Skip to content

Holiday rentals in Lake Montauk

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Lake Montauk

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

  1. Entire home
  2. Montauk
Kalaloo - Montauk Cabin-esque away from the crowds

Enjoy Montauk away from the crowds at this lovely location along picturesque East Lake Drive. Only 2.2 miles from the surf of Ditch Plains Beach and an even shorter 1.8 miles to the quieter Gin Beach and Long Island Sound. This modest and efficient 3 bedroom single story summer cottage is nestled within an acre of land overlooking a peaceful field. There is a feeling of privacy along with wide open East End skies, where deer and rabbits are often seen foraging for fresh greens.

SUPERHOST
  1. Entire rental unit
  2. Montauk
Duffy's On Lake Montauk 3

Recently renovated in soft grays and whites, these sleek units offer a full kitchen, washer/dryer, living area and large deck steps from Lake Montauk. Paddle boards and kayak available for rentals. All units have Bose players and Roku. The units sit at a 90 degree angle to the lake with partial lake views from the deck. The lake and beachfront are a 1 minute walk from the unit.Rental prices include Suffolk County Sales and Occupancy Tax.

SUPERHOST
  1. Entire cottage
  2. Montauk
Mellow Montauk on the lake

Bright, airy 2 bedroom freestanding cottage at Outrigger on East Lake Drive. French sliding doors in living room lead onto a wraparound deck facing the lake. Enjoy sunset dinners on the deck. Bring your kayak! New kitchen appliances. Remodeled bathroom. The lawn leads to our private beach on lake Montauk. We are about a mile from Ditch Plains (we walk or bike!) and 2.5 miles down the road from Gin Beach (walk/bike/taxi). Umbrella beach in town has public parking. There’s even an upright piano!

Holiday rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you.

  • Homes
  • Hotels
  • Unique stays

Other great holiday rentals in Lake Montauk

SUPERHOST
  1. Entire holiday home
  2. Montauk
PRIVATE ENTRANCE TO DUPLEX APARTMENT ON LUSH ACRES
SUPERHOST
  1. Entire rental unit
  2. Montauk
Private paradise 3 min from town ice skating pond!
SUPERHOST
  1. Private room
  2. Montauk
The Black and White Room.
  1. Entire home
  2. Montauk
Live your best life steps from the beach in this classic Montauk beach house!
  1. Entire home
  2. Montauk
Walk to beach - cool leisurama
SUPERHOST
  1. Entire apartment
  2. Montauk
Deluxe StudIo Apt@The Montauk Manor
SUPERHOST
  1. Entire rental unit
  2. Montauk
Duffy's on Lake Montauk 2
SUPERHOST
  1. Private room
  2. Montauk
Private Bedroom and Bathroom in MTK
  1. Entire rental unit
  2. Montauk
Beautiful, modern retreat steps to beach & harbor
  1. Entire rental unit
  2. Montauk
Walk to Ditch! King Bed Suite/Apt
  1. Entire cottage
  2. Montauk
Montauk - Only a 3 minute walk to the beach!
  1. Entire rental unit
  2. Montauk
Montauk’s Secret Private Spot
  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. New York
  4. Suffolk County
  5. Montauk
  6. Lake Montauk