Monthly Rentals in Lake Poygan

A beautiful house whit the great view, my wife and I came up from Sturgeon Bay to celebrate her birthday in this amazing house with all that you con need. Super clean with a lot of space to have fun, can found board games, cards. At the garage can found padle boards, kayas. A big patio with a beautiful fire pit a private dock and much more to do. I short we definitely come back. Nichole and Tyler are the best host.

Such a wonderful experience! The place is perfect for a getaway or even a longer stay. The surroundings are beautiful—we enjoyed breakfast on the terrace, did some grilling, and even tried a bit of fishing. Everything was super clean with a stylish, tasteful design. I would definitely come back for a summer experience!

We had a wonderful stay at this cozy and authentic cabin on a peaceful farm. The setting was incredibly calm, and with snow falling the entire weekend, it felt like a true winter getaway. Despite the cold, the heating worked perfectly, keeping us warm and comfortable. The cabin was very clean and well-equipped with kitchen utensils, though we could have used a few more towels. Trevor, the host, was fantastic—very considerate and helpful. He even cleared the snow around the cabin, making it easier for us to walk around. A unique highlight was the frozen river nearby, which we could walk on—an unforgettable experience! The location was also great, with plenty of dining options just a 5-10 minute drive away. The only downside was that the bed wasn’t the most comfortable, but overall, we had a fantastic time and would highly recommend this place for a peaceful retreat.

This is a GREAT place to call home for a week on the chain of lakes. Beautiful space, super comfortable and 1,000% more livable than a hotel. Highly recommend.