Cabin holiday rentals in New Buffalo

My family had a wonderful stay at the cabin. It was super walkable to the beach and restaurants, cute decor, and met the amenities in the description. We would definitely stay there again in the future.

Our stay was nothing short of amazing! The airbnb was so clean and so nice! We enjoyed our stay and would love to make the trip back up and stay again!

Our stay at Jason’s cabin was a 4/5 experience. While the cabin had potential, several issues impacted our visit. The biggest problem was the misleading description: we assumed each cabin was private based on the photos, but the fine print revealed it’s actually a shared community space. We spoke with other guests, and they had the same confusion. One cabin was told the sauna was private, while others were given shared-use instructions, which felt inconsistent. The hot tub area had a red ant infestation, and I ended up with several bites. Additionally, the property has multiple hosts, leading to unclear communication. One of the other occupants even shared pictures showing how unclean their cabin was, which raised concerns about cleanliness across the property. In our cabin, the floor was coming apart, which was disappointing. Knowing all this now, I’d consider staying again if I were more inclined to being social and sharing space with others. However it wasn’t quite what I expected

The place itself was nice and updated providing us with everything we needed. We loved that it was so close to everything. And it was a bonus to have the pickleball court, firepit, and hot tub.

I cannot say enough great things about this place! Perfect little retreat! Comfy beds, super clean and cozy. We'll most definitely be back!

We had a great time! Great place! Everything was easy!

Very cute place! Definitely recommend! Monica responded quickly & was helpful.

Thank you for letting us stay at your lovely home on Easter weekend! We loved the place and felt like home. Lots of light and the home structure and decor is very special and cozy. Callie was very welcoming and responsive. We were very close to wineries at Baroda county and St. Joseph. We look forward to come back soon!

Had a wonderful restorative weekend here. Would come back !

Cute log cabin, a bit rustic, but it added to the charm. Portia was very responsive to questions & helpful.

wow! this place is dog and people paradise. the yard is beautiful and spacious for our dogs to run - they stay close and it look amazing with the snow. love her style and felt very cozy and at home! Had what we needed and gave helpful suggestions and tips. thank you and would love to stay again!

We stayed for a long weekend, the cabin was super cute and had everything we needed and more! We spent a good deal of time playing the many games there, especially the street fighter game! We also used the bikes provided and loved exploring the nearby trails. We will plan on coming back when it's a little warmer so we can take advantage of the lake!

We were very thankful for a quiet and clean place to lay our heads during our trip. It met our needs.

The cabin was perfect for a couple looking to escape to Lake Michigan. Set back in the trees a bit, it really does feel secluded. The large windows throughout the home mean we almost never had to use lights until it was really dark out. Easy walking access to the beach. Short drives can take you up to New Buffalo or down to Michigan City. Only thing to be careful about driving is to look out for wild life. Deer like to eat right next to the roads and can startle as your car approaches. 10/10 would recommend staying here. Jen’s guide book and recommendations were 100% spot on.

This is a very cozy cabin by a beautiful lake, featuring panoramic windows and lots of interesting interior details. The location is very convenient yet secluded from other houses. The only thing I didn’t realize when booking is that there are no doors. Just something to keep in mind when making your reservation. Thank you, Ryan!

Liz was an absolute wonderful host! We booked this Airbnb to celebrate our mom’s birthday and mine and my husband’s anniversary and it was PERFECT! We had access to plenty of water toys and kayaks! Every night we sat in the enclosed patio and enjoyed the views. Liz even left us fresh tomatoes, cucumbers, and peppers that we used to make a beautiful garden salad! We are vegetarians so it was truly a treat! We would definitely recommend this home to any family and we look forward to renting here again!

Our stay for the bachelor party was a great time and the vibes were immaculate during our stay!

We really enjoyed our visit - it was so lovely to have a view of the pond, enjoy the firepit, walk through the woods, and of course check in on the chickens, goats, and llama that we could also see through our windows! It was very quiet and Bill was very helpful in answering our questions. We soaked in the jacuzzi while it snowed and rained outside and found the kitchen to have all the cookware and utensils we needed (we brought our own salt, pepper, oil, etc.) Thank you!

Great spot, close enough to more touristy areas for activities, public beaches and restaurants, but far enough away for peace and quiet. Our family of four had more than enough space and we really enjoyed the place. The property’s pool was great, and the private beach was really nice as well. Dena was always responsive whenever we had questions. Thanks for sharing your space with us!

My wife and I rented this cabin for our anniversary weekend. Absolutely loved the privacy and setting in the woods! Dave/Karyn paid attention to the little details that made our stay extra special. Plenty of wood and supplies for the fire pit, Alexa speaker, plenty of towels and linens, YoutubeTV. They also delivered flowers to the cabin that I sent to their home. There are tons of things to do in the area. 15 minutes from Lake Michigan. This property is a great value!

We loved this cabin! Very quiet & peaceful. We felt like we were in the middle of nowhere but we were still close to several cute towns. Well stocked kitchen and bathrooms. We would absolutely stay here again!

Great little cabin with a cute theme. It had lots of amenities, which were appreciated. It was very clean and we felt at home while staying at the cabin.