House holiday rentals in Casey Key, Florida

Find and book unique houses on Airbnb

Top-rated house rentals in Casey Key, Florida

Guests agree: these houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Guest favourite
A spacious living area features two large sofas and a patterned accent chair arranged around a central coffee table. Tall windows allow natural light to fill the room, highlighting the neutral color palette. A staircase leads to the upper level, enhancing the open layout.
Home in Nokomis
4.88 out of 5 average rating, 194 reviews

4/2.5 Oak Bahay, Heated Pool! 5min to Beach,4Acres

Welcome to Oak Bahay Ranch, our beautiful 4+ acre ranch home with pool! Enjoy the tranquility of this 4 bedroom/2.5 bathrooms with a pool (heated during winter). Bike or drive the quick 2.5 miles to Nokomis and Casey Key Beaches! Oak Bahay Ranch is a nature lover's paradise, close to Legacy Trail, Sarasota County's premier 20+ mile biking/walking trail. Oak Bahay Ranch is an easy drive to world famous Siesta Key Beach (15 mins), downtown Sarasota (20 mins), and downtown Venice (10 mins).

Superhost
A serene lake mirrors the surrounding landscape, showcasing greenery and trees along the shoreline. The cloudy sky is reflected in the still water, creating a calming ambiance. The scene emphasizes the natural beauty and tranquility of the property.
Home in Nokomis
4.73 out of 5 average rating, 343 reviews

The Ibis Cottage

Freshly renovated, The Ibis Cottage is a cozy studio on a beautiful property overlooking a small lake. It is a 5 minute drive to Nokomis Beach, Siesta Beach and Venice Beach are within easy reach, and a block away to the Legacy Trail bike path (Sarasota to Venice). Enjoy seeing a variety of birds on the property including the ibis, heron, and snowy egret. The cottage is conveniently located between Sarasota and Venice. The perfect location for enjoying the Gulf coast and outstanding beaches.

Guest favourite
An outdoor seating area is presented with dark wicker furniture, blue cushions, and an orange throw draped over the arm. A table sits in the center, with manicured grass and a view of the waterfront in the background, framed by a decorative gazebo.
Home in Venice
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 153 reviews

MCM Waterfront Retreat • Dock, Kayaks & Beaches

Welcome to our Mid-Century Modern waterfront escape on Curry Creek, minutes from Nokomis Beach (2 miles) and Venice Beach (3 miles). Spend your days fishing from the private dock, paddling one of 4 kayaks, or biking the Legacy Trail with 6 bikes. Evenings are for the firepit, grilling on the charcoal BBQ, or cornhole under the stars. We’ve stocked shark tooth gear, beach essentials, toiletries, coffee, tea, olive oil, spices, and a welcome bottle of wine — so you can arrive, unpack, and relax.

Top guest favourite
An outdoor dining area features a wooden table with two matching chairs positioned on a patterned rug. A decorative wall with colorful fish accents and a window reflects natural light. A door leads to the interior space, framed by lush greenery.
Home in Nokomis
5 out of 5 average rating, 21 reviews

The Nautilus Casita

A cozy spot to unwind the day after enjoyingTiki Bars, beaches and all Sarasota has to offer. We are 6 minutes from the Gulf and its white sandy beaches. Enjoy fishing the Jetty, boating the ICW, biking Legacy trail and enjoying sunsets at the Tiki bars with a famous grouper sandwich. So many activities to choose from in this town nestled next to the nation's #1 beach destination, Siesta key. All pets MUST be on a vet approved flea medication & proof sent prior to check in. No exceptions.

Top guest favourite
An outdoor area is showcased featuring a wooden pergola above a dining table with four chairs. A geometric-patterned rug extends under the table, and a pool is visible nearby, surrounded by greenery. Sunlight filters through the trees, illuminating the inviting space.
Home in Venice
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 50 reviews

Venice island Home w Heated Pool

Welcome to our beautifully renovated house on Venice Island Florida. Minutes away from the beaches, historical downtown, restaurants, shops, Venice airport. House has large pool, spacious driveway with on-site parking and a closed garage , projector and screen perfect for presentations, movies or catching a big game . It's perfect for getaway & seasonal rental. Enjoy the prime, convenience, comfort, quiet, very safe of this location while exploring all that our beautiful Venice has to offer.

Top guest favourite
A charming outdoor patio features a wooden pergola draped with fabric, providing shade over a seating area with four chairs. Lush greenery, including a palm tree, surrounds the cottage, nestled on a gravel area, creating a serene and inviting atmosphere.
Home in Sarasota
5 out of 5 average rating, 103 reviews

The Mango House Beach Cottage

Our cozy boho beach cottage, The Mango House is the perfect place for a couple or small family to relax and enjoy all the best Sarasota amenities. It’s conveniently located right between both Siesta Key entrances, walking distance to restaurants, grocery stores, Trader Joe’s, gym and a block from the popular Walt’s Fish Market. This gorgeous bungalow is the front house of a duplex on a large lot with plenty of cozy private outdoor space to relax and take in all the wonderful Florida weather!

Superhost
Home in Nokomis
5 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

Coastal Haven 3BR/2BA Beach Home

Experience the perfect beach getaway at our newly renovated 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom vacation rental. Just minutes from the sandy shores, this charming home offers the ideal blend of relaxation and convenience. Unwind in your private backyard oasis, featuring a sparkling pool—perfect for cooling off on warm days. Located just a short drive from the beach, Coastal Haven combines modern comforts with the charm of coastal living. Book your stay today and make unforgettable memories by the sea!

Guest favourite
A spacious covered lanai features woven seating and a dining table, providing an inviting space for relaxation and outdoor dining. Three overhead fans enhance airflow. The backdrop reveals a landscaped pool area through large screened windows, with sun loungers positioned beside the heated pebble tech pool.
Home in Nokomis
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 66 reviews

Tropical Pool Paradise - Minutes from the Beach!

Welcome to your own slice of paradise! This beautifully updated and completely eco-friendly and HEATED pool home in a quiet neighborhood is the perfect setting for your relaxing Florida vacation! You will love the privacy of this home overlooking tropical landscape vistas from the large covered lanai and solar heated pool welcoming you to your PRIVATE OASIS. You will enjoy easy access to our gulf coast beaches just minutes away. Beautiful Nokomis public beach is a 7 minute drive away.

Top guest favourite
A single-story house is set within a lush green landscape, featuring well-maintained shrubs and palm trees. The façade includes large arched windows and a spacious driveway nearby, with bicycles visible against the side of the house. A clean lawn invites outdoor activities.
Home in Nokomis
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 128 reviews

Sunny Getaway/Beautiful House/Beach/Heated Pool

Beautiful House with 3 bedrooms, heated pool, mini golf and two-car garage. Great location. five-minute drive to the beach. near shopping plazas, restaurants, and the famous Legacy Trail perfect for biking, running, and more. Situated at a dead-end in a peaceful community. Lots of outdoor space around the house with beautiful palm trees and a large patio. bicycles, board games, cornhole, a gas grill, and more at your disposal. Lots of places to visit in the Sarasota and Venice area.

Guest favourite
A screened-in patio is featured with comfortable seating made of woven material. A low table sits in the center with decorative items. The backdrop includes soft purple hues from the sunset and surrounded by tropical plants, offering a serene outdoor setting.
Home in Nokomis
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 55 reviews

Summer sunset. 3 minutes away from beach!

Welcome to your Summer Sunset Beach Retreat! It's a new property, just listed! Just a 3-minute drive to Nokomis Public, and very close to Shark Tooth Beach where to gather some shark tooths. Waterfront restaurants are just minutes away and Casey Key Gulf Club is too. The house offers the perfect blend of modern comfort. Fully equipped kitchen, Comfortable couches and beds. The clean, light, and airy atmosphere inside and beautiful surroundings outside make this stay perfect!

Superhost
Home in Sarasota
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 111 reviews

Rita Retreat - Beautiful 2/2 with private pool

Welcome to your dream vacation home! This charming rental offers a private pool and a lush green area for relaxation and fun. Situated just 4.6 miles away from the stunning Siesta Key beach, you'll have easy access to sun-kissed sands and sparkling waters. Seafood lovers will be delighted to find the renowned Phillippi Creek Oyster Bar nearby, offering some of the best seafood in town. Embrace the Florida lifestyle and make cherished memories in this wonderful retreat!

Top guest favourite
Home in Nokomis
5 out of 5 average rating, 6 reviews

Nokomis Waterfront Unit Walk to the Beach & Dining

Relax in this freshly renovated 2-bedroom, 2-bath canal-front retreat just a 10-minute walk to Nokomis Beach! Enjoy peaceful mornings on the deck, paddle out with the included kayaks, or stroll to local favorites like waterfront restaurants and ice cream shops. With modern comforts, a fully stocked kitchen, plush king + queen beds, and thoughtful amenities throughout, this is your perfect home base for a family getaway, snowbird stay, or beachside couple’s escape.

Popular amenities for house rentals in Casey Key, Florida