Holiday rentals in Sandy Island

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Sandy Island

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Top guest favourite
Home in Little Egg Harbor Township
5 out of 5 average rating, 5 reviews

Waterfront! Newly Built 3br Casa Del Pescatore

Welcome to Casa Del Pescatore, a stunning new waterfront home designed for fishing, boating, crabbing, and relaxing. This property offers direct water access, incredible lagoon views, & all the comforts of home for families, friends, and outdoor enthusiasts. Dock your boat or jet skis right at the property and enjoy the finest fishing and crabbing. Take a scenic ride across Great Bay for a day of striper or fluke fishing, have lunch in Beach Haven on LBI, or cruise to the Atlantic City Casinos.

Top guest favourite
Holiday home in Stafford Township
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 145 reviews

The Marsh Bungalow - a NEW Home 2 miles from LBI!

This NEW fully stocked coastal home is 2 miles from Long Beach Island with no direct neighbors! The perfect location offers close access to beaches, restaurants, and wedding venues! Professionally cleaned & maintained. Only used as Airbnb. 2 restaurants/bars within walking distance. Large driveway Distances to venues: (miles) Mallard Island Yacht Club: 0.5 Bonnet Island Estate: 2.5 Hotel LBI: 3.0 The Mainland: 3.3 Brant Beach Yacht Club: 5.6 Sea Shell Resort: 10 Parkers Garage: 10 STAC: 4.3

Guest favourite
A deck area features a dining table with six chairs and a BBQ grill. Soft lighting from an above lamp highlights the house's exterior, while large glass doors provide a view into the inviting interior space, including a warm-lit bedroom.
Home in Ship Bottom
4.89 out of 5 average rating, 148 reviews

LBI Ranch House, Walk to Beach and Everything!

**Wedding Parties: This home is 2 blocks to Hotel LBI, 1 mile to Bonnet Island Estate, 2 miles to Mallard Island. Walk to Bonnet Island using guarded walkway. We go to great length to make your stay easy, so that you can focus on your event. We provide made beds, linens. For the beach: badges, towels, chairs and umbrellas. Off street parking. This house is a classic raised ranch on pilings. It has modern conveniences and beach-y decor. The location is great (2.5 blocks or 1/4 mile to beach)

Top guest favourite
A two-story beach house showcases a wooden facade and multiple balconies. The driveway is lined with gravel and features a parked car in front. Garage doors are situated beneath the balconies, providing easy access to the home.
Home in Harvey Cedars
5 out of 5 average rating, 25 reviews

Beautiful Harvey Cedars home

Our 4 bedroom and 3 full bath home (+ bonus loft with bunks/sofa) sleeps 12 and is 1 block to the beach with traffic light & crosswalk (important!). Enjoy bay views as well as glorious sunrises and sunsets. After a day at the beach, grill and continue your outdoor beach vacation. The house is a short walk to the beach and bay as well as Harvey Cedars Marina, Bible Conference, and Harvest Cove. It's also located within short biking/walking distance to Harvey Cedars Park, restaurants and shops.

Top guest favourite
Home in Cape May Court House
5 out of 5 average rating, 71 reviews

Private Lakefront Retreat | The Cottage at Haven

"Where to Stay in Cape May" Condé Nast Traveler: August 2025 September 2025 Haven on Adullam Lake - The Cottage - a spacious, charming 2-bed, 2-bath retreat nestled on a private, family-owned 40-acre lakeside property, minutes from Stone Harbor & Cape May. Enjoy lake and forest views from the expansive sunset porch and deck, tall windows that flood the space with light, access to hiking trails, hammocks, county bike path, and a crystal clear lake with complimentary water sports equipment.

Guest favourite
Gentle waves roll onto a sandy beach under a clear sky. A wooden fence marks the beach area, with sparse vegetation visible in the foreground. The calming colors of the ocean and soft texture of the sand create a tranquil coastal setting.
Flat in Harvey Cedars
4.89 out of 5 average rating, 183 reviews

Maiden Lane Hideaway

Spacious studio 1 block from both the beach and bay in the heart of Harvey Cedars on Long Beach Island, NJ. Walk to restaurants, markets, ice cream, bar, liquor store and firehouse which hosts fun community events. Rental includes a coffee maker, blender, microwave, basic dishes, flatware. Sunny hideaway has a private patio, grill, two private entrances, access to an outside shower. Great couples retreat. Grab your surfboard, kayak, bicycles, beach bag and relax in this inviting environment.

Guest favourite
A cozy living area features a comfortable sofa adorned with patterned pillows and flanked by two modern rocking chairs. A warm rug lays beneath a rustic coffee table, while light enters through multiple windows, highlighting art pieces on the walls.
Home in Harvey Cedars
5 out of 5 average rating, 5 reviews

Sandcastle

Historic, renovated cottage in Harvey Cedars. Easy access to the ocean and bay beaches with water views from every window. 1 block to ocean, 3 blocks to restaurants and stores in town. A quiet street, our cottage is ideal for a couple or small family. Our family seaside escape for the last 15 years, this is not an impersonal rental property. Make yourself at home. Note that the house is a duplex, split down the middle of the house. We have wonderful retired neighbors who reside part time.

Superhost
A spacious kitchen area is featured with light-colored cabinetry and a large island with bar stools. Natural light enters through sliding glass doors leading to a deck, with stainless steel appliances and ample counter space visible.
Home in Stafford Township
4.78 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviews

4br 2.5 bath, 2 min to LBI! Sat to Sat rental!

Quaint and cozy centrally located Beach house - 2 mins to Long Beach Island and beaches. Large outdoor area featuring bar, grill, deck and entertainment space outside including pizza oven and ping ping Friendly, family neighborhood with quick access to fantastic restaurants, Mud City Crabhouse and Causeway (open year round) Great get away from NYC or Philly. Just down the road from Mallard Island & Bonnet Estate Wedding Venues. 25 years and up please.

Guest favourite
A charming cottage is set against a vibrant sunset sky, with soft hues of pink and orange. A wooden walkway leads through lush greenery to the cottage, which features large windows that reflect the evening light.
Cabin in Galloway
5 out of 5 average rating, 12 reviews

Blue Heron Cottage

Welcome to Blue Heron Cottage at Mott's Creek in Galloway, NJ! Our Waterfront Oasis is situated with stunning bay views. An impeccably renovated 1 bedroom, 1.5 bathroom cottage, offers the perfect blend of serene living and modern luxury. The cottage is equipped with all the amenities you need for a comfortable stay, including air conditioning, heating, WiFi, and a fully equipped kitchen. Enjoy your stay at our peaceful and private cottage!

Top guest favourite
An aerial view captures the bayside bungalow surrounded by several other homes along the water. The scene highlights boats docked at the waterfront, a bridge in the distance, and a spacious parking area along the road.
Cabin in Stafford Township
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 25 reviews

Bayside Rustic Bungalow

This home is the ideal escape from the often challenging and complicated world we currently live in, and is perfect for families, friends and loved ones seeking a return to simpler times and a breath of fresh air for their summer getaway. I look forward to providing my guests an unforgettable experience they will cherish forever in the Mud City section of Manahawkin!

Guest favourite
A serene sunset over Barnegat Bay paints the sky with soft hues of orange and pink. Silhouettes of Adirondack chairs provide a cozy spot for relaxation, while calm water reflects the colorful sky. A white picket fence and weathered dock frame the peaceful scene.
Home in Ocean Township
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 106 reviews

Bayfront Oasis, Kayak/Canoe, Clams, Swans, Sunrise

🌅 “Romantic Bayfront”: Your Water’s Edge Retreat Awaken to the sun’s tender caress, its warmth dancing on your windowsill. With panoramic views of the Barnegat Bay, this custom oasis invites you to swim, kayak, fish, clam, bird watching and create lifelong memories. Let the moonlight guide your stay—a symphony of water and sky awaits. 🏖️🌙

Guest favourite
A view overlooking nearby buildings and the beach, with the ocean visible in the distance. Soft dunes are seen in the foreground, framed by utility poles and overhead wires, creating a serene coastal atmosphere.
Home in Brant beach
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 253 reviews

Long Beach Island Escape-Walk to Beach-Brant Beach

1/2 block to the beach, on Long Beach Island, open and bright space, beautiful ground level porch for AM sun and people watching. Parking for 2 cars. Quiet location on coveted Ocean Blvd in Brant Beach Walking distance to bike rentals, seafood, and ice cream.

Popular amenities for Sandy Island holiday rentals