Holiday rentals in Horse Thief Lake

Hill City Get Away Black Hills SD

Your home-away-from-home is as sweet as it gets in this custom ranch with main floor living and fabulous upgrades on an acre that’s just a hop, skip, and a jump from Hill City and all the gorgeous Southern Black Hills has to offer! Mount Rushmore is a mere 11 miles. Deadwood is only 39 miles with stops along 385 for ATVing, snowmobiling, golfing and the list goes on. You will find Mountain Biking, hiking, swimming and many other adventures in every direction. Chef’s delight eat-in, fully stocked, kitchen with loads of custom Alder cabinets, plenty of granite countertop space, stainless steel appliances, large center island, walk-in pantry, and hardwood birch floods extending into the dining room with walkout doors to a partially covered back deck, overlooking pine tree studded woods. Awe-inspiring living room with sky high vaulted ceiling, striking wooden beams, custom cabinetry, and cozy brick-encased wood-burning fireplace. Huge luxurious master suite is an absolute dream with tray ceiling, brick-encased gas fireplace, and barn door leading into a private master bath with tile floor, double vanity, tile walk in shower with 2 shower heads, jetted tub, and walk-in closet. 2 more sizable bedrooms and full guest bath. Handy main floor laundry with dog washing station. Attached heated 2 stall garage + detached 2 stall garage plus a 3-sided carport, boat/RV storage. A whole plethora of upgrades throughout including: plush carpet, remote blinds, 8 foot doors, 9 foot ceilings, solar tube lights, built-in indoor & outdoor speakers, shed, built in BBQ (plumbed to propane line) with awning, and custom-built gables. Low traffic area so your peace won’t be disturbed - book now to secure your stay in Black Hills serenity! * We recommend considering trip insurance for your stay as our rental policy is firm and the winter weather here can be unpredictable. *

Creekside Sanctuary

Creekside Sanctuary is a 6+ acre paradise for families, friends, celebrations or retreats. Naming this property was not easy, not only is this a Sanctuary for relaxation and rejuvenation, guests can also enjoy the popular site seeing and abundant wildlife native to our beautiful Black Hills. Whether winter or summer, there are activates nearby - fishing, hiking, skiing, snowmobiling, ice skating. The large yard is host to deer and turkey, an ideal gathering spot for celebration, fun and games.

Grandma's House in the Heart of the Black Hills

Grandma's House is in the heart of the Black Hills, located 1 mile from Hill City, it is minutes away from Mt. Rushmore, Crazy Horse, Custer State Park and more. It sits alone on the edge of a meadow with hills directly behind it and a small, bubbly creek in front of the house. It has plenty of room for kids to run and play outside, and a cozy, quaint inside for families to enjoy each other's company. Grandma’s House is available for extended stays November thru April. Contact host for details

Cabin on 20 acres w/ horses, goats, & mini donkey

Enjoy country living close to town! Two bedrooms w/ queen size beds and loft w/ queen size pullout sofa allow you to comfortably sleep 6! Just 4 miles from downtown Hill City. Sits on 20 beautiful acres surrounded on 3 sides by Forest Service! Enjoy beautiful surroundings - a seasonal pond outside your cabin (water level varies), horses, mini donkey, mini goats and chickens. Enjoy private setting with the convenience of the owners just 1/4 mile up the driveway to take care of your needs!

Nature Stay with Views Like No Where Else

This home is truly one-of-a-kind and straight out of a magazine! Beautifully modern and furnished to an exceptional standard. Open the windows and let the soothing sounds of the nearby creek transport you to your own private paradise. Located close to Mount Rushmore, Crazy Horse Memorial, Custer State Park, and many other top attractions, you’re also just under 5 minutes from Hill City. We truly believe this is the ultimate spot to fully experience the breathtaking beauty of the Black Hills.

Mirror Cabin in the Black Hills

You'll love this unique and romantic escape. This tiny Mirror Cabin by REFLECT+RECONNECT, is nestled in the serene beauty of the Black Hills. It creates a rejuvenating and memorable experience. This unique retreat is designed to offer you a chance to disconnect from the hustle and bustle of everyday life and reconnect with the special person in your life, yourself, and the surrounding nature. Come for the adventure. Stay for the connection. Leave feeling refreshed, reconnected, and renewed.

Peaceful Canyon Retreat | Luxe Apt + Wildlife

Enjoy the perfect summer escape—warm days, open skies, and peaceful canyon views. Just 11 miles from the historic Game Lodge and the start of the famous Wildlife Loop. Nestled beside the stunning Box Canyon, our newly built 1-bedroom, 1-bathroom apartment offers a quiet retreat in one of the most breathtaking corners of the Black Hills. Spend your days exploring scenic drives, iconic landmarks, and endless trails, then return to unwind, and take in the natural beauty that surrounds you.

lNDOOR POOL! The FUN house

Ready for an unforgettable getaway? Welcome to your 7,000 sq. ft. vacation dream home! Packed with fun for all ages and designed with sustainability in mind, thanks to solar-powered energy! Whether you're splashing down the water slide, soaking in the hot tub, or enjoying a friendly game of foosball, this is where epic memories are made. Everyone in the family will thank you for choosing this one-of-a-kind escape! This property is pet-free and 100% smoke-free – indoors and out.

Castle in the Sky

Are you looking for a luxurious, unique place to stay? This house sits overlooking Rapid City with incredible skyline views, every evening is as picture perfect as the glowing city lights. This unique house is a fun mix of eclectic and fancy. Originally built as a local builder's "Coup de Grande", he ended up only finishing the guest house. You will find high-end finishes mixed with eclectic choices. We promise this will be one of the most memorable places you'll ever stay!

The Viewhouse - Hinterwood Inn & Cabins

The Viewhouse is part of Hinterwood Inn & Cabins and sleeps up to 8 people. It has 3 bedrooms, each with a queen bed and full private bathroom, then the living room has a daybed/trundle (two twin mattresses) for additional sleeping. Enjoy a full kitchen with provided essentials, and a private deck and fire pit area with a gas grill. It has two levels, so requires the use of stairs. You will love the views, animal sightings, and hiking right from your front door.

Creek-side Cabin | Hot Tub + Trout Fishing

Wake up to the sound of a babbling creek, sip your morning coffee on the deck while bighorn sheep graze on the hillside, and spend your evenings soaking in the hot tub under a sky full of stars. This beautifully furnished 3-bedroom Black Hills cabin sits right on the water — perfect for trout fishing, family gatherings, romantic getaways, or simply unplugging from the world. With stunning creek and mountain views, This is a Complete Black Hills retreat.

Americana Escape | Fire Pit, Games, Mount Rushmore

Modern Americana, minutes to Mt Rushmore - Air Hockey, Ping Pong, Bar, Smart TVs - Fire Pit, Gas Grill, Porch, Outdoor Dining - Coffee Bar: Drip Machine, K-cup, French Press, Frother, Creamers - Pet + Family friendly - Fully redesigned in 2025, central to Black Hills attractions - Minutes to downtown Keystone and Mt. Rushmore - Perfect for families, adventurers, or anyone seeking relaxation amidst nature and wildlife. - Fast Starlink Internet!