House holiday rentals in Nantucket Island

Find and book unique houses on Airbnb

Top-rated house rentals in Nantucket Island

Guests agree: these houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favourite

Home in Nantucket

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 111 reviews

Beach "Loft"

Enjoy The Beach Loft Apartment's convenient proximity to beaches, town and S’conset. Located 4 miles from the ctr. of the Historic District and 1 mile to Nobadeer beach our lofty spacious 900 sq. ft., 10 foot ceiling height apartment is the lower level (basement) of our home. Yet you will have complete privacy with separate parking as well as separate entrance and your own outdoor deck. The neighborhood is 3 acre zoning. It is secluded and quiet with many pine trees, oak and sassafras trees.

Top guest favourite

Home in Nantucket

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 98 reviews

Captain's House 1750 In town

Our 1750 house is just over a block from the cobblestones of Main St. and only one block from the harbor. You can walk from the Hy-Line Ferry. At night, just walk home from dinner at any restaurant in town. There are 3 bedrooms (1 has a bunk bed) and two and a half baths. In the morning, walk next door for great coffee and cinnamon muffin. Have a cookout and eat in our small backyard area. Come for a visit! (Restaurants, Buses and Cars can cause some noise FYI) Drip coffee maker/filters too!

Top guest favourite

Home in Nantucket

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 191 reviews

Cuddle In Cottage near Surfside Beach

This charming Nantucket chic decorated cottage is your ideal vacation spot. Perfect for 2 and a max of 4 people. The cottage is less than a mile from Surfside Beach, voted the islands favorite, and across the street from a bike path offering biking to the beach or town a safe and easy option. The cottage boasts privacy with fully stocked kitchen, in and out door shower, radiant heat, AC unit in the bedroom, 2 flat screen TV's, top drawer linens, towels, beach chairs and an out door grill.

Top guest favourite

Home in Nantucket

5 out of 5 average rating, 40 reviews

In-Town, Historic District, Nantucket Home + Yard

A coveted in-town location within Nantucket’s historic district, just a quick stroll downtown to enjoy the premier dining options, charming boutiques, award-winning Whaling Museum & more. In our two-story, two-bedroom home we've added lots of NEW items - linens, pillows, towels, individual toiletries, coffee, smart TVs, Alexa, Keyless Entry, a new dishwasher, new dryer, new stove & microwave & a new Pack n' Play & Highchair for our littlest guests. Our cottage is perfect for 4-5 people.

Top guest favourite

Home in Nantucket

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 155 reviews

"Upon a Rock" Peace & Quiet - Mid island retreat!

Our guest suite is a separate wing on the main house. It is separated by a locked door. You have your own separate private entrance. You must come into the backyard of the main house. Look for the arbor with BAIRD written on top. These is an extra charge for any guests after the first 2 guests.,$150 per guest per night. Our guest suite is not suitable for children. We do not allow pets. If you were bringing a car please let us know in advance so we can make parking arrangements

Guest favourite

Home in Nantucket

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 15 reviews

South of Town Surf Shack. Best Deal on Island.

Redecorated for summer 2025 with all new linens and amazingly comfortable Casper beds! While the exterior is the picture perfect Nantucket cottage-style home surrounded by hydrangeas, you will be surprised by the casual, surf-vibe of the decor. Enjoy the best of Nantucket by walking to Town (under 1 mi) at this prime location property. The lot has privacy hedges and borders conservation land. This property has a separate living area home to two of the homeowner's employees.

Top guest favourite

Home in Nantucket

5 out of 5 average rating, 35 reviews

Humble beach home in Madequecham 🐋🐚

Wake up to the sounds of chirping birds and the crashing surf of the South shore! Take in the fresh salty air! Just steps from one of the best beaches on the island, and removed enough from the hustle and bustle of town, you will feel right at home in our peaceful abode. Though simple, the house is equipped with everything you need for a comfortable stay: Complete kitchen, gas grill, outdoor shower, lounge chairs, beach chairs, very good wifi, and more.

Guest favourite

Home in Nantucket

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 224 reviews

Mid Island Crash Pad

A conveniently located mid-island Crash Pad for the all movers and shakers that visit Nantucket! This gorgeous, newly built one bedroom studio with its own exterior entrance is just a few steps from the bike path and shuttle that takes you right into town. This location and space offer everything you need to be comfortable in between beach jaunts or shopping trips to town. Like a hotel room, we offer a simple and affordable place to stay on ACK.

Top guest favourite

Home in Nantucket

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 35 reviews

Our Three Suns

Nantucket house with community access to pool, tennis courts, bike path This 4 bedroom, 3 1/2 bath house is located in the desirable family friendly community of Naushop. The house includes all the amenities Naushop offers; a community pool, two tennis courts, a pickle-ball court, playground and renovated clubhouse. The community is located on the bike path providing easy access to the beach (1.5 miles), town (2 miles), and other amenities.  

Top guest favourite

Home in Nantucket

5 out of 5 average rating, 43 reviews

Luxurious Madaket/Smith Point Gem Water Views!

Rare Madaket beachside custom home with capacity for families and groups! Have it all, a no excuses perfect getaway to a Nantucket paradise with stunning ocean views and beaches. Master king bed and full bath | Guest with queen bed and full bath | Guest with 3 twin beds | Basement pullout sleeper sofa spillover space. Inquire about adding bunk house (queen in loft & sleeper sofa) if extra space is needed.

Top guest favourite

Home in Nantucket

5 out of 5 average rating, 27 reviews

Quiet Cul-de-Sac near Sconset

Located on a quiet cul-de-sac across from Sconset Golf Club, this classic Nantucket home offers a peaceful retreat with views of Sankaty Head Lighthouse. Just a ten-minute bike ride to Sconset village and a short walk to the free island shuttle. Filled with natural light, the home features a spacious yard, outdoor shower, and all the essentials for an easy summer stay—beach gear, bikes, and more included.

Superhost

Home in Nantucket

4.81 out of 5 average rating, 118 reviews

Deb Mar Cottages

On a quiet street one mile from town, this Cape Cod cottage provides 3 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms upstairs and downstairs, a fully equipped kitchen with dishwasher, washer and dryer, fireplace, cable TV, a patio with furniture, grill and enclosed outdoor shower. There are four tower fans. Please respect the 10am check out time and the 4pm check in time .