Holiday rentals in Buckeye Lake

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Buckeye Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favourite

Cottage in Lancaster

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 232 reviews

Carriage House 1840: Downtown Lux, Hot tub, Pool

Welcome to Carriage House 1840. The carriage house is on the property of one of Historic Downtown Lancaster's oldest homes and only steps away from museums, restaurants and all that downtown Lancaster has to offer. The carriage house was built around 1840 and is the original structure updated with modern luxury amenities. Upon entering the carriage house, you will be met with a fully equipped kitchen and a full private bath, then proceed up the stairs to the loft portion and enjoy your stay.

Guest favourite

Home in Newark

5 out of 5 average rating, 109 reviews

Lakeview Haven

Comfortable, contemporary, and conveniently located. Your home away from home is sparkling clean throughout and features granite countertops, stainless-steel appliances, a bright, fully stocked kitchen, 75” HD smart TV, fast wi-fi, dedicated work space, washer & dryer, hardwood floors, back patio with furniture & BBQ grill (seasonal), well-manicured private yard, and attached garage. Close to Denison University in Granville, OSU Newark, restaurants, gyms, walking trails, shopping, and more!

Guest favourite

Cottage in Thornville

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 430 reviews

Little House on main lake of Buckeye Lake

The Little House on Buckeye Lake sits on a prime location and steps from the waters edge. Enjoy sunsets and sunrise from the porch while sipping coffee or your favorite beverage. Private setting. Central air-conditioning for those hot summer nights. Gas BBQ grill (May 1st-Nov 1st) Plenty of parking. Firepit , (firewood not provided) Bring your boat and dock or fish out back! Close to Legend Valley, Winery, The Port, Horvath's Harbor, National Trails, Interstate 70. Come enjoy Lake Life!

Guest favourite

Cottage in Buckeye Lake

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 112 reviews

Anchors Away - Relaxing Cottage Minutes from Lake

Newly remodeled home just a short walk to the Lake, Bars & Restaurants! 2 bedrooms & 2.5 bathrooms with a cozy nautical design. Fully stocked kitchen and spacious living room are perfect for vacationing with family! Additional amenities included for our guests are: 3 Bikes, Yard Games, Firepit, Propane Grill & Board Games We can accommodate a MAX of 3 Cars and no street parking available. All Short-Term Rentals in the Village of Buckeye Lake are governed under Ordinances #2022-36/#2023-27

Guest favourite

Cottage in Thornville

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 123 reviews

Buckeye Lake Retreat

A great place for families and fishermen Beautiful home right on the channel and direct access to the lake. Excellent for fishing, catching catfish right from the dock. It's an excellent place to relax and unwind. Fish directly off the dock or use the Kayaks included to explore the lake. We have an extra-long dock that can accommodate your boat(s). Fully equipped kitchen, your own washer and dryer, and a gas grill. There is a fire pit for the nights you want a campfire.

Guest favourite

Cottage in Buckeye Lake

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 109 reviews

Newly renovated 2-bedroom cottage by the lake

This newly remodeled cottage is perfectly located on the north bank side of Buckeye Lake just blocks off the water. You will enjoy quick and easy access to all the amenities and lakeside fun you could ever want. *North Shore Ramp -3min/drive (put your boat in) *Buckeye Lake Brewery/Chef Shack-2min/walk *Boatyard-4min/walk Property is 2 full lots with 1 whole lot available for all your parking needs. Whether you bring your own boat or rent one, there is plenty of parking.

Guest favourite

Home in Lancaster

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 359 reviews

Lancaster Luxury Apartment

Your own private entrance, off street parking spot, kitchen, bathroom, dinning area, laundry, and furnished patio. Additional person and extra bed charge at $10 a night per guest with a maximum of four guests. We accept dogs for an additional $25 per stay fee but they must be crated when left alone in the apartment. We do not charge a cleaning fee :-) Minutes from everything Lancaster--bike path, Mt. Pleasant, the downtown historic district, restaurants, and museums.

Guest favourite

Cottage in Buckeye Lake

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 256 reviews

3 Bedroom 2 Bath Cottage

Intel Amazon. Heath, Newark, Granville, Denison,30 min E of Cbus. 1 mile off I 79. Walk to all of Buckeye Lake’s best! Bike path, Boat, Brewery, Restaurants, Museum Pizza, Shopping., Boatyard. No railing to the the OH State creek in back may not be suitable for children. Roomy and Private Fire Pit Granville,Newark, Hebron,Heath, Lancaster, Columbus, Legend Valley, National Trail, Midland, Denison, OSU, Amazon Etna, Hocking Hill, Winery, Zanesville Intel within 30 min. .

Guest favourite

Cabin in Newark

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 157 reviews

Cozy Rustic Log Cabin on 22 acres with a creek

Relax in the woods in this rustic Log Cabin situated on 22 acres with a creek. Guests have access to all 22 acres. Memory Foam King sized bed, and pull out sofa for extra guests. Deer and other wildlife are in abundance. Cabin is fully furnished with Stainless gas stove, Stainless refrigerator , shower, smart TV (we do not have cable, but you may connect to your cellular device ex Netflix/YouTube) Wi-Fi, microwave, coffee pot, firepit, and other necessities. 🪵 🔥 🦌 🍃

Guest favourite

Cottage in Lancaster

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 144 reviews

Cheerful 1-bedroom cottage with indoor fireplace

Welcome travelers to the Rockmill Cottage! This bright, one bedroom guesthouse is located across the street from the historic mill and a short drive to restaurants, grocers, shops, and breweries. Enjoy the craftsman woodwork throughout, including a gas fireplace, fully appointed kitchen and cozy loft. In warmer months, the outdoor gazebo is perfect for morning coffee or a picnic. Please note that the cottage is on the same property as the Rockmill Farmhouse.

Superhost

Home in Thornville

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 182 reviews

The Lookout at Buckeye Lake

Welcome to The Lookout at Buckeye Lake! We stumbled upon this cozy cottage in the summer of 2018 and spent the next 12 months renovating the dream Buckeye Lake getaway. Our first project was an off-grid cabin featured on DIY Network’s Building Off The Grid. We took inspiration from that design to transform The Lookout into the perfect place to unwind and enjoy the lake. Located just 3 miles off I70, and walking distance to neighborhood favorite Papa Boos.

Guest favourite

Rental unit in Somerset

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 110 reviews

Peaceful apartment for 2 in the heart of town

A single, full size •upstairs• apartment for two in Somerset’s historical district - just steps away from restaurants, bars & shopping. Peaceful & cozy. We are a one bedroom space with a full size bed, there is also a living/reading area, dining room, full kitchen and full bathroom. Includes WiFi & streaming on the tv - Hulu. Please refer to the check-in instructions for a map on how to find our parking lot! This is contactless check-in. No pets!