can almost touch the stars and may see elk walking outside the window. There is wildlife and nature everywhere with direct access to the Gila Wilderness.

Superhost
Home in Reserve
5 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews

San Fran Cottage

This charming and simple cottage offers a comfortable stay for outdoor enthusiasts and solitude seekers alike. Surrounded by untouched nature, you’ll wake up to the sound of birds and may spot deer, elk, or even the occasional wild turkey right outside your door. We’re located in a very rural area, so if you’re looking to disconnect from the busy world and reconnect with nature, this is the place for you. We are a 2 night minimum Due to abundant wildlife we highly recommend arriving before dark

Top guest favourite
A quaint cabin is nestled among tall pine trees, featuring a welcoming entrance with a set of stairs leading up to a porch. The wooden exterior reflects a natural warmth, with logs stacked nearby for a cozy fire.
Cabin in Greer
4.89 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews

Maxwell's Rustic Cabin Get-Away

This delightful 600 sq. ft. cabin built in 1954 has 2 bedrooms, 1 bath, and situated on 3/4 acres with nature’s beauty at your doorstep. This cozy Get-Away is secluded with limited traffic on the road. Enjoy a peaceful night sleep atop pillow top firm mattress and sheets where thread count matters. Wake up to serene views as you sip on your morning coffee. The cabin is furnished with a Home Away from Home feel with original knotty pine wood throughout. We hope you enjoy our slice of heaven!

Top guest favourite
A rustic cabin is illuminated in soft light, nestled among pine trees. A welcoming porch features several wooden chairs arranged in a semi-circle, while warm light spills from the entrance, creating a serene ambiance. Lanterns are positioned on the ground, enhancing the outdoor space.
Cabin in Luna
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 74 reviews

Jesse James Hideout / Rock-Hound Paradise

Make your escape to this hideaway on the New Mexico-Arizona border – rich in Western history and surrounded by National Forest land. Whether you're seeking solitude or to explore the backcountry of the White Mountains, this is your perfect base camp. You may even find some of Jesse's loot hidden in the hills! It's perfect for hunters, star-gazers, and is a rock-hound's paradise!. Starlink internet. Property is 150 acres of private land and butts up to Nat'l Forest. The hiking is amazing!

Top guest favourite
The exterior of the charming house features a light-colored façade with a decorative silhouette of an ostrich. A sloped roof in green contrasts with the clear blue sky. A small set of steps leads to the front door, surrounded by a gravel area.
Home in Eagar
5 out of 5 average rating, 238 reviews

The Ostrich House! Cozy, comfortable and private

Relax and enjoy our charming little house that was once used in our ostrich business. A big smart TV, great Wi-Fi, a nice comfortable king size bed and plenty of peace and quiet, make it a great place to stay. The big sectional couch can sleep a couple of kids (bedding is provided) if you want to bring them along. Come enjoy our beautiful White Mountains where there are trails to hike, great fishing, & snow skiing only 20 minutes away. We also have horse boarding available with booking.

Guest favourite
A shaded porch area features two wooden chairs positioned around a small table. A grill is placed nearby, with lush green hills visible in the background. Potted plants add a touch of greenery to the space, creating an inviting outdoor setting.
Earthen home in Reserve
4.88 out of 5 average rating, 195 reviews

Eagle Peak Lodging

This quintessential adobe New Mexico barn was renovated for an earthy experience. The casita is 1/3 of the full length barn. Accommodates from 2-4 in the heart of the Gila National Forest. Hike, horseback, hunting with your senses, a camera or a gun . . . whatever your pleasure! Very Private! Please be aware that earthen structures have "earthy" experiences like dust; insects at times; and earthy smells. Not likely to be your "cup of tea" if a cobweb is alarming to you.

Guest favourite
A modern tiny home is surrounded by tall Ponderosa pines, showcasing a welcoming entrance with orange steps. The home features large windows and a red awning. A double deck is visible, with seating and an American flag proudly displayed.
Tiny home in Alpine
4.83 out of 5 average rating, 234 reviews

Elk Meadow Tiny Home

Enjoy a private, peaceful spot in our newer Tiny Home. Views from every window and a Double deck to enjoy views! We have upgraded from an RV to Tiny Home. We have full electric, water, sewer and you have your own driveway. Cell service is good as well. This spot with majestic meadow mountain views and big Ponderosa pines. Fire pit and amazing clear skies for star gazing. Markets & restaurants close by . Luna Lake for fishing. Close to the Gila National forest with trophy Elk. .

Guest favourite
A spacious cabin is viewed from the front yard, featuring a wooden deck and stairs leading to the entrance. Mature trees provide some shade, while a stone border outlines the gravel pathway. The area is tranquil, surrounded by natural landscaping.
Cabin in Quemado
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 104 reviews

Quemado Lake, Unit 15, rural home.

800 Sq. Ft. cabin in gated National Forest community, 1 mile from Quemado Lake. A water tank behind the home attracts elk some evenings. The bedroom features a dual-adjustable King-Size mattress, fitted with Giza Dreams sheets, and a comfortable sleeper sofa in the common area. "City" water, dishwasher, washer & dryer, 700 Sq. Ft. dog run and 500 Sq. Ft. deck. Comfortably furnished, with lots of windows and a sliding door to the deck. Keyless entry. FedEx and UPS delivery.

Top guest favourite
A rustic cabin showcases a wooden exterior with a metal roof, surrounded by a grassy area. A cozy porch with steps leads to the front entrance, framed by a planter. The backdrop features distant trees and a clear blue sky.
Cabin in Greer
4.91 out of 5 average rating, 293 reviews

White Mountain Lodge Cabin #3

Perfect for a Honeymoon, Anniversary, Friends Trip, or just a relaxing vacation for a small family! Our cabin is a cozy 1 bedroom, 75 feet from the Little Colorado river, conveniently located on the Greer Walkway, and within easy walking distance of the 2 restaurants in town. Comfortable & cute décor, with fully equipped kitchen, WiFi, Dish TV, fireplace, and a jetted tub in the living room! We stay here regularly ourselves, & are glad to share our vacation home with you!

Popular amenities for Reserve holiday rentals

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. New Mexico
  4. Catron County
  5. Reserve