Holiday rentals in New Bethlehem

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in New Bethlehem

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Top guest favourite
The living room features a stunning stone fireplace as its centerpiece, surrounded by warm wooden walls and floors. A staircase crafted from logs leads to an upper level. Large windows allow natural light to fill the space, enhancing the lodge's rustic charm.
Home in Kennerdell
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 237 reviews

Misty Ridge - Kennerdell Getaway

Silence and solitude in beautiful NW Pennsylvania. This lodge offers a breathtaking view off the back deck, 600’ above the Allegheny River. A beautiful interior with a rustic feel. Plenty of wood work and a gorgeous stone fireplace in the center of the living room. The house is located only 2m from a boat launch on the Allegheny River, yet just 10m from WalMart. Come enjoy a peaceful stay in the great outdoors! Hiking, fishing, bike riding and more! If you're looking for serenity, this is it!

Guest favourite
Home in New Bethlehem
5 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews

Redbank Retreat • Waterfront • Hot Tub • Fire Pit

Redbank Creek Retreat is a newly renovated, creek-front escape featuring a hot tub, fire pit, room for up to 8. Savor peaceful mornings by the water, kayak or fish. It's just a short walk to hike, bike & explore the scenic Redbank Valley Trail. Two beautifully designed units in one stay offering comfort, style, and space to unwind. Located just 25 mi. from Cook Forest, it’s your cozy home base for adventure, special gatherings, or small-town exploring. Perfect for families, couples, or friends.

Top guest favourite
Home in Smicksburg
5 out of 5 average rating, 49 reviews

Cozy, historic 5-bedroom home in Amish country

It doesn’t take long to fall in love with the rolling hills and serene landscape of western PA. Residents are blessed to enjoy the year-round beauty of all four seasons, ranging from mild snowy winters to the breathtaking foliage of autumn. Built in 1870, this house is one of a kind. Some of its unique charm includes gorgeous wooden floors and hand-blown glass windows. As you relax in your room you’ll be swept away to another century as you hear the clip-clop of Amish buggies as they drive by.

Top guest favourite
Home in New Bethlehem
4.88 out of 5 average rating, 32 reviews

Countryside Comfort/ Spacious Home in Small Town.

Escape to Gaston's Getaway, a peaceful hilltop retreat just an hour north of Pittsburgh. This family home has been lovingly updated for guests with a king suite and luxurious master bath. Enjoy your morning coffee and amazing sunrises on the handcrafted porch. *Just added new 58" Roku TV on the porch for outdoor movies! * Perfect for families, couples or group getaways seeking small town charm with modern comfort. This 3 bed/2 bath home sleeps 8 with 2 kings, 1 full and full size air bed.

Guest favourite
The image showcases a cabin with a large wrap-around porch, surrounded by greenery. A family is seen hiking on a woodland trail, enjoying nature. Another section captures children jumping into a calm river from a wooden dock, while the last features adults and children on an ATV, highlighting outdoor recreational opportunities.
Home in Shippenville
4.84 out of 5 average rating, 220 reviews

Clarion River Timberframe Cabin

The cabin is located on 650 acres of privately owned forest accessing the Clarion River and the North Country Hiking Trail, minutes from downtown, Clarion. Take a few steps out the door and trek the North Country Trail along gentle pathways or exert a little more energy to see the Scenic Loops. Next, cool down on your dock on the Clarion River Lake. Swim, fish ,kayak, boat or just relax in the sun. Finish the day dining on he River Overlook deck, the campfire, or a fine local restaurant.

Top guest favourite
A well-lit living area features a comfortable gray sofa and an armchair, accompanied by a coffee table with magazines. A dining table with four chairs is nearby. In the background, a doorway leads to the bedroom, while wall art adds a touch of decor.
Flat in New Bethlehem
5 out of 5 average rating, 31 reviews

Inn-1 New Bethlehem Town Center

The updated historic 1915 building boasts a spacious 1 BR with individually controlled heat and AC and full kitchen. It is centrally located in New Bethlehem, PA fronting on the midpoint of the 51-mile Redbank Valley Trail just 65 miles from Pittsburgh via SR 28/66, 16 miles from I-80 Clarion exit 64, 18 miles from I-80 exit 78 in Brookville, walkable to many restaurants, with secure bike storage available and free parking on site. Self-service breakfast options are offered.

Top guest favourite
The kitchen features modern stainless-steel appliances, including a refrigerator and oven, complemented by granite countertops. A central wooden island provides ample workspace. The open layout includes a cozy seating area with a rug and a view of an adjacent window.
Flat in Clarion
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 135 reviews

Lake Como Suite - 2BR/1BA Downtown Clarion

Inspired by the beauty of Italy, the Lake Como Suite is centrally located on Main Street in downtown Clarion, PA on the 2nd floor above the historic retail clothing store F.L. Crooks & Co. Enjoy your stay in this 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom newly renovated and stylish apartment unit. Comfortable with thoughtful amenities, you will find everything you need to relax and appreciate your stay. The Lake Como suite includes its own private outdoor balcony. Free off-street parking.

Top guest favourite
A private deck features a hot tub surrounded by wooden decking and a wicker-egg chair. String lights above provide a soft glow, enhancing the expansive views of the surrounding landscape at sunset.
Cabin in Brookville
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 200 reviews

Skyline Serenity (Hot Tub, Panorama, King Bed)

Welcome to Skyline Serenity, where heaven meets earth. This brand-new cabin was constructed on the side of Heartwood Mountain, overlooking the Pennsylvania forests for miles and miles. Huge panoramic windows open your eyes to gorgeous views every morning and evening, creating a peaceful environment for you to completely relax as you enjoy your stay. -Hot tub -Beautiful views! -Soaking tub -Fire pit (firewood provided) -Private deck -Laundry room -Great hiking nearby!

Guest favourite
Home in New Bethlehem
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 22 reviews

Remember When

Welcome to our historic, 1920’s era, charming, two-story, 3 bedroom, 2 bath home, located in the quintessential, small town of New Bethlehem, PA. Here in “New B,” small-town festivals and Friday night high school football games are just a part of our DNA. Our home is just seconds from Redbank Valley bicycle trail, and within walking distance to downtown shops and restaurants, as well as fishing in the Redbank Creek.

Top guest favourite
An aerial view captures the modern guest house nestled amidst lush greenery, with the flowing Redbank Creek meandering nearby. Surrounding hills are covered in dense trees, creating a serene natural landscape that invites exploration and tranquility.
Guest house in Rimersburg
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 151 reviews

Bear Run Guesthouse

Come relax at our modern guest house with an amazing view of the Redbank Creek and surrounding hills. If you’re looking for some adventure, we’ve got over 3 miles of private trails for you to explore. And with more than 600 acres to roam, it’s pretty easy to wear yourselves out. So at the end of a long hike, soak in the hot tub overlooking the creek or build a fire and enjoy a quiet evening in the woods.

Top guest favourite
Flat in Kittanning
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 371 reviews

Old Meets New on Vine

Soak up the modern and vintage charm of this inviting 2 bedroom apartment. It is housed in our 1870s Victorian home with a private entrance to this second story unit. Located in the heart of Kittanning within walking distance to the Kittanning River Park, Rails to Trails and downtown shopping and restaurants. Kittanning is approximately 35 miles north of Pittsburgh.

Guest favourite
A red cottage with a white star on its facade is showcased under a clear sky. The covered porch, featuring wooden railings, offers seating and a barbecue grill. Large doors lead to the interior while the surrounding landscape includes open fields.
Cottage in Knox
4.91 out of 5 average rating, 202 reviews

One Level Home-The Cottage at Mitchell Ponds

15 minutes from Interstate 80–close enough for convenience but far enough away to have a quiet night! Contact host for seasonal weekday specials! Our cottage is a cozy, one floor home with an open floor plan. It is set in the back of the property for added privacy. Come enjoy the beautiful stars and country quiet at this quaint getaway!

Popular amenities for New Bethlehem holiday rentals