Holiday rentals with lake access in Sylvan Beach

Tolus house was perfectly lovely as is Tolus. Everything was spotless clean and a lot of thought went into all the extra amenities. We felt very much at home. Tulus house has a great vibe to it. It's bright, cheerfull and comfy. Tolus is a tremendous host, responds immediately and is thoughtfully concerned that her guests e joy their stay....couldn't ask for a better host.

The entire area is absolutely beautiful. The patio and living room areas were amazing for board games and cards. We were always happy to come back to the place at the end of our festivities.

My sons and I had a great stay. The home was very clean and comfortable. Parking was easy even though we had three vehicles and a trailer. We had a great stay and are Looking forward to going back again.

This cottage is awesome-such a classic! You are truly surrounded by water on three sides. It is quiet and private. We spent most of our time on the enclosed wrap-around porch; the place is a gem!

Randi is very easy to communicate with - she is super responsive and friendly. The house is close to Colgate- made running back and forth very easy. The house is peaceful, really well stocked with all your kitchen needs plus plenty of towels etc., all very clean, comfortable, neat and uncluttered, and in such a lovely setting, right on the lake. Highly recommend!

Very nice accommodations. Beautiful lake. Enjoyed kayaking and rowing in the lake. Spacious rooms. Had lots of fun.

Where do we start? This trip was to bring our parents to their final resting place in Fayetteville. We booked this house and it was right on the lake and just GORGEOUS! Everything from start to finish was excellent. The living room was spacious and the bedrooms were great, especially the master bedroom upstairs. We had an incredible time and would not hesitate to return. I highly recommend staying at this home with these great hosts. We cannot thank them enough.

Our second stay, and it was just as good as the first time! Close to the family we were visiting, and easy check in/out. Comfortable for us to hang out and relax!

We were n town for a family funeral, but wanted to enjoy the company of extended family while in town. We couldn’t have picked a better place to stay. Beautiful area—so conducive to reflection and yet perfectly set up for communing with family. We would definitely stay here again!

Cal and Lisa are perfect host. Property clean and hosts are very helpful in communication before and during our stay. Great location in downtown Caz.

Cute and exceptionally clean apartment. Great location, walkable to attractions and restaurants. Very peaceful. Eileen was a wonderful host. We would definitely stay here again.

Overall an amazing stay. Beautiful home and the jacuzzi was a plus. The only thing I would say was a little bothersome was we were able to hear the neighbors upstairs but other than that it was a fantastic stay. Would highly recommend this place.

Excellent rental and great communications with Stephanie. We loved the back yard, docks, kayaks and fantastic views. Easy walk to some of the restaurants and beach area. Would certainly rent again and hope to return to Sylvan Beach during the summer months when more is open. Thank you :)

Absolutely loved this stay!! 10/10 will be back and will be recommending it to friends and family! such a romantic peaceful place to stay !! Christopher was an amazing host, always keeping in contact and ensuring I knew he was there for anything !!

Dennis had great communication and I enjoyed staying at the apartment. It was perfect for what I needed and in a great location within walking distance of many restaurants / shops.

We had the most wonderful stay at Amanda’s place! The space was exactly as described and perfect for our family while visiting our daughter at Colgate. We loved the location on the lake and views out the front windows. The house is about 3 miles from the Colgate athletic fields or a ten minute drive - 12 minutes if you’re going up the hill. Amanda was such a gracious and accommodating host with excellent communication. We will definitely be back!

We highly enjoying our stay at Samantha’s cottage. It was a beautiful weekend getaway and the fall foliage made it even better!! The kitchen was extremely clean, and had everything we needed to cook meals during our stay. We weren’t there long enough to use the washer and dryer but I was grateful to have it if needed. The house has lots of natural sunlight, and the covered porch was great when it rained or when we didn’t want to make the walk down to the lake.

Great for Colgate parents! Cozy and cute.

The place was awesome. We really loved the feel of the house. The view of the lake was wonderful. Everything is the house was exactly as described in the listing. I would definitely stay here again and would recommend it to anyone visiting the area.

Vicki is a great host and very attentive to guests needs. she checks in and asks if you need anything. Also had some extra care items in case you forget something. The lake and view are outstanding!! the location is very easy to get to. My only critique is: it's listed as a 2 bedroom, when really it's a 1 bedroom with a small loft with a bed... however, it was perfect for the 2 of us, and we really enjoyed out time.

We had an incredible time at Jesse and Bernadette’s!! 10/10 would stay here the next time we visit the Finger Lakes. Truly magical. Falling asleep to the sound of the lake was a definite highlight.

This rental was super cute and comfortable right on the water. We had a girls weekend and had everything we needed at Courtney's place. The cottage overlooks the water and it is a beautifully clear lake. Beds were very comfortable and everything was neat and clean. There are a few set of stairs to get down to the cottage along with stairs to access the downstairs living quarters/bedroom so just be aware of that. We saw Eagles over the water and heard owls at night...very peaceful and private. Tons to do in the town of Skaneateles as well and lots of great restaurants. We would certainly recommend this rental to anyone and are looking forward to coming back!

Johnathan was extremely responsive and had very detailed clear instructions for everything. He checked in during our stay to make sure we were settled in. We were looking for a quiet comfortable place to relax and recharge and it was perfect for that. We especially enjoyed watching the ducks and geese swimming. The gas fireplace was so easy to use and cozy! There was a big snow storm forecasted during our stay and I was panicking a little bit about getting stuck and losing power, but Johnathan put my mind at ease and we didn't get snowed in or lose power and the snow on the lake was just beautiful.

Wonderful place to stay for our family of four! Beautiful view and clean, cozy home with all amenities needed to feel at home. We look forward to the next time we have the chance to make it to the upstate NY area and stay here again!