Cottage holiday rentals in Sullivan County

Great place to stay.

We had a lovely time staying at Jo and Sean’s place even though it was the off season. One big thing for us is that our 3 dogs were welcomed with no restrictions. We enjoyed the deck being enclosed and having the dog run accessible. The views of the lake were stunning and peaceful. Our hosts were the most responsive we’ve ever had. Before we came, they provided lots of ideas for places to visit and things to do. We hope to come back again!

Such a great place! Loved my stay. The cottage is perfect and the outdoor spaces (jacuzzi, fire pit, BBQ) are really well set up. I can’t wait to go back again.

Wonderfully renovated with many smart features. Hot tub was perfect for relaxing. Olena was very responsive and provided great recommendations.

First things first, this house is a get away paradise. Me, my girlfriend, and some friends went for our anniversary and we all immediately fell in love with this property. We will 110% be going back and we’ll be regularly staying at this house. Saundra (the host) made this place feel like I’ve been there 100 times. She left us a booklet of things to do in the area and left us a whole bunch of board games in the basement. Also, she’s the most responsive and communicative host I’ve ever had. She was very clear on instructions for checking in and checking out. Over all, this beautiful warm house is the perfect get away for ANYBODY, I would recommend staying here for all

Right as we pulled in the house immediately caught our eye. Such a quiet community and we really settled in we got to check in early, we spent our time in the hot tub and by the fire and cooking! The beds are comfortable and I have to say I enjoyed my time although I wish I picked a better weekend to see the stunning views but the clouds made it so dramatic! David was a wonderful host would definitely book again!

We had a great time at The Shire. The location was private, sunsets were beautiful, and the sauna was hot. I would highly recommend staying at The Shire and will most likely be booking another stay in the future.

We enjoyed the lovely cozy, private cottage with our family. It was a pleasure to have the animals nearby for the kids to interact with, a safe environment to roam in the woods, and very convenient to have the farm shop a few steps away for local eggs, meats, etc. The cottage was stylishly modern with a clean aesthetic and modern conveniences. Josh was very accessible via text/phone and checked in with us during our stay. We enjoyed ourselves thoroughly and would recommend to nature lovers, families, and those looking for a getaway in the woods!

We had an amazing stay! The space was incredibly comfortable, with plenty of room for our group of four ladies, and we felt right at home from the moment we arrived. The beds were cozy, and the overall atmosphere was warm and inviting. We were easily able to make eggs, toast and coffee which we enjoyed in the super cute dining while listening to Carly Simon on the record player. What really made this stay special were Kristen's thoughtful recommendations. From fantastic local restaurants to hidden gems in the area, she provided us with all the insider tips, making our trip even more memorable. It was clear that she truly cares about her guests’ experiences, including around what to expect upon arrival. And she responded quickly when we reached to her with a question. We couldn’t have asked for a better spot to enjoy a ladies' weekend getaway, and we’d definitely return! Highly recommend this place to anyone looking for a relaxing, comfortable stay with great local insights.

We had a perfect long weekend at Steven's cottage. It is bigger than it looks in the photos and was immaculately clean when we arrived. Steven was extremely responsive to all our questions and needs. The place is incredibly peaceful, a 2 min walk from the lake, on a private road where Steven owns all three houses. It was so relaxing and rejuvenating to spend time at this oasis with my partner and our best friends. There's a lot to love, but the best part is that the house comes with a private deck and dock, and unlimited access to various boats, to make your lake weekend whatever you want it to be. We loved that we could take our dogs to play fetch off the dock and not worry about getting in anyone's way or having to share any space. It was a great stay and we hope to go back!

This cozy little cottage was so much more than their pictures. We were enthralled by how large, yet cozy the family room was. Huge comfy couches. Perfect for relaxing and snuggling. The bedrooms were the perfect sized and decorated perfectly. The luxurious bathroom felt like it belonged in a 5 start hotel. Definitely stay here! You won't regret it!

Alex was a very gracious host. We had an easy check in and a great first night — the listing was as described and the location was very quiet and scenic. When a big snow storm hit and we had to leave early, Alex was quick to accommodate our early check out. Thank you for being a great host!

I rented this home for an extended stay while work was being done on my own home. What a perfectly appointed, charming home! I can’t say enough how well Lauren has laid out and decorated the space - embracing the original charm of this older home while insuring all modern comforts and conveniences. Some reviews mentioned the “steep” stairs. They are not so much steep, as they are the original stairs from (I believe) the early 1900s. So the steps’ depth is smaller by today’s standards. We had no problem making it up & down the stairs, finding it a bit easier to go sideways on the way down. Lauren was extremely responsive to all of my questions. Just as charming to deal with, as her home is charming to relax in! Thank you for a wonderful stay!

I had a great stay! The Airbnb met all my expectations—it was clean, comfortable, and very cozy. The space had everything I needed, and the atmosphere made it easy to relax. The owners were also super responsive and helpful with all my questions, which made the whole experience even better. I’d definitely stay here again!

Beautiful place My family loved it. Rented it for my daughter’s birthday weekend and she had a great birthday. Will be renting it again for my youngest daughter’s birthday . Felt like home.

If you are looking for something to disconnect from city or work this is the right place to go. Or even work from home while you enjoying nature. Amazing hosts. Alex, always responsive even at late hours. My dog was completely happy as well running around the Woods. A very nice, clean,cozy and quiet place, definitely will be my favorite place to go on weekends.

This charming cottage in Upstate NY is the perfect escape from city life. Surrounded by towering trees and nature’s tranquility, it offers a cozy, welcoming retreat. Inside, the rustic decor, soft lighting, and warm bed create the ultimate cozy atmosphere. The well-equipped kitchen and plush bed ensure comfort, making it easy to relax. The outdoor space is a highlight—sip coffee on the porch, stargaze , or explore nearby hiking trails. Whether you’re a couple, solo traveler, or small family, this peaceful retreat is a must-visit. Highly recommended!

Great amount of kids toys and kitchen supplies Beds were really comfortable but could use some extra blankets as it was a little cold at night. Check in and out was simple

Wish we could have stayed longer, but had to get back to real life. Ed's cottage was super well kept, quiet, and clean. Ed called to assist with check in and to offer recommendations for dining and sights. He left a light on for us and set the temperature so we would be comfortable when we arrived. Really appreciated speaking with him. This was one of the best experiences we've had in the area and we'd love to come back and explore the property when we have more time. Very highly recommend!

Rest Co. lives up to its name , due to bad weather conditions we were unable to do the activities we had planned in the area , so we stayed in the cottage and got Rest! Chris was very responsive and helpful before and during our trip. The cottage was very cozy and we felt right at home . The drinks in the restaurant were yummy and the steak was TOP NOTCH! I’m sad due to the bad weather we didn’t swim or do fires/s’mores but I guess that just means we need to come back .

Cute (nearly) tiny home had everything we needed for a great 2 night stay.

Such a beautiful place in a gorgeous setting. Clear communication from Victoria made it a sealed and highly enjoyable stay!!

Absolutely beautiful little spot to have a relaxing getaway. April was so accommodating and responsive. We would definitely come back!