Fitness-friendly holiday rentals in Seneca County

Blue Heron Lodge- Lakefront luxury with boat dock

Welcome to Blue Heron Lodge, your ultimate Cayuga Lake getaway! This Adirondack-style home blends modern amenities with upstate NY charm. Enjoy a powered boat lift, dock, kayak, canoe, and rowboat. The main floor offers a luxury kitchen, living/dining area, two bedrooms, and a half bath. Upstairs, two semi-private loft bedrooms include one with an en-suite bath. The basement features a living room, full bath, and gym. Relax on the deck, screened porch, or 150’ of private lakefront. EV charger.

Refined Home across from Inns, walkable to Spa

Gracious house that feels like home in the heart of the village! Newly renovated with superlative amenities: well appointed kitchen with wine cooler, fitness room, tv/kids room, piano, central air, laundry room, EV charging station. Sweeping veranda and back patio with grill and gazebo in large backyard. Ideal for quiet family/friends gathering. Across from the Inns close to The Spa, MacKenzie-Childs, wineries, across the street from lake with village access. Early checkins possible.

Lakefront Romulus Retreat w/ Private Dock!

A New York escape awaits you at this Romulus vacation rental! Boasting a fully equipped kitchen, 4-bedrooms, and 3.5-bathrooms, this home is the perfect getaway for a family or group seeking their next adventure. When here, spend time on the water at Cayuga Lake, take a quick trip to the Montezuma National Wildlife Refuge or visit the It’s A Wonderful Life Museum. Looking to stay in? No problem — hang by the lake on the deck, relax on the covered patio, or shoot a game of billiards!

Heck-of-a-deck Lake House, Kayaks & Sunsets Too!

Make the lake your living room at our freshly renovated lake house just around the corner from Long Point State Park and only a 3 minute drive south of the Village of Aurora. Great deck with grill and a wide view of spectacular sunsets! Dock perfect for swimming, fishing, boating. 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, all amenities to make you feel at home!

Top of the Fingerlakes, relaxing retreat.

Perfectly efficient setup, in a nice neighborhood, that’s in the middle of everything, right at the North end of Seneca lake. 3 minutes from the lake, 5 minutes from downtown Geneva, or 5 minutes from downtown Waterloo. If you're interested, ask about our bicycle and outdoor game rentals.. Hottub is no longer available.

Family Friendly Village Lake House

Enjoy all the comforts of home, in this charming, historic home whose backyard is Cayuga Lake providing swimming, fishing and boating opportunities with the bonus of glorious sunsets at your door! And so conveniently situated in the heart of Aurora! Early checkins possible.

2 Doubles l 41 Lakefront l City View | Near Trails

Stay right in the heart of Geneva, where downtown charm meets lakefront views and winery adventures. The City View Double Room offers two double beds and a peek at the vibrant streetscape. Great for travelers seeking comfort and local flavor.

Plum Point Lodge- Yurt 1

Sleep in a Yurt! Our glamour camping option has all of the amenities of home while being close to nature. After a good nights rest, listen to the birds and feel the warmth of the sun as it rises from the comfort of your queen sized bed.

Finger Lakes Farm House Suite!

This is the Farm House suite in the main house built in 1802. The suite is on the second floor above the restaurant. Plum Point Lodge has 300 feet of lakefront with an inground pool, fitness center, onsite wine shop and restaurant.