Holiday rentals in Tuscarora Lake

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Tuscarora Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Top guest favourite
The kitchen features dark wood cabinetry and a spacious island with seating for six. A sleek black countertop complements modern appliances and a stylish tile backsplash. Ambient lighting from a unique pendant fixture enhances the practical layout, perfect for preparing meals.
Flat in Cazenovia
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 158 reviews

Home Away From Home

Home Away From Home is 850 square feet, 2 bedrooms w/ full kitchen, bath, laundry, newly done. We are close to beautiful views, and nice restaurants.Cazenovia Lake has parks, boating and swimming. Close to down hill and cross country skiing, The links walking trails, winery, brewery , distiller. Colleges include Cazenovia, Morrisville, and Colgate, and only 25 miles to Syracuse University. Couples, solo adventurers, business travelers, and even small families will find solace here. Welcome!

Top guest favourite
A newly finished red barn structure is set against a backdrop of vibrant autumn foliage in various shades of orange, yellow, and green. The surrounding landscape features open fields and gently rolling hills, creating a serene rural atmosphere.
Place to stay in Chittenango
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 193 reviews

Luxury Barn Apartment with Private Hot Tub

Come and enjoy the quiet of our newly finished country apartment! Relax and unwind in the hot tub on your private deck, overlooking the beautiful hills of Central New York. A seven minute walk will bring you to Chittenango Falls Park with it’s majestic waterfall and lots of trails. The property is backed by the NYS walking trail that follows an old rail line. The historic Village of Cazenovia is four miles away. Hillside has everything you’ll need for a quiet getaway. Good dogs allowed. No cats

Top guest favourite
Home in Hamilton
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 145 reviews

*All Decked Out* Lakefront, Kayak, Fish & Colgate!

Lakefront cottage on Lebanon Reservoir in Hamilton, NY! Enjoy time together around either campfire, paddleboard, kayak (6 provided), and chill out on the 4 person tube! Bring your fishing gear, play games, swim, cookout on the Weber or Blackstone grill. Simply relax at the lake and get some sun on the private dock! Take in the lakeview on the covered porch, sitting in an Adirondack chair. The perfect spot for your getaway. 10 minutes from Hamilton/Colgate. Enjoy Central NY's finest!

Top guest favourite
Home in Erieville
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 85 reviews

Great Lakefront House - Enjoy All of the Seasons!!

Relax by the lake while taking in the scenery from the expansive deck. Watch cranes and eagles fly around, kayak around the lake or go fishing. Or if you are looking for a quiet and relaxing get away in the Fall or Winter this is the spot! You can snowshoe, ice fish, or just watch the snow fall. Very cute 2 bedroom, 1 bath house with great kitchen, central AC and WiFi on private Tuscarora Lake. This house has a full kitchen, washing machine/dryer and kayaks, canoes, show shoes and more.

Guest favourite
Home in Hamilton
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 102 reviews

Modern Lake Retreat, Sleeps 8, 5 min to Colgate

- 🌅 Waterfront lake views - 🚣 Self-serve kayaks & paddleboard - 🛏️ 2 bedrooms + trundle bed + pull-out couch (sleeps 8) - 🎓 5 minutes to Colgate University - 🕹️ Giant Connect Four - 🎯 Lawn games - 🔥 Electric fireplace - 🍳 Fully stocked kitchen - ☕ Drip & Keurig coffee maker - 🛁 Linens & towels provided *⚠️ Lake Moraine is currently drawn down 10 ft through 2028 for a NYS dam project. Kayaking, paddleboarding, and fishing continue unaffected at the Colgate Boathouse next door 🚣*

Top guest favourite
Guest suite in Hamilton
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 400 reviews

Private Entry-1 block to campus+downtown, Clean!

With an excellent location on Broad St. in Hamilton Village, the space is just a block walk to campus or downtown. There is a private entrance to the ensuite on the 1st floor (keyless entry code). It has a private bath (shower), king bed, smart TV with basic cable, Keurig, mini fridge, sitting area, and WiFi. A mini-split provides heat and air conditioning. Also, a fireplace w/remote control. A twin rollaway is available upon request. This suite is perfect for campus visitors.

Top guest favourite
Home in Cazenovia
5 out of 5 average rating, 19 reviews

The Magee House

This 19th-century country farmhouse has been recently renovated with all the modern conveniences while preserving its historic charm. With three living spaces and two fireplaces, there's plenty of room to relax with family and friends. The spacious kitchen is fully equipped. Celebrate special events in the unique bar room. The four bedrooms and the two updated baths offer comfort and convenience. Enjoy the outdoors on the patio. Take a walk to the pond or down the mowed field path.

Top guest favourite
Four blue Adirondack chairs surround a stone firepit, facing a serene lake. Lush greenery and hills are visible across the water, while a cloudy sky reflects a calm atmosphere. The setting provides an ideal space for relaxation and enjoying lakeside views.
Guest suite in Hamilton
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 203 reviews

Lakefront studio apartment near Hamilton, NY 13346

Pets stay free! Lakefront walkout basement studio apartment, steps to water. Greatroom with king & queen beds. On Lebanon Reservoir a few miles from Hamilton, Colgate University and Seven Oaks Golf Course. Room to dock your motor boat, kayak, fish & swim. Rental kayaks available within walking distance. Best view of the lake. Big starry night skys from your private outdoor firepit & covered patio with propane grill & plenty of seating.

Superhost
A wooden deck extends from the cabin, surrounded by lush green trees. The calm water of Tuscarora Lake is visible in the background, framed by vibrant foliage, inviting a sense of tranquility and natural beauty.
Cottage in Erieville
4.7 out of 5 average rating, 47 reviews

Rustic Summer Camp on Tuscarora Lake

The camp is close to two charming, historic towns: Cazenovia and Hamilton, NY. Both villages have great restaurants but there's a popular one right on the lake. The cabin is right on Tuscarora lake, Erieville, NY and it is nestled among many trees. If you want to be away from the city, this may be the place for you. This seasonal cabin is not available during the winter months. This charming lake community welcomes everyone!

Guest favourite
Cabin in Edmeston
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 35 reviews

Pondside Chalet · Loft Soaking Tub · Sauna+Hot Tub

Welcome to the Oasis Skylight nestled on 10 acres of land in natural surroundings. A stylish retreat that blends luxury and nature with vaulted ceilings, sleek black-and- natural wood design, and panoramic windows. Enjoy a fully stocked chef’s kitchen, cozy custom nooks, and a lofted soaking tub. Outside, unwind in the hot tub sauna and spa or by the beautiful pond, all surrounded by serene mountain views.

Guest favourite
Flat in Hamilton
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 67 reviews

2 min drive to Colgate,

Charming studio with a queen bed, smart TV, desk, and wall-mounted ironing board. Bathroom stocked with essentials. Fully equipped kitchen for home-cooked meals. Living room area has a twin pullout couch with smart TV. Outside has a cozy sitting space with peaceful country views. Stay 2 or more nights and enjoy a complimentary bottle of wine from our local winery it'll be perfect for a relaxing getaway.

Guest favourite
The exterior of a tiny home is showcased, featuring dark wood siding and large windows. A private hot tub with bubbling water is positioned in the foreground, surrounded by stone pathways and lush greenery. A wooden staircase leads to the entrance, enhancing accessibility.
Tiny home in East Syracuse
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 420 reviews

Renovated 1880’s Milk Barn

Experience a unique stay in our fully renovated, charming, and historic tiny home. Situated on 2.25 acres of tranquil land, you'll have the perfect blend of nature and convenience. Just 10 minutes from Green Lakes! A local Gem! 12 minutes to Destiny USA 10 minutes to downtown Syracuse 15 minutes to the SU Dome 17 minutes to the Lakeview Amphitheater.

Popular amenities for Tuscarora Lake holiday rentals