Skip to content
Sign up
Log in
Vacation rentals in Preston-Potter Hollow

Vacation rentals in Preston-Potter Hollow

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Preston-Potter Hollow

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

  • 1800's Farmhouse near Windham & Catskill Mountains
    SUPERHOSTEntire house · 6 guests · 3 beds · 1.5 bathrooms
    1800's Farmhouse near Windham & Catskill Mountains

    Enjoy our renovated Farmhouse that has been lovingly restored. 12 acres of fields and woods are yours to explore. Plus enjoy the creek that borders the property with beautiful views. There are about a dozen cows that live next door, about 200 feet from the Farmhouse. And horses live across the street on the other side. Located less then 7 minutes from East Durham (Zoom Flume) and 20 minutes from Windham. A perfect getaway for a family with children/teens or group of outdoorsy friends.

    What guests are saying:

    “I happen to be a super host myself so I know what to expect and Kathleen’s home and hospitality is the reason why she was given the accolades of a super host. Everything she described in her listing was 100% accurate however you can’t really tell how special this place is until you actually stay there the house was warm and cozy with all the proper amenities it was on a beautiful sprawling property that you could hike around the property and it feels like you’re in another world. It was very close to the ski mountain as well as good restaurants and very easy to get to with just a couple turns off of some main roads. Although she allows pets in this home which is one of the reasons why we picked it you could never tell that She allows pets as there is no signs of any animals in the house at all which is fantastic because I hate houses that smell like animals even though I have multiple dogs. And the cows and horses adjacent to the property or an extra special treat that only for my dog but for the kids as well we hope to stay here again someday soon thank you again Kathleen for a great experience at a very reasonable rate.”

  • The Elsbree House - Northern Catskills
    SUPERHOSTEntire house · 6 guests · 3 beds · 1.5 bathrooms
    The Elsbree House - Northern Catskills

    The Elsbree House is located in the great Northern Catskills in the historic hamlet of Preston Hollow. This well-tended 1882 Victorian house boast access to modern amenities but with old world charm. It is located within close proximity to numerous options for dining and activities such as skiing, boating, fishing, hiking, antiquing and flea markets. The Elsbree House is perfect for couples, solo adventurers, wedding guests, or anyone looking to get out of the city and enjoy country living.

    What guests are saying:

    “Spent a few days at the Elsbree House with some friends to celebrate my wedding! Everyone was appreciative of the house's character and charm. The owners have done such an amazing job at preserving the history of this house. Rafael was a wonderful virtual host, responding promptly and providing local recommendations! In between all the festivities, we cooked both in the spacious kitchen and on the outdoor charcoal grill, and got a chance to enjoy the surrounding nature (check out Vroman's Nose in Middleburgh, and Rensselaerville Falls/Huyck Preserve) as well as the Livingstonville flea market. Don't miss out on this historic home and all the beauty in and around it! Thanks, Rafael!”

  • Casa Bella Vista with Great Views.
    SUPERHOSTEntire house · 6 guests · 3 beds · 1.5 bathrooms
    Casa Bella Vista with Great Views.

    Quaint and cozy cabin sitting on 7 acres with large Koi pond and pergola. You can enjoy wildlife sightings anytime of the day and spectacular views of the Catskill Mountains!

    What guests are saying:

    “Lucy & Mike's place was an absolute steal. We booked barely 12 hours in advance of our stay, and they were incredibly generous with both their rate of and amount of communication. The place itself is gorgeous, exactly as advertised. The property is huge and makes for a mini adventure itself. We had a car with us, so it made things like grocery shopping and accessing hiking very simple. Their place has tons of nature and privacy with the right touch of modern amenities (up to a dishwasher!). The water source is from a well, and it tastes....exactly like water. Delicious. Wifi is touch-and-go as they mention, but it's really not what you should be wanting among all the quietude. We lacked absolutely nothing. We'll definitely book again soon. Thank you again, Lucy & Mike!!”

Holiday rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you.

  • Homes
  • Hotels
  • Unique stays

Popular amenities for Preston-Potter Hollow holiday rentals

  • Kitchen
  • Wifi
  • Pool
  • Free parking on premises
  • Air conditioning

Other great holiday rentals in Preston-Potter Hollow

The Elsbree House - Northern Catskills
SUPERHOSTEntire house
The Elsbree House - Northern Catskills
Price:£121 / night
Casa Bella Vista with Great Views.
SUPERHOSTEntire house
Casa Bella Vista with Great Views.
Price:£104 / night
Glamping the Sun Barn in the Catskill Mountains
Barn
Glamping the Sun Barn in the Catskill Mountains
Price:£70 / night
Cozy Cabin in the Catskill Mtns (Dog Friendly)
SUPERHOSTTiny house
Cozy Cabin in the Catskill Mtns (Dog Friendly)
Price:£50 / night
Private Apartment in 1810 Building
Entire flat
Private Apartment in 1810 Building
Price:£57 / night
Private, Unique Log Cabin in the Woods
Entire cabin
Private, Unique Log Cabin in the Woods
Price:£81 / night
1800's Farmhouse near Windham & Catskill Mountains
SUPERHOSTEntire house
1800's Farmhouse near Windham & Catskill Mountains
Price:£109 / night
The Perfect Winter Time Getaway w/Hot tub & Sauna
SUPERHOSTEntire house
The Perfect Winter Time Getaway w/Hot tub & Sauna
Price:£75 / night
Peaceful Mountainview Studio Apt
SUPERHOSTEntire guest suite
Peaceful Mountainview Studio Apt
Price:£65 / night
Mountain TOP  Studio
SUPERHOSTEntire flat
Mountain TOP Studio
Price:£121 / night
Shuttle Bus converted into Charming Tiny Home
SUPERHOSTPrivate room
Shuttle Bus converted into Charming Tiny Home
Price:£36 / night
Country Cabin in the Catskills   (Dog Friendly)
SUPERHOSTTiny house
Country Cabin in the Catskills (Dog Friendly)
Price:£45 / night
Show all