Holiday rentals in Horse Thief Lake

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Horse Thief Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top guest favourite
Flat in Rapid City
4.91 out of 5 average rating, 129 reviews

Quaint 1-bedroom-West Boulevard!

Quaint 1-bedroom in Historic West Boulevard. Enjoy easy access to downtown for shopping, restaurants, tourist attractions, and grocery stores. This newly remodeled unit was originally an early 1900s farmhouse that was relocated to this spot. You'll enjoy soaking in the cast iron clawfoot tub that has 1889 stamped on the bottom, the year South Dakota earned statehood! Fully equipped kitchen! Full-sized bed. Pine floors with South Dakota decor! Easy access to Mt Rushmore & other sights!

Top guest favourite
A cozy bedroom features a spacious bed covered with a red blanket. Two framed artworks adorn the wall above the bed. A mounted TV is positioned nearby, while a light wood closet with double doors is visible to the right. Natural light enters through a window.
Guest suite in Rapid City
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 496 reviews

Quiet private suite with garage bay & kitchenette

Quiet private bedroom and kitchenette isolated from the main house with common use sun room between. Rural setting off Hwy 44 just minutes from Rapid City Airport. Tesla 11kw destination charging outlet in your garage bay directly accessible from the suite. Starlink 150mbps internet. Pet friendly to friendly pets with pet door from the suite out to the fenced back yard & patio isolated from our dog & cat. Private bath has in-floor heat and endless hot water with continuous flow water heater.

Guest favourite
Cabin in Custer
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 135 reviews

★ Secluded Stay in a Wonderful Creekside Getaway ★

This beautifully remodeled home is thoughtfully furnished to a high standard, offering the perfect retreat. Tucked away in a secluded setting, you’ll enjoy the serenity of the Black Hills while still being just minutes from top attractions like Mount Rushmore, Crazy Horse Memorial, Custer State Park. With easy access right off a main highway, our home provides the best of both worlds — quiet privacy and convenient proximity to adventure. This is the ideal home base for your unforgettable stay.

Guest favourite
The game room features a classic wooden pool table with a blue felt surface, surrounded by a carpeted floor. A wall of brick showcases various framed memorabilia and decorative items, enhancing the recreational atmosphere. Two high-top chairs are positioned nearby.
Guest house in Rapid City
4.91 out of 5 average rating, 719 reviews

Priceless Black Hills View!

Two Large Furnished Bedrooms, new Queen Beds Pool Table and Darts Large living room with new sofa sleeper Newly remodeled bathroom 65'' UHD Smart TV, Dish DVR, Bluray Pool and Rec facilities, seasonal WIFI Highspeed Internet Outdoor patio area with seating Gas grill Pool table and darts Full size fridge/freezer Convection oven Induction cooktop Microwave Keurig coffee and breakfast snacks Washer and dryer Close to Rapid City shopping and dining Nature and wild life Amazing stars out at night!

Top guest favourite
A scenic view showcases a cabin set against a snow-covered landscape, surrounded by tall trees. A winding gravel path leads to the entrance, with a backdrop of gently rolling hills blanketed in white. The cabin's A-frame structure is visible in the distance.
Cabin in Rapid City
4.89 out of 5 average rating, 46 reviews

A Room in Nature

Escape to a cozy A frame cabin situated in the peaceful Aspen forest just 10 minutes from Mount Rushmore. Whether you’re looking for a romantic retreat, a solo escape, or a peaceful haven to unwind, we can't wait to host you! Please note that this listing is for one bedroom within our spacious cabin and is limited to two guests only. As this is our off-season listing, you will be the only guests in the cabin and will not share the space with anyone else during your stay. Pets are welcome.

Top guest favourite
Flat in Keystone
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 120 reviews

The Sage - Hinterwood Inn & Cabins

The Sage is part of Hinterwood Inn and Cabins and sleeps up to 4 people. It has one bedroom with a king bed, a daybed/trundle (two twin mattresses) in the living room. It has a full kitchen with a gas stove, refrigerator, microwave, a regular coffee pot, dishes, utensils, and pots and pans. It includes one full, spacious bathroom with a shower (no tub). It's approximately 500 sq. feet. Enjoy the private fire pit area, the gas grill outside, and the expansive outdoor spaces on the property.

Guest favourite
A large lodging building is shown, featuring a combination of wood and stone exterior. The front showcases a spacious deck with wooden railings, surrounded by trees. A garage door is visible on the left side, contributing to the rustic, natural atmosphere of the area.
Guest suite in Keystone
4.76 out of 5 average rating, 402 reviews

Wild, Wild West Experience

On 10 private acres in the heart of the Black Hills, this airbnb offers the best of both worlds—just 8 minutes to Mount Rushmore and 15 minutes to Rapid City. Surrounded by thr National Forest, it’s the perfect home base for exploring the area's sights and scenic drives. After a day of adventure, unwind where you can soak in the views, spot deer wandering through the trees, and enjoy the quiet sounds of nature. It’s the perfect spot to relax, recharge, and plan your next day in the hills.

Top guest favourite
A spacious cabin is set amidst oak trees, featuring a large covered porch with seating. A fire pit area with multiple chairs is positioned in the foreground, surrounded by natural scenery. The well-maintained yard leads to a tranquil view of the wooded surroundings.
Cabin in Keystone
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 26 reviews

The Oak Grove Cabin

Welcome to the Oak Grove Cabin. This 3 bedroom/2 bath cabin is set apart and surrounded by oak trees. With multiple gathering areas there's enough room for the whole family to be together. Take a deep breath of fresh air and listen to the water run down the stream on this 8 acre property surrounded by National Forest. You will feel complete peace while also being minutes away from Mt Rushmore (2.4 miles) and Custer State Park (15 mins)

Top guest favourite
Tiny home in Custer
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 159 reviews

Rustic Modern Tiny House Next To Custer State Park

Enjoy this modern Tiny House, located just 5 minutes to Custer State Park. Experience unique views of rock formations while you drink your morning coffee. You will have access to the entire house, all to yourself. Great area to hike, bike, see the fluffy buffalo. Just a two minute drive to downtown Custer. This area has great ATV, trail ride and kayak rentals near by! Feel refreshed when you stay in this rustic gem.

Top guest favourite
A living room is showcased with a combination of seating options, including a gray sofa and two yellow accent chairs. A round wooden coffee table sits on a patterned area rug, while a clock and framed artwork adorn the walls. Natural light brightens the space.
Holiday home in Rapid City
4.87 out of 5 average rating, 178 reviews

Apt 1, Historic District, Downtown

West Boulevard is Rapid City's most historic and architecturally eclectic neighborhood. Clean, quiet, safe, convenient, and comfortable...all the things you're looking for! You’ll be walking distance from downtown, and a short drive to all the Black Hills has to offer. I am born and raised in the Black Hills so I know all the good spots to eat, hike, bike, or whatever you're after here on your vacation.

Guest favourite
Flat in Rapid City
4.88 out of 5 average rating, 110 reviews

Historic Modern 1 Bedroom Downtown Luxury Flat

Enjoy a stylish experience at this centrally-located newly renovated apartment! This beautiful large studio apartment is nestled right between West Blvd (Historic Neighborhood) and Mt. Rushmore Rd. Perfectly located in a peacefully quiet neighborhood, minutes from Interstate 90 or Hwy 16 and blocks from the fun of Downtown Rapid City.

Top guest favourite
A single-story house is depicted with a wooden exterior in a soft grey shade. Large glass sliding doors offer views of the interior, framed by two side windows. A small seating area with two chairs is visible on the porch, surrounded by grassy grounds and pine trees.
Cottage in Hill City
5 out of 5 average rating, 217 reviews

Mystic Road Cottage… -Peaceful -Private -Hot tub

Kick back and relax in this calm, stylish space. Conveniently located adjacent to the Mickelson Trail and UTV Trails. If you enjoy water adventures, Deerfield Lake, Sheridan Lake and Pactola Lake are only a short drive away. Come enjoy nature and explore the Black Hills. End your day relaxing in the hot tub gazing at the stars.

Popular amenities for Horse Thief Lake holiday rentals