Holiday rentals in Sylvan Lake

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Sylvan Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Top guest favourite

An L-shaped pier extends over calm waters, leading towards a grassy island with scattered trees. Sunlight filters through the foliage, casting soft shadows on the wooden walkway. Boats are tied at the dock, enhancing the serene lakeside scene.

Home in Rome City

5 out of 5 average rating, 22 reviews

Upscale Lakeside Oasis – Private Island & Hot Tub

Experience Hilltop Haven on Sylvan Lake—an upscale luxury lakefront retreat where families reconnect and friends celebrate life by the water. Perfect for getaways, reunions, and special occasions, this spacious 5BR home features a private island, large pier, indoor hot tub, chef’s kitchen, game room w/pool table, TV room, & a wraparound deck w/grill for lakeview dining. Enjoy the kayaks, SUPs, fire pit, bikes, and basketball hoop for endless fun. Relax, play, and make memories at Hilltop Haven!

Top guest favourite

The exterior of the cabin features a rustic wooden facade with white horizontal stripes. Green window shutters frame four windows, contributing to a charming and inviting appearance. A covered porch supported by wooden beams offers a welcoming entryway.

Cabin in Shipshewana

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 449 reviews

Log Cabin

Are you looking for a quiet, relaxing and peaceful place to stay? Look no further, this little cabin is all that and more! These pictures do not do the cabin justice, we have heard this from so many guests that have stayed at our cabin! You will not be disappointed with your stay at our cabin. The kitchen is equipped with a stove, microwave, refrigerator and dishwasher. A front and back porch with beautiful views to drink a cup of coffee, read a book or relax! We hope you will come stay soon!

Guest favourite

A hot tub is positioned on a wooden deck, overlooking a serene lake at dusk. String lights are draped above, casting a warm glow. Reflections of trees and a dock are visible on the calm water's surface, enhancing the tranquil atmosphere.

Home in Bronson

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 355 reviews

Lake house with swimming and kayaks

*Lakeside Luxury Awaits: Your Tranquil Escape* Immerse yourself in the serenity of lakeside living at this stunning retreat, perfectly positioned just 10 minutes from the natural beauty of Pokehagen State Park. This 3-bedroom haven offers an unparalleled escape for families and friends seeking relaxation and adventure. Wake up to breathtaking lake views from almost every room. The sunroom beckons with its cozy ambiance, ideal for enjoying your morning coffee or losing yourself in a good book.

Superhost

A modern kitchen is visible, featuring stainless steel appliances and a spacious island. Adjacent, a cozy seating area is presented with a gray sofa, a light-colored rug, and a small dining table with two chairs. Natural light streams through large windows, enhancing the inviting atmosphere.

Home in Rome City

4.75 out of 5 average rating, 48 reviews

Sylvan Lakeside Retreat

Welcome to Sylvan Lake, Rome City IN! This 3 bed 1 bath home was completely remodeled in 2024 on one of Indiana's favorite all sports lakes. Whether you're in town for a family retreat, celebrating a special occasion, or need a peaceful place to stay while traveling for work, this lakefront home offers the perfect setting to unwind after a day of adventures. Full grocery, lakeside pubs, liquor & bait along with the public boat launch just blocks away. Boat rental also available upon request.

Guest favourite

Cabin in Warsaw

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 149 reviews

Romantic A-frame · HeartJacuzzi · Firepit · Kayaks

Peaceful channel-front A-frame cabin on Barbee Chain of 7 lakes! This cozy retreat features a charming, rustic interior, fully stocked kitchen, and heart-shaped jacuzzi. You'll love stargazing or drinking morning coffee on your spacious deck with gas firepit and gas grill. Unwind by the cozy fireplace, kayak and fish on the Barbee Chain of 7 lakes, and make s’mores by the waterside firepit! Minutes from boat launch. Book now for unforgettable memories in this intimate, picturesque getaway!

Top guest favourite

A modern guest house features a striking black exterior contrasted by natural wood detailing. Large windows allow ample light to filter in, while surrounding greenery and trees provide a tranquil environment. A covered porch extends from the side, adding to the outdoor living space.

Tiny home in Middlebury

5 out of 5 average rating, 44 reviews

Amen Corner - A Modern Retreat in Amish Country

Welcome to this brand new private guest house in Middlebury, Indiana tucked quietly away in the heart of Amish country. Amen Corner offers the best of both worlds…modern amenities surrounded by nature’s beauty and amazing sunsets. - Enjoy a beverage on the back patio while watching birds or the neighboring horses - Cuddle up for your favorite series inside with bedroom & living room fireplaces - Peace and quiet can be found also if you’re looking to just relax and walk some of our trails

Top guest favourite

A welcoming entry features a set of stairs leading up to the cottage, flanked by white railings. A decorative American flag is displayed on the front porch, surrounded by landscaped areas with pebbled ground and greenery.

Cottage in Rome City

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 262 reviews

Lakeside Sylvan-Lake Rome City Cottage

Welcome to Sylvan Lake in Rome City, IN. Sylvan Lake is an all season ski lake wonderful for all boating, fishing, skiing, tubing, wave runners and even a swim from the dock. You have 60 feet of lake front with two docks to bring your lake toys or rent a pontoon for the day/weekend or week. Full size kitchen, laundry, two big smart tv's with cable and wifi. Small shed for storage, large deck, canoe for 3, fire pit & gas grill. Wedding, family, golfing or weekend away? Lakeside Sylvan!

Guest favourite

A bright living room features large windows providing views of the lake. A light gray sofa and a comfortable armchair are arranged around a decorative area rug. A ceiling fan adds a cooling touch and a door leads to an outdoor deck.

Home in Rome City

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 47 reviews

3 BR Sylvan Lakefront Oasis

Relax with the whole family at this peaceful place to stay. Enjoy the 3 BR 1.5 Bath lake front retreat. Bring your boat and enjoy sylvan lake, a 700 acre sport lake wonderful for all boating, fishing, skiing and tubing. Kick back and relax in this open, stylish space and enjoy the elevated decks & lounge areas. All bedrooms and dedicated work space are on the second level providing quiet privacy. Includes: Washer & Dryer, Gas Grill, Fire-pit! Plenty of parking available!

Top guest favourite

A serene lakeside view is presented at dusk, featuring calm water reflecting soft colors of the sunset. A fire pit is positioned on a grassy area adjacent to the water, while a wooden dock extends into the lake, perfect for leisure activities.

Cottage in Albion

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 147 reviews

Beautiful Skinner Lake View Cottage

Private vacation home with a beautiful view of Lake Skinner. Waterfront access for fishing or taking the paddle boat out (seasonal). This cottage has all the basic amenities to make your stay comfortable. From the warm fire place to the spacious deck and 3 seasons room, you can enjoy this place anytime of the year. The full kitchen makes this place perfect for a week long getaway! A short twenty minute drive to Auburn and under an hour drive to Fort Wayne and Shipshewana.

Top guest favourite

Tiny home in Shipshewana

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 205 reviews

Private Lake+Fire Pit+Sauna+Kayaks | Pine & Paddle

Welcome to Pine and Paddle — the perfect place to unplug, recharge, and reconnect with nature by the lake. Unwind at this cozy lakeside tiny home, perfect for couples, friends, or solo travelers seeking peace, nature, and a hint of adventure near downtown Shipshewana. 🔥 Campfire pad w/ firewood + lake views 🛶 Kayaks + fishing poles + private dock ♨️ Wooden barrel sauna for ultimate relaxation 🌳 Private lake, beach, & outdoor games 🛏️ Sleeps 5 w/ full-size bunks + couch

Guest favourite

The exterior of a lake house is framed by tall trees, featuring a large wooden deck with seating. A blue kayak rests on the water's edge, while a dock extends toward the water. The house is two stories, showcasing multiple windows and a sloped roof.

Cabin in Rome City

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 48 reviews

Sylvan Lake Three bed, Parking and two piers

Have fun with the whole family at this stylish Three bed, two-bath on 600 Acre all sports, Sylvan Lake. Large dock with room for your boat. Remodeled throughout with a three-season screened porch. Centrally located in the narrows (no-wake zone), excellent fishing & water sports. Huge driveway for up to six cars. Three bedrooms five beds sleep up to 10 comfortably. You won’t want to miss this fantastic opportunity to spend time with your family at the lake!

Top guest favourite

A spacious family farmhouse is surrounded by a well-maintained lawn and trees. The house features a mix of brick and siding, and a porch can be seen in front. A gravel driveway leads to the property, with a clear sky above.

Guest house in LaGrange

5 out of 5 average rating, 194 reviews

Bird’s Nest Air BnB

Keeping it simple at this peaceful and centrally-located family farm. Within two miles of the famous Shipshewana Auction & Flea Market, Blue Gate Restaurant and Performing Arts Center. The Michiana Event Center which is also Located in Shipshewana has many attractions. We are located in the middle of a small, quiet farming community with all Amish neighbors, so be ready to listen to the clipclop of horses going by. Enjoy the peaceful country sunsets.