Holiday rentals in Sandy Island

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Sandy Island

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Guest favourite
The image captures a serene sunset over the bay, with the sun descending towards the horizon. Silhouetted docks are visible along the water's edge, reflecting warm colors across the tranquil surface. The calm atmosphere highlights the natural beauty of the surrounding landscape.
Home in Barnegat Light

Beautiful, vintage home on Barnegat Bay, LBI

Gorgeous, cosy waterfront property with amazing views over bay. Enjoy access to bay, ocean, beautiful beaches, and Barnegat Lighthouse. Bring your own boat, kayaks and explore the waterways! Bring your own bicycles to explore the island by land. *this is our private family home, not a hotel. Please respect it and treat it as you would your own home. **guests who leave the home messy (especially the kitchen) will be charged for any extra cleaning. Only guests with positive reviews accepted.

4.81 out of 5 average rating, 121 reviews
Top guest favourite
Holiday home in Stafford Township

The Marsh Bungalow - a NEW Home 2 miles from LBI!

This NEW fully stocked coastal home is 2 miles from Long Beach Island with no direct neighbors! The perfect location offers close access to beaches, restaurants, and wedding venues! Professionally cleaned & maintained. Only used as Airbnb. 2 restaurants/bars within walking distance. Large driveway Distances to venues: (miles) Mallard Island Yacht Club: 0.5 Bonnet Island Estate: 2.5 Hotel LBI: 3.0 The Mainland: 3.3 Brant Beach Yacht Club: 5.6 Sea Shell Resort: 10 Parkers Garage: 10 STAC: 4.3

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 159 reviews
Guest favourite
A deck area features a dining table with six chairs and a BBQ grill. Soft lighting from an above lamp highlights the house's exterior, while large glass doors provide a view into the inviting interior space, including a warm-lit bedroom.
Home in Ship Bottom

LBI Ranch House, Walk to Beach and Everything!

**Wedding Parties: This home is 2 blocks to Hotel LBI, 1 mile to Bonnet Island Estate, 2 miles to Mallard Island. Walk to Bonnet Island using guarded walkway. We go to great length to make your stay easy, so that you can focus on your event. We provide made beds, linens. For the beach: badges, towels, chairs and umbrellas. Off street parking. This house is a classic raised ranch on pilings. It has modern conveniences and beach-y decor. The location is great (2.5 blocks or 1/4 mile to beach)

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 149 reviews
Guest favourite
Home in Manahawkin

Lakefront Retreat, Hot Tub, Private Dock, Near LBI

Welcome to our luxurious lakefront retreat, near LBI! This exquisite 4-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom home offers relaxation and adventure. Four bedrooms, a balcony, expansive deck, private hot tub (May–Oct), and a glowing boardwalk winding through the pines to a lakeside yoga nook, fire pit, and private dock. Kayaks, paddleboards, cornhole, Weber grill, wet bar, PS5, ping pong, board games, 10 free beach badges — everything’s here. Sleeps 10, small pets welcome. Book now for an unforgettable getaway!

4.82 out of 5 average rating, 65 reviews
Top guest favourite
A spacious living area features a large sectional couch with plush cushions, facing a modern fireplace. Natural light fills the room through sliding glass doors that lead to an enclosed deck. Nearby, a dining area with seating for six is visible.
Home in Barnegat Light

Grandma's LBI House

Bring the whole family to our spacious house on the beach block in Barnegat Light, recently highlighted in the Washington Post as a relaxing beach. There are spaces to be by yourself and read a book and spaces to gather together and eat, talk, play games or watch movies. Outside, you can take the short walk a half block to the dunes and beach. Or walk a few blocks to the township park and playground, Barnegat Lighthouse, and shops and restaurants. Everything is here for you to come and relax!

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 29 reviews
Guest favourite
Gentle waves roll onto a sandy beach under a clear sky. A wooden fence marks the beach area, with sparse vegetation visible in the foreground. The calming colors of the ocean and soft texture of the sand create a tranquil coastal setting.
Flat in Harvey Cedars

Maiden Lane Hideaway

Spacious studio 1 block from both the beach and bay in the heart of Harvey Cedars on Long Beach Island, NJ. Walk to restaurants, markets, ice cream, bar, liquor store and firehouse which hosts fun community events. Rental includes a coffee maker, blender, microwave, basic dishes, flatware. Sunny hideaway has a private patio, grill, two private entrances, access to an outside shower. Great couples retreat. Grab your surfboard, kayak, bicycles, beach bag and relax in this inviting environment.

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 200 reviews
Top guest favourite
A three-story duplex showcases a covered parking area with a gravel surface. The exterior features multiple private decks with white railings. Large windows illuminate the structure, while a bright blue sky creates a visually appealing backdrop.
Home in Surf City

Dream Location w Covered Deck, Nectar King Bed

Inquire for Labor Day week, 3 day minimum ....I'll respond with deal. Guest Fav Beach House w King Size Nectar bed, Comfortable Sleeping for 7/8. Huge Deck with multiple seating areas. Ideal Foodie Location. * 7th Home from Beach (2 Min Walk) * 5 Minutes to Bay Beach (for kids) * 6 Beach Badges, Beach Chairs Included * Parking Onsite 4+ Cars..No struggling for Parking * Lectrofan EVO Sound Machine * 4 BodyBoards for kids * Super Fast Wifi 400+ * 1 Minute walk to Everything = Park and Relax

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 143 reviews
Guest favourite
A cozy living area features a comfortable sofa adorned with patterned pillows and flanked by two modern rocking chairs. A warm rug lays beneath a rustic coffee table, while light enters through multiple windows, highlighting art pieces on the walls.
Home in Harvey Cedars

Sandcastle

Historic, renovated cottage in Harvey Cedars. Easy access to the ocean and bay beaches with water views from every window. 1 block to ocean, 3 blocks to restaurants and stores in town. A quiet street, our cottage is ideal for a couple or small family. Our family seaside escape for the last 20 years, this is not an impersonal rental property. Make yourself at home. Note that the house is a duplex, split down the middle of the house. We have wonderful retired neighbors who reside part time.

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 6 reviews
Top guest favourite
A two-story home is viewed from the side, featuring a mix of blue and yellow siding. Lush landscaping with colorful flowers surrounds the property, while a patio area with lounge chairs and umbrellas is visible in the background, inviting relaxation.
Home in Ship Bottom

RATED AS LBI's BEST RENTAL - NEW

LONG BEACH ISLAND - New, 1 BLOCK TO OCEAN! - 3 bedroom, 2 bath, outdoor enclosed beach shower! 2-car garage, full laundry, gas fireplace, natural gas grille on private 2nd floor deck, 2nd grille on ground level. Impeccably maintained, natural light, and spacious. Restaurants and shops 1/2 block. Bagels, coffee and ice cream same block. Keurig & Cuisinart coffee makers. Exceptionally CLEAN. AIR PURIFIERS in all 3 Bedrooms. MIN 2 NIGHTS - off summer. MIN 5 NIGHTS - some summer weeks.

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 186 reviews
Top guest favourite
The exterior of a recently constructed, two-story oceanside home is displayed, featuring a light green facade with a sloped roof and multiple balconies. The ground level includes a garage with wooden doors. Surrounding landscaping consists of sandy pathways and low shrubbery.
Home in Barnegat Light

High-End LBI Oceanside Retreat

Beautiful, recently constructed oceanside home in ideal Barnegat Light location. Just steps from the beach, and walking distance to bayside boat launch, beach & playground. Proximate to Viking Village shopping & everything northern LBI has to offer. High-end finishes, quality beds, great light, large open kitchen, high ceilings, bbq + outdoor shower. Sleeps 8 comfortably. We love our home and know you will too! Perfect for multiple couples, families (with kids), and small groups.

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 138 reviews
Top guest favourite
The home's exterior features a light-colored facade with multiple gabled roofs. Two garage doors are visible beneath the elevated entrance, which is framed by a white railing. Large windows allow natural light to fill the space, contributing to a welcoming appearance.
Home in Beach Haven West

5 Bedroom Water Front Home, Minutes from LBI!

Welcome to our home in Beach Haven West! Walk out the back door and you’re on the lagoon, enjoy beautiful sunsets and just a quick ride to the Beach! We provide lots of information on the local area and activities! Fully stocked kitchen, amenities and bedding/bath linens. Fresh towels, sheets, shams AND quilts are provided for each turnover. Contact us directly through messenger regarding special stays and custom dates.

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 92 reviews
Top guest favourite
A serene sunset over Barnegat Bay paints the sky with soft hues of orange and pink. Silhouettes of Adirondack chairs provide a cozy spot for relaxation, while calm water reflects the colorful sky. A white picket fence and weathered dock frame the peaceful scene.
Home in Waretown

Bayfront Kayaks/Canoes, Clamming, Reduced Rate

🌅 “Romantic Bayfront”: Your Water’s Edge Retreat Awaken to the sun’s tender caress, its warmth dancing on your windowsill. With panoramic views of the Barnegat Bay, this custom oasis invites you to swim, kayak, fish, clam, bird watching and create lifelong memories. Let the moonlight guide your stay—a symphony of water and sky awaits. 🏖️🌙

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 113 reviews

Popular amenities for Sandy Island holiday rentals