Holiday rentals in Cayuta Lake

Naturalists' Retreat

Retreat to paradise at this cozy cottage in the heart of the Finger Lakes. Charming custom woodwork offers a unique, rustic aesthetic while modern amenities provide the comfort of home. Minutes from famous naturalist attractions in all directions. Enjoy the entire peaceful cottage and surrounding yard with outdoor seating, fire pit, and hot tub to yourself. Three acres of adjoining trails and creek shared with neighboring host family, who are fun-loving and approachable but respect your privacy.

A Treehouse -Falcon Nest

A Treehouse. Reconnect with nature at this unforgettable escape. Nestled in 28 acres of woods with hiking trails. This unique new construction all electric 525 square feet elevated structure offers a wrap around deck for an ever changing view. King size new technology foam bed offers complete comfort in separate climate controlled bedroom. Heated bathroom floor is a “warm” surprise. Optional outdoor shower for the adventurous spirit. Kitchen lacks nothing tucked conveniently in the great room.

FLX 3- Lake View Wine Country Tiny Cabin

Nestled up on a hill overlooking Seneca Lake, watch the sunset while laying in bed or from your own patio with a fire crackling. We are local hosts and will make sure you have an unforgettable stay! Everything you could want to do in the Finger Lakes will be at your fingertips. Wineries galore, two even just next door, multiple breweries nearby, minutes to the lake, 15 minutes to downtown Watkins Glen, 10 minutes to hiking trails at the national forest, or stay in, relax, and enjoy the view!

Finger Lakes Dropstar on Cayuta LAKEFRONT

Dropstar is a modern spacious 3300 square foot retreat in a peaceful setting on Cayuta Lake in the breathtaking NY Finger Lakes region. Immerse yourself in nature and see the best views of the entire lake through the enormous windows, sunbathing on private decks, fireside on the patio or fishing and swimming on the dock at Dropstar. Grill or cook for a crowd in the fully stocked gourmet kitchen, rest privately in 4 large appointed bedrooms and never wait with 3 full baths. LIVE, LOVE, LAKE!

Cabin @Sanctuary in the Woods in the Finger Lakes

Enjoy our forest in cabin w/queen bed near creek w/electricity, lights, portable heater, hammock, picnic table, fire pit w/grill, BBQ& chairs. A short walk uphill 2 outdoor hot water on demand private shower & toilet. Well water from sink & spiquot drinkable. No firewood can come in b/c of invasive species so we sell bundles on porch. Park next to cabin. Near Ithaca, Watkins Glen, State Parks- Treman, Buttermilk, Taughannock & Watkins Glen & 60 wineries/breweries around Lakes Seneca & Cayuga.

House on the Hill

A tiny house with the comforts of home. Single Bedroom stair free in-law suite with amazing sunsets and the feeling of being in the middle of the woods while still being close enough to enjoy a reasonable drive to some of the Finger Lakes best hiking trails, food, wineries and other destination locations. If you come in the winter you will want an all wheel drive vehicle if there is snow on the roads, but half a mile down the hill and you are on the state highway to the finger lakes region.

Lake Spirit-Lakefront-Hot tub-Pet friendly-Boats

Lake Spirit welcomes you & your pets year-round! This lakeside home provides a retreat-like experience, offering activities for every season. You can fish, ice fish, relax in the hot tub, enjoy the two decks and docks, the boats or explore the Finger Lakes region. Amenities include a Hot tub, BBQ, fireplace, fire pit, books, games, kayaks, canoe, and pedal boat. While off the beaten path, the property is conveniently located near renowned gorges, waterfalls, vineyards, and distilleries.

Secluded Yurt, Clean, Comfy Retreat in Nature

Relax in the circular comfort of the yurt nestled on the edge of woods & farm. 1/4 mile off the main road, enjoy quiet & convenient access to wineries, food, lakes & waterfalls. The yurt is clean, comfortable, and authentically rustic. Ample space and high-speed internet allow for working remotely or relaxing. Outside, enjoy the gardens, sip local wine on the deck as the sun sets, stargaze, nap in the hammock, or cozy up by the warmth of an evening bonfire, or the friendly farm dog.

Forest Glamping

Get away from it all when you stay under the stars in a large canvas bell tent with a real, full size bed. Tucked into the woods, just a short distance from Watkins Glen and the Seneca Wine Trail. The shared modern bath house is a short walk from the site with running potable water and a shower. The property is off grid (no electricity) which means excellent star gazing! Linens are provided. The site also has a fire pit with seating for relaxing. See “other details to note”