Holiday rentals with lake access in Long Island

Great location, quiet and away from the street. Recommend to anyone coming to the area

A Perfect Serene Getaway! I had the most wonderful stay at this Airbnb! From the moment I arrived, I was impressed by how spotlessly clean and well-maintained everything was. The space was beautifully designed, with a calming and cozy atmosphere that made me feel right at home. The location was incredibly peaceful—perfect for a relaxing retreat. Whether I was enjoying my morning coffee on the patio or unwinding in the comfortable living area, I truly felt a sense of tranquility. The attention to detail, from the soft linens to the thoughtful amenities, made my stay even more enjoyable. If you’re looking for a serene escape where you can recharge and relax, this is the place to be. I can’t recommend it highly enough and will definitely be staying here again!!

10/10, best rental! The house felt like a hotel - it was immaculately clean with beautiful decor and in an ideal location. They put a lot of thought into it, there were so many little things we weren't expecting from an Airbnb that made this one top notch. We appreciated the fluffy clean towels and toiletries they provided. They had a whole section of baby items stored neatly in the garage and we used the baby monitor to keep an eye on the kiddos during the night. We really enjoyed the kayaks with life jackets in adult and kid sizes. They even thought to provide things like waterproof cell phone cases to take on the kayaks! They also had a small cooler, tons of beach chairs and lawn games. The location of the house is great, there's a little beach around the corner and 1 min drive into a part of town with some nice restaurants. We took a recommendation from the house's Insta-page and went on an easy hike on the boardwalk section of the Appalachian trail! It was a great time!

Everything was perfect ! My family and I had a great time. Looking forward to staying here again in the summer.

We had a truly wonderful stay at Gaby's home. Unlike many Airbnb hosts who design their spaces to feel like generic hotels, Gaby’s place radiated warmth, personality, and charm. It felt like a home that had been truly lived in and loved, with thoughtful, personal touches like family photos, unique art, and an impressive collection of books that added so much character. Gaby herself was an incredible host—always responsive, friendly, and approachable. She’s the kind of person I'd love to sit down and chat with. The setting was absolutely stunning. We had snow, the lake was frozen, and the wintry view was really peaceful. The abundance of wildlife made it even more special—we spotted deer, bald eagles, a couple of foxes who visited every morning, and even a bobcat prancing around the house one evening. We also love to cook, and Gaby’s kitchen was fully equipped with everything you could possibly need to play chef If you’re looking for an authentic and unforgettable Airbnb experience

We really enjoyed our stay at this lake house. Isaac & Stef were very friendly and responsive hosts and helped answer any questions we had. The house is comfortable with plenty of windows and situated so that it is looking out over the lake. The views and hot tub were a highlight. Would stay again!

Beautiful home! My boyfriend and I had a great time. It’s super clean and the beds were so cozy. Would definitely go back :)

This house was amazing and so unique! you can tell the host puts a lot of energy into it and it shows. Amazing host as well, Brenda was incredibly responsive and helpful! would recommend this stay again.

We stayed here for 6 days and it was the perfect spot! She had everything we needed & it was a beautiful place to spend our vacation. Erica was extremely responsive whenever we had questions for her. We would definitely come stay here again!!

Ted's place is really good and clean! My friend and I were able to relax and unwind, getting a much-needed break from the city. The kitchen is also well-equipped, making it easy to cook and feel at home. Plus, the locals are super friendly and helpful, adding to the overall experience. Highly recommend!

My friend and I stayed at Clare’s Airbnb in Montauk over the weekend, and she was one the nicest and most attentive hosts we have stayed with. Our room was really nice and contained everything we needed to have a very comfortable time. We really appreciated Clare for her very friendly hospitality and for going above and beyond for us whenever we needed her for something. And she was so lovely to our dog, Chi Chi ☺️ We will def stay at her place again if we make another visit to Montauk! 🐶🐾💕

the place is really nice and comfortable.

Thank you Bee for letting us stay at your beautiful house🙏, it was very clean, had everything we needed for our stay. We will definitely want to come back or recommend our friends and family 💕

This was just what I needed for my first trip to Mohegan Lake! Quiet neighborhood. Cozy bed. Great water pressure. I’ll definitely be booking again if I come back to this cute little town.

Went to locate a go to place for me to reset from life’s nonsense and this was the most healing environment in a peaceful cozy house.

Such a lovely place. Games to play. Books. Relaxing there because so many chill spots to hang. Awesome kitchen. Nice living room. I didn’t sleep well so it was great to be able to pull out sofa and not annoy my hubs. Magnolia tree - perfect for spring. Loved location … between beach and URI. Parking perfect. Loved the area to sit outside.

Very quaint and happy little house. Everything you need is supplied. Bed is comfy. A super nice place to be.

We had a great time here. The outdoor space, deck and kayak/ paddle boat was a big bonus. We will definitely go back!

We had a beautiful stay at the cabin. The views are stunning and the hot tub was glorious. A lovely escape into nature.

The place was perfect for us as a weekend getaway: at such peaceful and secluded location, you can really unplug and feel the warmth of the sun and wind from the ocean. Elizabeth was a super responsible and supportive host. Make sure to book if you are looking for a nice vacation at the beach!

We loved the view out to the lake, which was different every day and throughout the day. The open layout of the house is great to enjoy the views, and if the weather is nice, there are great sitting areas outside as well. The house is well-stocked and cozy. The hosts are friendly and always responsive. There are also great parks to visit nearby. We had a great winter weekend and would love to stay again.

As everyone else noted, what an AMAZING find! A truly beautiful location that has you saying “wow” from when you first step inside. The place had everything you could ask for and we felt like we were at home. I would certainly come back again and I completely understand why she is booked out through the summer. What a lovely area and easy access to so many towns and attractions.

Our stay was lovely and the cottage on the lake was everything we needed to get out of the city and relax. We stayed during a bit of a snowstorm and our host Kevin was overly helpful making sure we could get in and out safely. He salted and shoveled the walkway and our parking spot for us. Kevin was one of the most attentive and kind hosts we've had and we would gladly stay again!

We had a great stay at Greg's place. Potter pond is gorgeous and a kayaking paradise, and the walk to the beach was amazing. Being so close to great restaurants was also amazing. This is a gem of a location for a beach vacation. One note- I had thought we'd be able to launch our kayak at the water right behind the unit, but you need to walk them a little bit over to the kayak launch. Not a big deal, but make sure you bring a kayak cart if you think you'll need one.