Holiday rentals with a fire pit in Sag Harbor

Very nice house with lots of room to relax and a well-stocked kitchen to cook. The house was clean and the beds were comfortable. The neighborhood is quiet and close to so much! When we had a question, Ellen answered with a call within minutes. She was the perfect host!

Really liked this house - quiet and secluded with the family. Good amenities, lovely back yard, and peaceful surroundings. About 20 mins to the beach by the time you park and walk across. A 10-15 min walk to a little dock with a playground for young kids. Thanks for the stay!

What a lovely place! Kitchen was a pleasure to use. Location was great for wineries and Greenport restaurants/bars. Spacious.

Such a great house for a group! Well kept and very accommodating. Will definitely be back

We had another great stay at Claudia's place! This was our third visit to this location, and likely not our last. Thank you!!

We had an amazing time here! The home is very charming, in a great location on the North Fork close to our favorite vineyards and restaurants. Paul was kind enough to offer us an early check in so that we may accommodate our guests traveling to visit! We really enjoyed our stay & made great memories.

The house was as advertised and well appointed and comfortable. I would stay again. Our family had a very nice memorable long weekend.

Alexis was a tremendous host-always available & great to interact with. The house was perfect, had anything & everything needed and was extremely comfortable. I would highly recommend her home to anyone visiting Shelter Island.

There are not enough stars to give to Nancy and her air b&b. This was our first experience with the app. The room was better than advertised. But what made this even more special was Nancy herself. What a sweet, kind woman. We plan on going back often. Not only to explore the Hampton area. But to make sure we have a drink around the fire pit with Nancy and her husband. Thank you again Nancy. You were awesome.

Great host, house and location. Would go back

Deborah’s place was very comfortable and super clean! It was close to Southampton town (10 min drive) and Deborah offered lots of local restaurant recommendations that were all delicious. The location was quiet and although the hot tub and pool are attached to the main house we felt vey comfortable utilizing them and even had the tiki torches lit for us at night which was fun. The space was roomy and the beds were comfortable. The kitchen had all of the necessities we needed. Would love to come back again during the summer and stay again!

Thank you for the lovely accommodations! The space was well appointed and we loved the attention to detail with the decor and amenities. It was the perfect space for us with a living space, kitchen and nice bathroom. The airbnb had everything we needed and more! Thank you, Nina!

This is our first AirBnB experience. Communication with KC in advance was great. The place is very nicely decorated, so we felt very comfortable right away. Our children liked the children's room very much and I liked the veranda. Our kids are very bright and loud and that's certainly a challenge for hosts. We are therefore glad that there were no complaints. The area is very nice and quiet. We will be happy to come back.

My friend and I stayed at Clare’s Airbnb in Montauk over the weekend, and she was one the nicest and most attentive hosts we have stayed with. Our room was really nice and contained everything we needed to have a very comfortable time. We really appreciated Clare for her very friendly hospitality and for going above and beyond for us whenever we needed her for something. And she was so lovely to our dog, Chi Chi ☺️ We will def stay at her place again if we make another visit to Montauk! 🐶🐾💕

We had a wonderful trip! Enjoyed the amazing views and easy access to the beach.

We had a great time at Vanessa’s apartment with our dog. Vanessa was always responsive and very helpful along the way. Centrally located between all of the surrounding towns and the apartment had everything you needed! The nature of the complex does allow for some outside noise from neighbors but the apartment complex was very peaceful and well kept. We hope to be back in the summer time to explore more of the beaches!