Cabin holiday rentals in Seneca County

The cabin exceeded our expectations. It was a rainy weekend but with the hot tub, games to play, available books and plenty of natural light- it didn’t feel dreary. We commented a few times on how quiet and comfortable the space was for us. We took advantage of the local recommendations for food, wine and beer tastings and enjoyed it all! There was a guest log book and the recs from other guests helped guide us also. We went there to reconnect and spend time with each other for an early anniversary trip. (17 years next month) and we got exactly what we wanted! The hosts were attentive and friendly. Would definitely stay there again! But now I also need to buy a Blackstone grill and hot tub for home. 😂

Gray’s place was extremely calm and serene, exactly what my girlfriend and I were looking for! This place had everything we needed to relax as much as possible while also enjoying the property and some time outdoors. Truly a nice little gem in the woods!

This is a beautiful and peaceful bungalow! My husband and I enjoyed a very relaxing weekend at Seneca Lake.

This was a fantastic weekend getaway for us and everything was just as described. Very, VERY nice. One small suggestion: perhaps one of those big thermometers nailed to a tree to fond the AM temp?

Great Stay Great Cabin! Everything was clean we felt comfortable there. The hot tub was great after the 2.4 mile walk at Watkins glen. It was too cold for us to kayak but it was nice sitting by the water and chilling. Loved the sound of the water at night.

You will want to book this place if you are in the area for hiking, wineries, lake activities, anything really! That's because it's in the perfect location and, at the same time, you'll feel like you have your own private retreat because the cabin is set back from the road with peaceful surroundings. The enclosed porch with hot tub put it over the top - don't hesitate to book, hosts were great and even let me check in early!

We had an amazing time at Eshay’s Cabin. It’s in a lovely location. Close to all the beautiful swimming holes and Georges in Ithaca. We will definitely be back. Thank you Eshay.

This place is beautiful looks even nicer in person than on the pictures . It’s very peaceful and fairly easy to find they left little notes around the house to find extra linens toilet paper etc which was a very cute touch . has a lot of stuff to do outside and inside it is the perfect little get together cabin the host is very nice helpful and attentive with any questions you may have through the stay definitely recommend

A wonderful comfortable cabin in secluded location while being centrally located to all the sites and parks looking to visit. Well stocked and everything is in working order. Topping it all off was fresh breakfast delivered each morning of our stay. (Breakfast is if you stay in the Cedar cabin). We would definitely return here if back in area again.

Nick was an excellent host. Very responsive to messages and available anytime I reached out. Would definitally stay again!

Awesome spot! Very close to all of our favorite vineyards and breweries my wife and I love to visit. More importantly our dog Bandit was comfortable in the cabin. Fully stocked kitchen to make any meal with ease. Highly recommend this Airbnb and will be back when we run out of wine!

Overall we enjoyed the place. Cute cabin, located away from the city traffic!! Couple of suggestions/ feedback for the readers and the host. 1) it can’t fit 16 people. Only 8 people can comfortably sleep. The description has to be corrected. If camping is allowed on the property, it has to be mentioned in the description. 2) driving directions could be better. It gives hard time to find the cabin, especially in the dark. GPS Coordinates would be better. 3) Cabin is lacking ventilation. During our visit, it was full with paint odor. It took some time to adjust. 4) it is a smoke-free cabin. The description has to be corrected. 5) it is far from everywhere, you will need a vehicle.

Suzanne is a very kind host and answered messages promptly. Her cabin is so cute, very clean, and in an amazing location. Beautiful views at sunrise and sunset, and close to the nearby restaurants/wineries. We made the mistake of arriving after sunset, which made it a bit difficult to find where to turn on the grass. We would definitely recommend getting there while it’s still bright outside!

Stayed for my partners birthday, the cabin and property were beautiful! It was super easy to find and enter, the Magic Castle staff were quick to provide information to make our stay comfortable. Charcoal and firewood for grill and fire pit were easily accessible and the hot tub was clean and so relaxing! They bring breakfast in the morning, the homemade donuts were amazing! We brought our dog and they had so many resources available including a lead for the yard. All and all we had a great time and will be returning!

Great location. Spacious cabin 7. Check in & check out couldn’t be easier. Very responsive and friendly hosts. We would definitely stay again

We had a great stay in Paulette's cozy little cabin. The space is small but it was just what we needed for our girls weekend at the wineries. We built a fire with the wood supplied by Paulette and we had a very nice view of the lake. Would definitely come back and recommend to others.

Cheryl’s cabin was an excellent place to stay for exploring the Finger Lakes. Just minutes from multiple wineries and close to some great hiking. The cabin was even nicer than it looks in the pictures, everything was very clean and neat. There are two other cabins on the property but we were never bothered by noise and it still felt very private. It wasn’t quite warm enough to utilize the dock by the lake yet but we walked down there a few times and it was absolutely lovely. I’m sure it makes for a great time during summer! Cheryl was extremely proactive and responsive before and during our stay. She answered our questions quickly and let us know some good dog walking spots nearby. If you are looking for a dog-friendly rental in the finger lakes I would absolutely recommend this cabin!

Cute little cabin close to wineries and breweries. Check in was very easy. Everything was very clean and in good condition. Great space for family of 8. Winery right across the street. Nice walk to the lake access, steps are a bit steep to the dock as shown in photos. Only suggestion is maybe an extra couch/big chair for the living space so everyone can sit comfortably in the living area together. We loved Three brothers winery, Tin Barn brewing has beautiful views, and Seneca stag has great beer, which is very close to the house. Thanks for a great stay!