Holiday rentals in Buckeye Lake

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Buckeye Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favourite

Flat in Somerset

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 177 reviews

Peaceful apartment for two in the heart of town

A full size •upstairs• apartment for two in Somerset’s historical district - just steps away from restaurants, bars & shopping. Peaceful & cozy. This is a one bedroom space with a full size bed, there is also a living room/reading area, dining room, full kitchen and full bathroom. Includes WiFi & you can sign into your own streaming service on the tv. Please refer to the check-in instructions for a map on how to find our private parking lot! This is contactless check-in. Sorry, no pets allowed!

Top guest favourite

Guest house in Newark

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 332 reviews

Cherry Valley

A cozy, comfortable getaway close to everything! Cherry Valley is a separate guesthouse on our 3 acres. A spacious studio with private entrance and queen bed. Our decor brings the outdoors in, featuring calming colors and natural materials. Solar powered. We value the land we live on. We grow native & useful plants, food for ourselves & for wildlife, and lots of flowers. Each season brings a new chapter of life, we hope you see the magic of the moment while you're here! @theyardatcherryvalley

Top guest favourite

Cottage in Buckeye Lake

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 135 reviews

Anchors Away - Relaxing Cottage Minutes from Lake

Newly remodeled home just a short walk to the Lake, Bars & Restaurants! 2 bedrooms & 2.5 bathrooms with a cozy nautical design. Fully stocked kitchen and spacious living room are perfect for vacationing with family! Additional amenities included for our guests are: 3 Bikes, Yard Games, Firepit, Propane Grill & Board Games We can accommodate a MAX of 3 Cars and no street parking available. All Short-Term Rentals in the Village of Buckeye Lake are governed under Ordinances #2022-36/#2023-27

Guest favourite

Cottage in Buckeye Lake

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 160 reviews

2 Queen Size Beds +Outdoor Firepit +Back Yard +BBQ

This newly remodeled cottage is perfectly located on the north bank side of Buckeye Lake just blocks off the water. You will enjoy quick and easy access to all the amenities and lakeside fun you could ever want. *North Shore Ramp -3min/drive (put your boat in) *Buckeye Lake Brewery/Chef Shack-2min/walk *Boatyard-4min/walk Property is 2 full lots with 1 whole lot available for all your parking needs. All Short-Term Rentals in the Village of Buckeye Lake are governed under Ordinance #2024-22

Top guest favourite

Home in Buckeye Lake

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 89 reviews

Waterfront House with Private Dock on Buckeye Lake

The ultimate Lake House on the North Shore of Buckeye Lake. This newly renovated water front property is located next to the Boat Yard at Buckeye Lake and 5 min walking distance from the Buckeye Lake Yacht Club, the North Shore State Park boat launch, restaurants, bars, supermarkets and more. Enjoy this 3 bedroom home with its extensive private garden and outdoor fire pit area. The house includes a private lot for 10 cars or you can use it to park a boat. One dock space will be provided.

Superhost

Home in Thornville

5 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

The Shome 2 - Heated Pool & Hot Tub

Coming soon. The Shome 2: Your Future Country Luxury Retreat!** Set to open on June 1, 2025, this stunning Barndominium will sit on 5 acres, blending rustic charm with modern luxury. Accommodating 16-18 guests, it will feature two master suites with pool views and private decks. Enjoy an inground heated pool, hot tub, and outdoor grilling space—perfect for gatherings. Experience this beautiful Barndominium, just a short drive from local attractions. “See the Shome one for reference”

Guest favourite

Cottage in Millersport

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 124 reviews

Cozy 2 Bedroom Buckeye Lake with Lakeview

Welcome to the Chelsea Cottage at buckeye Lake: the cleanest cottage with the most comfortable beds in the area and a view of the water from the front deck. Updated cottage with a gorgeous water view from the front deck! Brand new furnishings, comfortable beds and updates throughout. Enjoy the fire pit, coffee on the deck or go out and explore Buckeye Lake and the amazing surrounding area! Please note only two vehicles are allowed as that is all the room we have in the parking area!

Guest favourite

Cottage in Buckeye

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 62 reviews

The Paddle Inn-Buckeye Lake cottage on the Water

Welcome to this lovely lake front cottage on the North Bank of Buckeye Lake! Beautiful views from the wall of windows in the spacious vaulted Great Room. This 1930's cottage has many recent updates & improvements including a loft with spiral stairs, gas fireplace, balcony overlook with spiral stairs for panoramic views of the lake. Rental docks nearby. Located within a short walking distance to local businesses. All Short Term rentals in Buckeye Lake are governed under Ord. # 2024-22.

Top guest favourite

Home in Buckeye Lake

5 out of 5 average rating, 21 reviews

Buckeye Lake Village cottage

Your family will be close to everything when you stay at this centrally-located getaway. Our home is walking distance to the North Shore Marina, the village local restaurants and Buckeye Lake brewery. The outdoor space is a perfect gathering spot for a warm fire after a long day on the lake. Excited for you to make lasting memories at our home. All short term rentals in the Village of Buckeye Lake are governed under ordinances #2022-36 and #2024-27 *weekly and monthly discounts *

Top guest favourite

Home in Millersport

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 62 reviews

*Newly Upgraded* Hot Tub-Game Room-Dock-Fire Pits

*LISTED SUMMER 2024 & UPGRADED AUGUST 2024* **Hot tub, interior fireplace, game room & much more added 8/22/2024** Formally known as the Blue Heron/Terrace Retreat on the Canal. Spyglass Landing is located on the historic Erie Canal, only 1,000 feet from Buckeye lake - our double dock allows for easy lake access via boat or even kayak! *Renter must be at least 25 years of age & must be present during entire booked stay* **Maximum 6 adults** *Up to 7 guests including children*

Top guest favourite

Cottage in Thornville

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 134 reviews

Buckeye Lake Retreat

A great place for families and fishermen Beautiful home right on the channel and direct access to the lake. Excellent for fishing, catching catfish right from the dock. It's an excellent place to relax and unwind. Fish directly off the dock or use the Kayaks included to explore the lake. We have an extra-long dock that can accommodate your boat(s). Fully equipped kitchen, your own washer and dryer, and a gas grill. There is a fire pit for the nights you want a campfire.

Guest favourite

Home in Buckeye Lake

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 129 reviews

The Lake House for Family & Friends

Enjoy the Buckeye Lake north shore. Public boat ramp less than 1/2 mile. Walk to boardwalk, enjoy winterfest, restaurants, Yacht Club, ice cream, Boat Yard for bike or kayak rental or enjoy a drink with live music. Fenced yard for small pet (no more that 30 lbs accepted with fee) or enjoy enclosed front entry way to watch the sunset. Roku TV & wi-fi available. Two bdrm, bath, laundry on main floor. Third bdrm upstairs gives a view of the lake. Drive fits 2 cars.