Holiday rentals in Horse Thief Lake

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Horse Thief Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Top guest favourite

A spacious home is nestled among tall trees, overlooking a gently flowing creek. The property features a large deck and stonework, blending harmoniously with the natural surroundings, while vibrant greenery enhances the serene environment.

Home in Rapid City

Creekside Sanctuary

Creekside Sanctuary is a 6+ acre paradise for families, friends, celebrations or retreats. Naming this property was not easy, not only is this a Sanctuary for relaxation and rejuvenation, guests can also enjoy the popular site seeing and abundant wildlife native to our beautiful Black Hills. Whether winter or summer, there are activates nearby - fishing, hiking, skiing, snowmobiling, ice skating. The large yard is host to deer and turkey, an ideal gathering spot for celebration, fun and games.

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 125 reviews

Top guest favourite

An inviting interior showcases a spacious living area with wood accents. A serene view of two bedrooms is visible in the background, featuring cozy queen beds. A rustic charm is highlighted by the wooden beam accent wall and decor, enhancing the cabin's welcoming atmosphere.

Cabin in Keystone

The Notch Cabin - Hinterwood Inn & Cabins

The Notch Cabin is part of Hinterwood Inn & Cabins, situated 60 ft. from National Forest. Enjoy hiking and wildlife sightings from your front door! The cabin has 2 bedrooms, each with a queen bed, a queen murphy bed in the living room, a bathroom with a shower (no tub), and an apartment size kitchen w/ essentials. Custom built by the owners, enjoy the beautiful wooden accent wall, pine slab table, and vaulted ceilings. Includes a private deck with a gas grill, private fire pit area, and more!

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 178 reviews

Top guest favourite

A charming red house is surrounded by lush green grass and tall trees, with a sloped hill rising in the background. A small deck with white chairs is visible at the front, offering a welcoming outdoor space.

Cabin in Hill City

Grandma's House in the Heart of the Black Hills

Grandma's House is in the heart of the Black Hills, located 1 mile from Hill City, it is minutes away from Mt. Rushmore, Crazy Horse, Custer State Park and more. It sits alone on the edge of a meadow with hills directly behind it and a small, bubbly creek in front of the house. It has plenty of room for kids to run and play outside, and a cozy, quaint inside for families to enjoy each other's company. Grandma’s House is available for extended stays November thru April. Contact host for details

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 130 reviews

Top guest favourite

A modern tiny cabin features reflective walls, blending into the surrounding nature. Tall trees and a blue sky are mirrored on the surface, creating a seamless connection with the forest. The cabin's structure is set among rocky terrain, emphasizing its unique design.

Tiny home in Lead

Mirror Cabin in the Black Hills

You'll love this unique and romantic escape. This tiny Mirror Cabin by REFLECT+RECONNECT, is nestled in the serene beauty of the Black Hills. It creates a rejuvenating and memorable experience. This unique retreat is designed to offer you a chance to disconnect from the hustle and bustle of everyday life and reconnect with the special person in your life, yourself, and the surrounding nature. Come for the adventure. Stay for the connection. Leave feeling refreshed, reconnected, and renewed.

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 180 reviews

Top guest favourite

A panoramic view reveals a verdant canyon surrounded by towering pine trees. Jagged rock formations line the cliffs, with splashes of green foliage contrasting against the earthy tones. The sky, filled with soft clouds, adds a serene backdrop to this natural landscape.

Flat in Hermosa

Peaceful Canyon Retreat | Luxe Apt + Wildlife

Enjoy the perfect summer escape—warm days, open skies, and peaceful canyon views. Just 11 miles from the historic Game Lodge and the start of the famous Wildlife Loop. Nestled beside the stunning Box Canyon, our newly built 1-bedroom, 1-bathroom apartment offers a quiet retreat in one of the most breathtaking corners of the Black Hills. Spend your days exploring scenic drives, iconic landmarks, and endless trails, then return to unwind, and take in the natural beauty that surrounds you.

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 61 reviews

Guest favourite

An expansive indoor pool area features a large swimming pool with a water slide. Natural light filters through skylights and large windows. A basketball hoop stands at the side of the pool, while lounge chairs provide space for relaxation.

Home in Rapid City

lNDOOR POOL! The FUN house

Ready for an unforgettable getaway? Welcome to your 7,000 sq. ft. vacation dream home! Packed with fun for all ages and designed with sustainability in mind, thanks to solar-powered energy! Whether you're splashing down the water slide, soaking in the hot tub, or enjoying a friendly game of foosball, this is where epic memories are made. Everyone in the family will thank you for choosing this one-of-a-kind escape! This property is pet-free and 100% smoke-free – indoors and out.

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 144 reviews

Guest favourite

Home in Keystone

Grizzly Bear Creek- Mt Rushmore Views- w/ Hot tub

Welcome to your perfect Black Hills getaway! Surrounded by breathtaking views, fresh mountain air, and a rustic setting that captures the true spirit of the Black Hills, this home is your ideal escape into nature. Best highlights of the property: 👉 Stunning VIEW of Mt. Rushmore RIGHT from the property 👉 Enjoy a peaceful walking path by the creek and gather around the fire pit to watch the Mount Rushmore lighting ceremony —creating unforgettable memories during your stay.

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 15 reviews

Superhost

Home in Rapid City

Castle in the Sky

Are you looking for a luxurious, unique place to stay? This house sits overlooking Rapid City with incredible skyline views, every evening is as picture perfect as the glowing city lights. This unique house is a fun mix of eclectic and fancy. Originally built as a local builder's "Coup de Grande", he ended up only finishing the guest house. You will find high-end finishes mixed with eclectic choices. We promise this will be one of the most memorable places you'll ever stay!

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 142 reviews

Top guest favourite

A covered porch is displayed with two wooden chairs positioned in front. Large glass doors reveal a spacious dining area and kitchen, featuring dark cabinetry and modern appliances. The floor appears polished and reflects the warm lighting from overhead fixtures.

Home in Hill City

Hill City Hideaway on the Mickelson Trail

Location, location, location. Hill City is located in the center of the Black Hills and this house is within walking distance of the best parts of Hill City. 40 feet to the world famous Mickelson Trail, 1/2 a block to the 1880s steam train, and 3 blocks to the best restaurant in South Dakota. This home is not too big and not too small. Whether you are doing a couples get away, traveling with kids or your friends this home may be "just right" for you.

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 216 reviews

Top guest favourite

A charming creek-side home is featured, showcasing rustic wooden siding and a welcoming entrance. A pathway leads to a wooden deck, with a flagpole prominently displaying the American flag. Vibrant green grass and a fire pit with red chairs enrich the outdoor space, surrounded by natural hills.

Cabin in Rapid City

Creek-side Cabin | Hot Tub + Trout Fishing

Wake up to the sound of a babbling creek, sip your morning coffee on the deck while bighorn sheep graze on the hillside, and spend your evenings soaking in the hot tub under a sky full of stars. This beautifully furnished 3-bedroom Black Hills cabin sits right on the water — perfect for trout fishing, family gatherings, romantic getaways, or simply unplugging from the world. With stunning creek and mountain views, This is a Complete Black Hills retreat.

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 394 reviews

Top guest favourite

A two-story wooden house features a spacious covered deck with railing and several hanging plants. Lounge chairs are positioned on the lower level, with a hot tub visible nearby. The surrounding landscape includes grassy patches and tall pine trees, creating a serene outdoor setting.

Home in Custer

French Creek Farm

3,000-sq-ft custom home on 40 private acres in the Black Hills with French Creek in the valley. Sip morning coffee or sunset drinks and enjoy unforgettable stargazing from the covered porch or huge side deck. Inside: stunning stone fireplace, oversized spa-like baths, and a fully stocked kitchen (gas range, 2 ovens, warming drawer). Trails start on-site for ATV/horse/hike/bike. Unwind in the hot tub or by the fire pit. Close to Custer & top attractions.

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 37 reviews

Superhost

A rustic cabin constructed from wood stands beside a well-maintained gravel path. Vibrant red flowers adorn the windows. Lush greenery surrounds the cabin, with tall trees and rolling hills in the background. A vintage train is faintly visible in the distance, adding character to the scenery.

Barn in Keystone

The Barn near Mt Rushmore

Welcome to The Barn at Backroads Inn and Cabins. Originally a 1900's sawmill this barn transformed in 2012 with a complete renovation to provide a truly unique and unforgettable stay. Take a deep breath of fresh air and listen to the water run down the stream outside the barn on this 8 acre property surrounded by National Forest. You will feel complete peace while also being minutes away from Mt Rushmore (2.4 miles) and Custer State Park (15 mins).

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews