Holiday rentals with a fire pit in Shelter Island Heights

This was a truly beautiful home that was perfect for our week along the coast of Connecticut. The home was impeccably clean and setup with an amazing bathroom and kitchen. Set in a peaceful area north of Niantic, it was a perfect place for my family and I to head out to many coastal adventures. We had close access to Mystic and New Haven with a short road trip to Newport. Jason and Colleen were wonderful hosts and have setup their place amazingly easy to get in and utilize. From the available bikes in the basement to the games my kids quickly found to play, this was a perfect place for us this week. Highly recommend to others looking for a great CT coastline getaway!

Came for a one week spring break stay with my 7 year old, husband, sister and dog. The home is well-appointed and thoughtfully furnished and decorated to be cozy and comfortable. The house is right on the lake and offers beautiful views from everywhere you are. Weather was up and down (as April can be!) but there was plenty to do not far away, and a selection of games to keep us busy, in addition to those we brought. Thoughtful touches throughout the house! Morning coffee on the deck overlooking the lake with birdsong and ducks swimming by was a particularly peaceful highlight. Look forward to returning during warmer months for evening wine outside and more bites when we fish! A great stay - book this place!

Ashley’s place was absolutely incredible for our girls weekend in Montauk. Impeccably clean, spacious, and tastefully furnished. The hot tub was perfect after a winter hike, and the firepit was great for s’mores and stargazing at night. There was also an indoor fireplace in the living room where we had a couple of really fun movie nights. The kitchen is a dream, and very well equipped with everything you would ever need to cook a fabulous meal. The spacious open plan kitchen/dining area/living room was perfect for communal cooking and hanging out. Gets great light and such a pretty view. The bedrooms were super comfortable and the master has an amazing tub. The location was perfect. Right in town and a short walk to the beach (also walking distance to the brewery!), but also felt very private. Lastly, Ashley was an excellent host- very communicative and helpful and super sweet- she even left a treat for us in the fridge when we arrived! Will definitely be coming back to stay at

Very nice house with lots of room to relax and a well-stocked kitchen to cook. The house was clean and the beds were comfortable. The neighborhood is quiet and close to so much! When we had a question, Ellen answered with a call within minutes. She was the perfect host!

Our family opted for a trip to New London to reconnect with our family for Thanksgiving. We were able to utilize the beautiful dining room for our dinner . We loved staying at Rosa’s place and were very comfortable . Just a note - there is only one bathroom and it is on the second floor ( as are all the bedrooms) We made this work but can be difficult with a larger family . It would definitely not deter me from booking again! This place was beautiful. The surrounding area and ease of access was comforting ! Would definitely stay here again .

It's our second time staying at Joe's. We only stayed one night as we were heading out to Block Island, but it's a lovely house with a cute downtown and lots of great restaurants and local businesses. We love Westerly!

Mariza's house was not only beautiful on the inside, but on the outside aswell. We felt very welcome from the moment we stepped foot into her home. We had lots of room for everyone, which was nice. I would highly recommend it!

The house was as advertised and well appointed and comfortable. I would stay again. Our family had a very nice memorable long weekend.

Our stay at the Boathouse was just what we needed, a quiet retreat with a comfortable bed, all the amenities we could ask for. A warm welcome from Curran, and attentive to our needs and comfort. We will likely return to the Boathouse on our return visits to visit family in the area.

Viviana's place was the perfect stay. It was incredibly clean and included everything you could need. We traveled with our 1-year-old and there was a pack-n-play already setup for him. We felt safe, welcome, and really enjoyed our stay. We appreciated the private entrance, private parking, and clear/detailed instructions. I cannot recommend it more.

Our stay was perfect at Scott's place, we felt right at home, everything matched the description and photos. The fire pit on the patio is a great option to relax while taking in fresh air. I would definitely recommend Scott's place to anyone. Everything was excellent.

We stayed here for 6 days and it was the perfect spot! She had everything we needed & it was a beautiful place to spend our vacation. Erica was extremely responsive whenever we had questions for her. We would definitely come stay here again!!

My friend and I stayed at Clare’s Airbnb in Montauk over the weekend, and she was one the nicest and most attentive hosts we have stayed with. Our room was really nice and contained everything we needed to have a very comfortable time. We really appreciated Clare for her very friendly hospitality and for going above and beyond for us whenever we needed her for something. And she was so lovely to our dog, Chi Chi ☺️ We will def stay at her place again if we make another visit to Montauk! 🐶🐾💕

The house was beautiful in a very nice quiet neighborhood. It felt very safe and was just a 5-10 drive into Main Street. The bedrooms and bathrooms were clean and very confortable. We had our dog with us and it was a great location for taking him in nice walks around the neighborhood. Really great location. Jennifer was very proactive in messaging us everything we needed to know before we arrived.

Really chill and laid back place to enjoy a weekend getaway. Host are great at communication and definitely will come back..

Amazing Airbnb! Eli’s place is comfortable and clean, with amazing views of the lake. Close drive to town, beach, and train. And Eli is flexible and easy to communicate with. We had a great time!

I had an amazing stay. The house was nice and very clean with everything I needed. The host was responsive and got back to me within minutes to provide me with items I needed or answer any questions I had. Overall it was peaceful and I highly recommend staying here.

Clean and cozy cabin. Close to Mystic without being right in the thick of it. We enjoyed a night by the fire with a friendly local fisherman. It worked nicely for our short trip to the area.

Great spot. We weren’t there to take advantage of the little marina and kayaks— though that would have been cool! Had a weekend event in New London and this was very easy, super straightforward and quiet. Thank you, Paul!

Place was amazing! Had a comfortable and peaceful stay. Is a beautiful home and close to everything that is needed. Loved how private it was and how clean everything was. Highly recommend.

The cabin was just what I needed for a long weekend. It had everything you needed while inside such an authentic type of space. Keith was proactive and super responsive. Would definitely come back!

We had a fabulous time! Can't wait to come back. Was equally perfect for two toddlers as it was for four adults! Beautiful property, amazing hot tub, comfortable beds, great kitchen... everything was lovely.

A wonderful spot and wonderful host. Everything was cheery and thoughtfully done. I knocked off a star for the price mostly because I wasn't anticipating how expensive it is to get around by Uber in the area, and to find an accessible grocery store - otherwise necessary to have a car. Ended up ordering UberEats... my mom was at another Airbnb down the road and the difference in how we were treated as guests was astronomical. Marina did not charge me for having my little dog, there was a little firewood for us to use, fresh coffee and tea, and all the amenities! Marina was also very responsive and kind, and left a very helpful note about whether the beach is public or not. 100% recommend. In contrast, my mom felt badly treated by the host, the place was poorly kept and she felt it was way overpriced in comparison to mine (Marina's). Good thing she was able to come here during the day, and we spent most of our time here, in the yard or the short walk to the beach.