
Holiday rentals in New Castle
Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb
Top-rated holiday rentals in New Castle
Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

Spacious 3 Bedroom Home - New Castle
This home is equipped with everything you need for a relaxing stay. Unwind in the living room while watching your 65” TV. Prepare a meal in the fully equipped kitchen. The home offers a King, Full, and 2 Twin size beds. All 3 bedrooms are fitted with room darkening curtains. If you need a quick start, grab a shot of espresso on the way out the door. For a slow morning, pour yourself a cup of coffee and relax on the large back deck. The fully equipped laundry area offers washer, dryer, and iron.

The Muncie Guesthouse: Unit 2
Come stay at the historic Phillips-Johnson House, a local historic landmark, located in the Old West End neighborhood of Muncie's Downtown. This home went through a complete interior remodel / exterior facelift in 2019 and offers modern accommodations paired with historic charm. The heart of downtown is just a 5 minute walk away. The property features 3 units and you have the entire unit #2 to yourself. This property also conveniently features a large onsite parking lot for easy arrival.

Cute Studio in Old West End
Enjoy a budget-friendly experience at this cozy apartment in Muncie's Old West End neighborhood. Close to downtown hotspots and a short hop to BSU/hospital. Perfect for 1-2 guests. Newly renovated and stylish; all art in the apartment is by local artists. *Please note*, there are no exceptions to the “nonrefundable” option if you choose it. Please research our neighborhood before booking - our prices reflect our location in a diverse, populated urban neighborhood that is being revitalized.

The Eagles Nest, two bedroom retreat.
Peaceful, centrally-located historic 1892 Queen Anne Victorian home. The Eagle's Nest has private entrance, off street parking, 2 bedrooms, furnished suite on the 2nd floor overlooking White River. Walk 0.6 miles to downtown Muncie, less than 2 miles to Ball State Univ. and 2 blocks to the Bob Ross Experience (Minnetrista). Nearby eatery and brewery options. Just 29 steps to 62-mile Cardinal Greenway, longest trail in Indiana. Might see an eagle hunting along the river too. You will love it!

Maxwell-Commons #105, New Castle IN, 2bd2bth dwntn
#105 Maxwell-Commons: downtown LOFT for business, family, pleasure - HAVEN for peace. Wild party? PLEASE go elsewhere. Nea: HC Saddle Club; Go-Karts; NC High School; Hall of Fame. Indianapolis 50min; Richmond 30min; Muncie, Anderson 20min. Bring toiletries. Coffee available. THERE ARE STAIRS. 3 or 100s of guest voiced complaint re overnight trains. I am powerless over the midwest rail-schedules. It is fair to let would-be guests know. There are 2 assigned outdoor parking-spaces.

Private Apartment-800sq ft Next to Earlham College
Upper level separate apartment. Short stroll to Earlham College campus, ball fields, tennis courts, stables and Athletic Center. 5 houses up from the President's house. Windows galore offer natural lighting. Quiet neighborhood. Hardwood floors give that cozy feeling. Guaranteed clean and private. Well-behaved pets welcome. Breakfast not included. Coffee, tea, microwave, toaster oven and refrigerator in apartment. Host lives in lower apartment with dog and 2 cats. Chickens in the back yard.

New Hagerstown Apartment-Self Check-in. Sleeps 4+
Have fun with the whole family at this stylish place. Whether you are looking to visit family in the area or just wanting a small-town vibe to escape to, my welcoming apartment has everything you need. The unit comes with AC, Wi-Fi, Netflix, a private bathroom, and a fully stocked kitchen. Located in the heart of Hagerstown, the unit is blocks away from the local shops and restaurants on Main Street. My adorable apartment offers a deck, grill, pull-out couch, Keurig, and more!

A country night under the stars!
Get away from it all when you stay under the stars. Join us for a peaceful country stay, close enough to drive to nearby shopping and dining, and far enough to hear the crickets and see the stars. Your cozy place will include a kitchenette, coffee pot, microwave & TV. The dining area inside or on the attached deck, full size bed & full bath with shower. Only 3.9 miles from Interstate 70. Should you choose to use 100-foot zipline to exercise your pet.

Studio by Falls Park
Welcome to the Studio by Falls Park. This is a family-friendly studio apartment with a separate entrance. You are within walking distance to several good restaurants and the local drinking hole (The Wine Stable), Falls Park, walking trails. Located 10 minutes off I-69, and 20 minutes North of Indianapolis. Harrah’s casino is 15 minutes North on I-69. Studio has shower/bath, 1 queen bed, a full size futon, queen size blowup mattress and kitchen.

Greenfield CountryCottage-minutes to downtown Indy
Beautiful, relaxing country cottage room is a perfect place to stay for your business trip or vacation. We provide clean and comfortable furnishings, along with a kitchenette and coffee bar. You will have total privacy, including a private driveway and entrance. Relax on the balcony with your morning coffee or after a busy day. Our room is located on a 2nd story with a private stairway to the entrance. Special discount on stays 3 days or more!

Entire Home in Cambridge City
This spacious ground level home is located at the heart of antique alley in Cambridge City, Indiana. This fully remodeled home is equipped with everything you will need for a relaxing stay. Including central air, 2 bedrooms, 1 bath, full kitchen, smart television, Wi-Fi, washer/dryer, outdoor patio, and grill. The home is just a few minute walk away from the downtown shops, restaurants, and entertainment.

White River Retreat
Escape to a private retreat on the White River in Indianapolis! This custom-built home offers a peaceful, open-concept space with a stone fireplace, pool table, and jetted tub. Enjoy 12 acres of shared grounds with river access, kayaks, and fire pits. Perfect for a unique getaway, feeling worlds away yet close to everything. Ideal for couples or small groups seeking tranquility and adventure.
Popular amenities for New Castle holiday rentals
Other great holiday rentals in New Castle

Room 2 - Clean and Private Bedroom in Fishers

Historical country estate guest house on 10 acres

Backyard Barndominium

Downtown Muncie | Luxe Loft, Spa Bath, 1 Bed, BSU

Little Longhorn Lodge

Studio Apartment for Rent

Private B&B #2- Monét's Water Lily, Cambridge City

15 Mi to Summit Lake State Park: Updated Apt!
Quick stats about holiday rentals in New Castle

Total holiday rentals
Explore 10 holiday rentals in New Castle

Nightly prices starting at
New Castle holiday rentals start at £30 per night before taxes and fees

Verified guest reviews
Over 940 verified reviews to help you choose

Wifi availability
10 of New Castle holiday rentals include wifi access

Popular amenities for guests
Guests love Kitchen, Wifi and Pool across New Castle rentals

4.9 Average rating
New Castle stays are highly rated by guests – averaging 4.9 out of 5!
Destinations to explore
- Chicago Holiday rentals
- Nashville Holiday rentals
- Northeast Ohio Holiday rentals
- Downtown Chicago Holiday rentals
- Indianapolis Holiday rentals
- Pittsburgh Holiday rentals
- Southern Indiana Holiday rentals
- Detroit Holiday rentals
- St. Louis Holiday rentals
- Columbus Holiday rentals
- Louisville Holiday rentals
- Cleveland Holiday rentals
- Lucas Oil Stadium
- Eagle Creek Park
- Indianapolis Zoo
- Indianapolis Motor Speedway
- Summit Lake State Park
- The Fort Golf Resort
- Mounds State Park
- Brickyard Crossing
- Country Moon Winery
- River Glen Country Club
- Woodland Country Club
- Prairie View Golf Club
- The Sagamore Club
- Ironwood Golf Course
- Crooked Stick Golf Club
- Greatimes Family Fun Park
- Hopwood Cellars Winery & William Rose Distillery
- Broadmoor Country Club
- Marion Splash House
- Adrenaline Family Adventure Park
- The Hawthorns Golf and Country Club
- Bridgewater Club
- Urban Vines Winery & Brewery




