Guidebook for Shelter Island Heights

Prima
Guidebook for Shelter Island Heights

Food Scene

A restaurant in Shelter Island public golf course. The master chef Tom Ritzler is a native of Shelter island with more than 20 years experience. Delectable American cuisine enjoyed in the midst of the beautiful Shelter island scenery. Attire can be casual and atmosphere is very relaxed.
The Flying Goat Restaurant
26 Sunnyside Avenue
A restaurant in Shelter Island public golf course. The master chef Tom Ritzler is a native of Shelter island with more than 20 years experience. Delectable American cuisine enjoyed in the midst of the beautiful Shelter island scenery. Attire can be casual and atmosphere is very relaxed.
Delicious pastries, to go sandwiches, take out fine cuisines, organic food, a little pricey.
41 locals recommend
Marie Eiffel Market
184 N Ferry Rd
41 locals recommend
Delicious pastries, to go sandwiches, take out fine cuisines, organic food, a little pricey.
Fine dining, excellent host Jimi Rando
16 locals recommend
18 Bay
11 N Ferry Rd
16 locals recommend
Fine dining, excellent host Jimi Rando
22 locals recommend
Commander Cody's Seafood
41 Smith St
22 locals recommend
22 locals recommend
Stars Cafe
17 Grand Ave
22 locals recommend
16 locals recommend
Maria's Kitchen
55 N Ferry Rd
16 locals recommend
The beautiful Crescent beach is right in front of the hotel. Great views.
17 locals recommend
The Pridwin
81 Shore Rd
17 locals recommend
The beautiful Crescent beach is right in front of the hotel. Great views.
19 locals recommend
Ram's Head Inn
108 S Ram Island Dr
19 locals recommend

Drinks & Nightlife

They serve anything. Beautiful people, beautiful place. Early bird or late night dinner. For the young and adult.
34 locals recommend
SALT Waterfront Bar & Grill
63 S Menantic Rd
34 locals recommend
They serve anything. Beautiful people, beautiful place. Early bird or late night dinner. For the young and adult.
10 locals recommend
Isola
15 Grand Ave
10 locals recommend
93 locals recommend
Sunset Beach
Shore Rd
93 locals recommend

Arts & Culture

18 locals recommend
Shelter Island Historical Society
16 S Ferry Rd
18 locals recommend

Essentials

The only supermarket in Shelter Island. Can not compare from anywhere else. It is in an island but equipped with almost everything you need.
28 locals recommend
IGA Shelter Island
75 N Ferry Rd
28 locals recommend
The only supermarket in Shelter Island. Can not compare from anywhere else. It is in an island but equipped with almost everything you need.

Swim and relax

Beach for the whole family. Picnic tables available for public use with restrooms and lifeguard in duty.
12 locals recommend
Wades Beach
114 S Midway Rd
12 locals recommend
Beach for the whole family. Picnic tables available for public use with restrooms and lifeguard in duty.
A 10-minute walk to and from the house. Away from the busy Sunset Beach.
Menhaden Lane Beach
Menhaden Lane
A 10-minute walk to and from the house. Away from the busy Sunset Beach.
hotel and restaurant nearby
93 locals recommend
Sunset Beach
Shore Rd
93 locals recommend
hotel and restaurant nearby

Sightseeing

Includes a 3-mile, 5-mile or whatever trail distance you prefer. A place for hikers and nature lovers.
70 locals recommend
Mashomack Preserve
79 S Ferry Rd
70 locals recommend
Includes a 3-mile, 5-mile or whatever trail distance you prefer. A place for hikers and nature lovers.

Historical building, Educational Farm

Interested about the sugar plantation in the 1600’s
18 locals recommend
Sylvester Manor Educational Farm
80 N Ferry Rd
18 locals recommend