Cottage holiday rentals in Sister Bay

Find and book unique cottages on Airbnb

Top-rated cottage rentals in Sister Bay

Guests agree: these cottages are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favourite

Cottage in Brussels

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 109 reviews

Dogs Stay Free! Waterfront Door County Cottage

Jiffy's Journey is a beautiful lake side cottage features stunning sunset views over Green Bay. Outside, enjoy easy, private water access, beautiful deck, and the stunning sunset views of Green Bay. Inside, enjoy the bright, updated open floorplan, with views of the bay from every room in the house, even the bathrooms! Upstairs the entire floor is a giant master suite that will wow you! During the day, you're just a short drive from all that Door County has to offer! Pet friendly and no pet fees

Guest favourite

Cottage in Fish Creek

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 178 reviews

Cole's Country Cottage •In The Heart of Fish Creek

Come relax at our very comfortable, homey, quiet space located in the heart of Fish Creek, just minutes from downtown, the beach, Peninsula State Park + popular restaurants and shops. We prioritize the cleanliness of our space + the comfort of our guests. Two bedrooms, a living room, kitchen + bathroom make it perfect for families - you get plenty of backyard space too! We provide coffee + a fully equipped kitchen and bathroom. Stay with us for some relaxation + see all Door County has to offer!

Guest favourite

Cottage in Sister Bay

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 134 reviews

Sea Glass Cottage

Welcome to Sea Glass Cottage. Your Door County home away from home. This light and airy cottage is on the water with rock beach, beautiful sunrises, great room with beam ceilings & wood burning fireplace, kitchen ready for cooking and baking. A view of Lake Michigan from nearly every room. Perfect location for families or couples vacation. This cottage is tucked away on a wooded lot with an open backyard to enjoy sunshine and shoreline, or take a quick 5 minute drive to downtown Sister Bay.

Guest favourite

Cottage in Ellison Bay

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 161 reviews

Tiny Yellow Cottage in Gills Rock

Live small, unplug, and unwind at our cozy, clean, and charming cottage in peaceful Gills Rock. Away from crowds, this tiny retreat includes a living area with kitchenette, two full-sized beds with crisp cotton linens, plus a private patio, grill, fire pit—stunning sunsets just across the street. It’s the perfect home to recharge after a day exploring Door County. Just 15 minutes from the bustle of the bigger towns—close enough for adventure, far enough for peace. Located on scenic Highway 42.

Guest favourite

Cottage in Washington

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 289 reviews

Gull Cottage Waterfront Home on Washington Island

Find a little piece of heaven at Gull Cottage on Washington Island! Our charming cottage has been passed down through generations and is the perfect island get-away! Centered on Figenschau Bay, we are just minutes from restaurants, island landmarks and boat launches. This property has the comforts of home and the amenities of a boutique hotel! Newly renovated/interior painting/remodeled bath/new mattresses/bed linens/draperies. Fully equipped kitchen. Outdoor seating area w/deck and fire pit.

Guest favourite

Cottage in Sturgeon Bay

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 316 reviews

Logan Creek Cottage

We hope you love our newly renovated home on Logan Creek as much as we do! We took a lot of time to renovate the small cabin, wall to wall. The living room has abundant natural light with a picturesque window and large sliding glass doors over looking our porch and Logan Creek. All of these renovations were to increase the view of the natural beauty of the Logan Creek State Natural Area. We have two bedrooms + loft so it is perfect for your small family or just a cozy spot for two!

Superhost

Cottage in Sturgeon Bay

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 199 reviews

Peace of Beach, 4 season waterfront cottage

Beautiful 4 season, private 2 bedroom Knotty Pine Cottage located on the shores of Lake Michigan just 10 yards away from water in Sturgeon Bay, WI. 2 BR/1 bath cottage with beautiful stone, wood burning fireplace. A fully equipped kitchen with high bar dining which seats 8. Lots of living space with leather sectional and full size hide-away sofa sleeps 2, Main Guest Room 1 w/ queen log bed and Guest Room 2 with full size log bunk beds, Large screen tv, wifi and panoramic lake view.

Top guest favourite

Cottage in Sister Bay

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 191 reviews

The Sister Bay Getaway: Water View & Downtown!

Updated 2 bedroom home - smoke & pet free. WiFi, Smart TV and A/C. Walking distance to downtown Sister Bay shops, restaurants, beach and more! This has been a favorite Door County location for many! We sincerely hope you enjoy our vacation home, Sister Bay, and everything Door County has to offer! Accept rental agreement (House Rules) prior to your stay. Airbnb bills and remits the WI State/County Taxes (5.5%); Door County Lodging tax (8%) & Sister Bay Resort tax (0.5%).

Guest favourite

Cottage in Sister Bay

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 116 reviews

The Key to Happiness

Sleeping 4-6 between 4 beds, Plum Retreat provides a one-of-a-kind Door County experience. With 2 large bedrooms (plus giant living room with queen sofa bed, dining area and full kitchen), the 1700 sq-feet have a charming cottage-like feel. Conveniently located with gorgeous perennial gardens, it makes a romantic, peaceful or fun space. Private lawn & patio/grill. Pretty much everything has been thought of. Last summer, all 37 groups of people gave it a 5-star rating!

Guest favourite

Cottage in Sister Bay

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 196 reviews

A-Frame - Coffee Bar, Gas Fireplace - Sleeps 4!

Trade the hustle and bustle for peace and quiet at our cozy retreat, just 5 minutes from the heart of Sister Bay. Tucked away on 1.6 acres of serene woods filled with beautiful beech trees, the cottage is your perfect getaway spot. Kick back on the spacious front deck, unwind on the screened-in porch, and soak in the natural beauty all around. Inside, mid-century modern vibes meet cozy comforts, with everything you need for a relaxing, stress-free stay.

Top guest favourite

Cottage in Sister Bay

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 141 reviews

Lofted Pines Cottage

Settle in at Lofted Pines Cottage for your Door County stay! Located off the beaten path, but only a few minutes from downtown Sister Bay or Lake Michigan, Lofted Pines is elegantly situated among mature cedar and fir trees, yet open and airy. Whether you're relaxing on the wrap around porch, cozied up in front of the fireplace or enjoying the wood burning fire pit, Lofted Pines is the perfect spot to unwind after exploring the Door County Peninsula.