Holiday rentals in Sylvan Lake

The Cozy Lake Front Cottage

Come relax, soak up some sun with the entire family at our peaceful and cozy lakefront cottage on Witmer Lake. It offers stunning views of sunrises, sunsets, wild life and lake activities while sitting on the lawn or around the fire pit. Being located on one of the five chain of lakes and just walking distance from lakeside dining, makes this a great experience. The 2 bedroom 1 bath cottage is perfect place to relax after a day at the lake. Option to rent 1990 20ft Smokercraft pontoon (seasonal)

Upscale Lakeside Oasis – Private Island & Hot Tub

Experience Hilltop Haven on Sylvan Lake—an upscale luxury lakefront retreat where families reconnect and friends celebrate life by the water. Perfect for getaways, reunions, and special occasions, this spacious 5BR home features a private island, large pier, indoor hot tub, chef’s kitchen, game room w/pool table, TV room, & a wraparound deck w/grill for lakeview dining. Enjoy the kayaks, SUPs, fire pit, bikes, and basketball hoop for endless fun. Relax, play, and make memories at Hilltop Haven!

Westward House

The "Westward House" on Dallas Lake offers stunning westward sunset views, modern/mid-century/Scandi design, and abundant natural light with water views from nearly every room. Located on the Indian Chain of Lakes, it provides full access to a two-story home with heated floors, a gas fireplace, four bedrooms, and a screened porch. Outdoor amenities include a dock, boat ramp, loungers, and a fire pit. Nearby activities include pontoon rentals, a sandbar and Shipshewana/Amish Country attractions.

Waterfront Oasis w Beach, Dock & Kayaks!

Soak up sun-filled lake days and peaceful sunset evenings at this inviting waterfront retreat. From laid-back picnics to paddling adventures, everything you need for a memorable stay is here. This home offers: 🛶 Kayaks & life vests 🏖️ Private dock with water access 🔥 Wood-burning fire pit 🌅 Screened porch with lake views 🍔 Gas grill & outdoor dining 📺 Smart TV with local channels & streaming, games & books Perfect for couples, small families, and friends seeking a relaxing lake escape.

Sylvan Lakeside Retreat

Welcome to Sylvan Lake, Rome City IN! This 3 bed 1 bath home was completely remodeled in 2024 on one of Indiana's favorite all sports lakes. Whether you're in town for a family retreat, celebrating a special occasion, or need a peaceful place to stay while traveling for work, this lakefront home offers the perfect setting to unwind after a day of adventures. Full grocery, lakeside pubs, liquor & bait along with the public boat launch just blocks away. Boat rental also available upon request.

Amen Corner - A Modern Retreat in Amish Country

Welcome to this brand new private guest house in Middlebury, Indiana tucked quietly away in the heart of Amish country. Amen Corner offers the best of both worlds…modern amenities surrounded by nature’s beauty and amazing sunsets. - Enjoy a beverage on the back patio while watching birds or the neighboring horses - Cuddle up for your favorite series inside with bedroom & living room fireplaces - Peace and quiet can be found also if you’re looking to just relax and walk some of our trails

Amazing Views Lakehouse with Kayaks

The Cozy Nest is an adorable three-bedroom, pet-friendly cottage with amazing views of a quiet, no-wake lake. Enjoy the stunning view while your cares melt away in the hot tub. The kitchen is fully stocked and ready for your use. Fiber optic wifi will keep you connected. There are two bicycles available for exploring the surrounding countryside as well as a canoe, 3 kayaks, and paddle boat to use on the water. Shipshewana is a quick 15-mile drive away through beautiful Amish countryside.

Lakeside Sylvan-Lake Rome City Cottage

Welcome to Sylvan Lake in Rome City, IN. Sylvan Lake is an all season ski lake wonderful for all boating, fishing, skiing, tubing, wave runners and even a swim from the dock. You have 60 feet of lake front with two docks to bring your lake toys or rent a pontoon for the day/weekend or week. Full size kitchen, laundry, two big smart tv's with cable and wifi. Small shed for storage, large deck, canoe for 3, fire pit & gas grill. Wedding, family, golfing or weekend away? Lakeside Sylvan!

3 BR Sylvan Lakefront Oasis

Relax with the whole family at this peaceful place to stay. Enjoy the 3 BR 1.5 Bath lake front retreat. Bring your boat and enjoy sylvan lake, a 700 acre sport lake wonderful for all boating, fishing, skiing and tubing. Kick back and relax in this open, stylish space and enjoy the elevated decks & lounge areas. All bedrooms and dedicated work space are on the second level providing quiet privacy. Includes: Washer & Dryer, Gas Grill, Fire-pit! Plenty of parking available!

Beautiful Skinner Lake View Cottage

Private vacation home with a beautiful view of Lake Skinner. Waterfront access for fishing or taking the paddle boat out (seasonal). This cottage has all the basic amenities to make your stay comfortable. From the warm fire place to the spacious deck and 3 seasons room, you can enjoy this place anytime of the year. The full kitchen makes this place perfect for a week long getaway! A short twenty minute drive to Auburn and under an hour drive to Fort Wayne and Shipshewana.

Private Lake+Fire Pit+Sauna+Kayaks | Pine & Paddle

Welcome to Pine and Paddle — the perfect place to unplug, recharge, and reconnect with nature by the lake. Unwind at this cozy lakeside tiny home, perfect for couples, friends, or solo travelers seeking peace, nature, and a hint of adventure near downtown Shipshewana. 🔥 Campfire pad w/ firewood + lake views 🛶 Kayaks + fishing poles + private dock ♨️ Wooden barrel sauna for ultimate relaxation 🌳 Private lake, beach, & outdoor games 🛏️ Sleeps 5 w/ full-size bunks + couch

Sylvan Lake Three bed, Parking and two piers

Have fun with the whole family at this stylish Three bed, two-bath on 600 Acre all sports, Sylvan Lake. Large dock with room for your boat. Remodeled throughout with a three-season screened porch. Centrally located in the narrows (no-wake zone), excellent fishing & water sports. Huge driveway for up to six cars. Three bedrooms five beds sleep up to 10 comfortably. You won’t want to miss this fantastic opportunity to spend time with your family at the lake!