House holiday rentals in Setauket- East Setauket

This is the 2nd Thanksgiving weekend we spent at Deeanna's. Her home is beautiful, comfortable and each detail is thought though in the best way. Deeanna went above and beyond to accommodate my family and we are so grateful to her. The kitchen is perfection and the bedrooms are lovely and comfortable. The scenery and views are breathtaking. Overall, this home is a total gem. Thank you, Deeanna! We hope to come back next year!

We had a wonderful stay. Cute and comfortable house in an amazing location. Very comfortable for a family of 4.

My family and I had a beautiful stay and I couldn’t have asked for a better rental. The Airbnb was huge with more than enough room for everyone and the backyard was large and spacious enough to have everyone eat comfortably. If I ever need another large rental you can bet I’m gonna check here first.

We had an amazing stay at Michael’s Airbnb this past weekend! The space was exactly as described—clean, cozy, and well-equipped with everything we needed. Michael was a fantastic host: super responsive, thoughtful, and made us feel completely at home. The location was perfect for a relaxing getaway, and the setting was even more beautiful in person. Would absolutely stay here again—thank you for a wonderful experience, Michael!

I was in Dion’s place with my family we really enjoyed the time we spent there,everything was perfect the pool was something that my kids enjoyed a lot, and hopefully we will come back again, for sure I totally recommend his house if you want to go and have a couple days of fun and relax thank you again Dion.

Sarah was wonderful as a host and the home was very well maintained in a beautiful neighborhood. Thank you!

We absolutely loved staying at Christine’s beautiful home! The place was immaculate, and we particularly enjoyed the pool and fire pit. The location was perfect—situated in a quiet neighborhood, close to great restaurants, and within walking distance of the water. Christine was an amazing host, letting us check in early and check out late. She also texted to make sure we had everything we needed and were enjoying our stay. She even stopped by to share some great recommendations and ensure we knew how to use the house and pool code. We had a fantastic experience and would highly recommend this Airbnb to anyone looking for a relaxing and enjoyable stay!

We had a wonderful two day stay at Roger and Amy’s place. It was fantastic- such a beautiful, inviting home. Our kids had a blast in the heated pool- we could barely get them to come out despite it being under 60 degrees out! The kitchen was stocked with more than just kitchen basics- the spice cabinet had soo many different choices ! It was probably the most perfect AirBnb experience I’ve had and we travel plenty.

Everything was great. The home as exactly as advertised, clean and in a prime location. Highly recommend.

Staying at Amy's place was perfect for my friends and I while we're out on the North Fork for a wedding. Amy was very responsive with any questions we had. We were all very comfortable in the main living area as well as our bedrooms. The house was conveniently located to the wedding venue and my friends were also very happy that it was located near some pickleball courts. Thank you Amy for a wonderful stay.

So glad we stayed at John's beachfront home. We wanted a way to escape the noise and chaos of a large city and this was the perfect fit. Granted the commute is longer, but we couldn't get enough of the amazing ferry ride from Rockaway to Manhattan/Wall Street. Such a great way to explore NYC.

The apartment met all expectations. I felt very comfortable. The bed was insanely comfortable so I could sleep very well. Of course, the way to Manhattan from Rockaway Beach is not the shortest, but I knew that in advance. Within 75 minutes I was "in the middle" of whether I went by train or boat. Supermarket and the recommended "restaurant" are also within walking distance (5 minutes). Even as a woman traveling alone, I felt safe in the area. The fact that you were on the beach within a few minutes' walk in the most beautiful weather was rounded off.

Great space. Wonderful communication with host regarding any questions we had. Host was quick to respond. Very happy with the stay, would rent again.

We had a great time at this lovely, antique home, complete with gardens and great big back yard! Bob, our Corgi, definitely approved! Easy access to Stamford and Bedford! Thanks for your thoughtful arrangements!

The inside and outside areas were meticulously maintained. The weather was great, so we were able to really enjoy the pool and deck. Michelle was extremely responsive and did a great job with instructions, recommendations, and communications. One member of our party needed to work a few days, and the office space in the basement was perfect.

This is our 2nd review Victoria’s properties and we just want to reiterate how special of a landlord Victoria is. The best. I cannot recommend her properties enough if you are in need of a Greenwich rental like we were.

It was an amazing experience. Wonderful Stay. Tomi was a gracious host. The place smelled amazing and very clean. I would love to stay here again and recommend it to everyone who is interested. 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽

The stay was great. Our host was accommodated and great with communication. Would love to come back!

Very respectable, responsive and courteous couple! Proactive in solving your issues. Felt like home

This house was exactly what our group was looking for. It sleeps 12 people comfortably and it’s very large. A quick walk from the jitney with 5 parking spots, it was perfect for all guests and their respective method of transportation. The backyard is also VERY spacious. There’s a grill, tennis court, etc. plenty of things to do — there’s never really a reason to leave during your stay. The house also has really nice energy. It’s quaint, gets beautiful light and is really charming! I would stay here again :)

we rented La Spiaggia in December, and while it's mostly going to be more beautiful and better in the summer (since it's a beach house) it was still perfectly fine in the winter; well insulated and with good strong heaters. speaking of the beach I can't stress enough of how close this place is to the water; I'm talking literally ten steps to the sand. I would certainly recommend the place as a great summer getaway!

My family and I have stayed at a ton of different airbnbs, vrbos and vacation rentals both stateside and abroad and I have to say Anne’s property is among one of the best we’ve stayed in. We were traveling with twin toddlers and the space was perfect. Anne is very friendly, the place is larger than we expected, very clean and you can tell Anne cares to the make the best experience possible. All the little touches were so wonderful - she has beach chairs, reusable beach bags, sunscreen, books, kids toys, coloring accessories, balls and toys, an outdoor game, hammock, lanterns, lights, fire pit and wood, you name it - it’s there. It was one of the most convenient stays we’ve had. We’d love to return and I couldn’t recommend it enough!!

We had a lovely stay. JP was extremely responsive and accommodating. The house was exactly as stated in the listing. We would stay there again if in the area.

We loved our stay! Dylan was extremely responsive and the home was exactly as explained. The rooms were spacious and the beds were so comfy! No complaints! We will definitely stay again when we visit family.