Holiday rentals in Geiger Key

Beach House, Private Pool, Dock, Gulf View Sunsets

You don’t come to the islands to stay in a town—you come to slow down. Welcome to our tropical keys beach home, tucked away from the traffic and noise of US Hwy #1. Sway with the palms on the wraparound deck, soak in wide-open panoramic bay views, and catch fiery sunsets right off your dock. Fire up the BBQ, brew a Keurig, float in the private pool, or cast a line from the 300’ private pier/dock. Easy going island living with ocean / gulf breezes, comfy beds, quality linens, Wi-Fi, and cable TV.

Rest A Shore Waterfront Home, New Private Pool

2-Bed, 2-Bath Retreat Sleeps 4 (Max 6). Additional guests: $25/day after 4 guests. Air mattresses available. Features a private pool, hot tub, gas grill, outdoor games, and a 42-ft private dock with water/power (boats up to 32 ft). (Note: Minimum weekly rental. All bedrooms and bathrooms are located on the second floor of the home and involve stairs). Pet-friendly, 1 pet max ($350) Charter recommendation: Captain Jay Charters, 10% when booking Sombrero home. Pack and Play available upon request.

Oceanview Marathon - Screened Porch, Theater & Bar

2020 New Construction Private, well-appointed 2 bed 2 bath home boasts: +5-Star OCEANVIEWS +Screened Porch with Ocean views to enjoy your morning coffee +Outdoor Theater +Bar and Adirondack chair conversation nook +Jumbo Nest Chairs over lush beach sand +Loungers +Full Kitchen +Grill Relax or adventure awaits - Minutes from the Keys' best public sandy beaches (Sombrero and Bahai Honda State Park), Theater of the Sea, Marathon Aquarium, Dolphin Research Ctr, Turtle Hospital and 7-Mile Bridge!

P37 - Charming 2 bedrooms duplex with Private Pool

Key Colony Delight! This 2 bedroom, 2 bath all ground level duplex in Key Colony Beach is absolutely delightful! Offering an open floor plan, well-stocked kitchen and plenty of room to relax. Guests are please to find both bedrooms are comfortable and spacious and have their own on-suite baths. This home comes with access to the Cabana Club; its private beach, large pool, bar and grill. The second unit in this duplex is a 1 bedroom/1 bath and is available to rent in addition to this ...

A Great Escape! Private 2 Bed Rm Beautiful Marina

Our Marina has a pool and a small private beach overlooking the beautiful Keys water! More affordable than most places in Key West while able to reconnect with nature at this private getaway on the Great Escape. As you approach the boat, you feel your dream vacation has come true . One of a lifetime. Staying on a beautiful sportfisher yacht, laying in the waters of the calm keys and in the most beautiful peaceful marina, will definitely set you free from all your worries and stress.

The Lighthouse - Beach Houses Key West

If you’re reading this, you’re already one step closer to paradise. Thank you for considering us for your getaway. Our charming Lighthouse Bungalow is a 2-bedroom, 1-bath loft-style retreat located just steps from our private beach. The master bedroom loft, accessed by a spiral staircase, offers a stunning bird’s-eye view of the Atlantic Ocean. The nautical-inspired living area opens to an exterior deck overlooking the beach—an ideal spot for peaceful mornings and ocean breezes.

Amazing houseboat with 2nd floor observation deck

Escape to our one-of-a-kind houseboat “Wild One,” anchored minutes from Soencers boat yard Key West. Surrounded by turquoise waters, enjoy one complimentary round trip per day, with times arranged around our charters. Evening rides may be available on request, last ride 10 PM. Extra charge after 8 PM Special Promotion: End your day with a private Sunset Eco Trip (6–7 PM) as your nightly ride to the houseboat—watch the sky ignite before settling in for a peaceful night afloat.

*NEW* Penthouse-Beach Front

Live the island dream in this stunning 2 Bed | 2 Bath Penthouse Condo perfectly situated in the heart of Key Colony Beach, Florida. Perched on the top floor, this coastal retreat offers sweeping, unobstructed views of the Atlantic Ocean and direct beach access—your private paradise in the Florida Keys. The primary suite includes a private bath and sliding doors that open directly to the balcony, letting you enjoy amazing Sunsets.

Coco Plum Waterfront Hideaway Home in Marathon

This Coco Plum home is the ultimate family getaway! With four bedrooms, two bathrooms, a modern living room with a 4K TV and surround sound, and an outdoor area that includes a fire pit, outdoor dining, and outdoor living space. The boat dock and breathtaking sunset views make this the perfect home for your fishing adventures. Beautiful Coco Plum beach is just a ten minute walk away. Make this home your next island adventure.

Beautiful Houseboat in Key West

Enjoy a unique and peaceful stay on our cozy houseboat in Key West. Perfect for couples or small families who want a relaxing water experience close to town. Comfortable sleeping area, deck space, and beautiful sunset views. Check-in is by appointment with personal captain meet-and-greet and boat transfer from the marina. A memorable island stay surrounded by nature and ocean air.

White House - Receive $400 towards a Boat Rental!

Receive a $400 gift certificate towards a boat rental. When you reserve a week for any of the dates and house below. When you book a full week at one of our homes staying between the dates of Sept 1, 2026 through Dec 19, 2026 Except for Nov 21-28, 2026 Please reach out before booking for boat availability. Kayaks come with the rental. Small floating dock for your boat.

Waterfront Captain House with Boat Basin & Ramp!

Welcome to Paradise! Stay in the amazing Keys and beautiful waterfront home with boat basin for your boat. The property lot is almost an acre with an island point surrounded by sea life. Stunning panoramic water views, sunrise and sunset. Steps away from ocean water. Bring or rent fishing and snorkel gear nearby to fish right off the point and enjoy the underwater scenery!