Holiday rentals with a fireplace in Ithaca

Anything you need, was at the house. It was like walking into your own home. Beautiful older home with all the modern updates you'd want, without losing the charm. Perfect place for our family to meet up. Lot's of space for everyone. We made Easter dinner and all the necessities were there. Hoping The Blue House is available next time we visit. Dennis was the best host, super responsive and very nice. Thanks for a weekend of great family memories!

it's a beautiful place. it was real quite. we enjoy sitting on the dock and back porch. We want to go. Because of the weather we didn't get to use the fireplace on the waters edge.

We had a great time a Merry's place. Beautiful, old house, but very well kept. We walked into Geneva several times ; less than a mile walk. Hot tub was great, as was the propane fireplace. Just so comfortable and welcoming. We really loved the old house, and Merry was super accommodating. Great visit!!

Very comfortable beds, it was the perfect place for a lot of friends to gather for a weekend away. The backyard is beautiful and the firepit felt very special. Pool table was a HUGE plus. We saw turkeys!!

We loved our girls trip. The home was clean, safe, and in a perfect location. We really enjoyed the hot tub after a day of hiking. There were many thoughtful touches around the house such as the welcome music, wine, plastic glasses and towels for the hot tub, plenty of extra bath towels, and more!

This place is very comfortable! The kids have plenty of space to run around and even during a storm, the living space is family friendly. There were plenty of board games to choose from and the bed rooms were very spacious for down time. I also really enjoyed that they had some extra food options (including gluten-free options) available in the kitchen, which was really thoughtful! We really enjoyed our time here and look forward to coming back!

Clean, cozy, comfortable, and convenient. This is our fourth time staying at Michele's place and we always feel so at home. Looking forward to our next stay, thank you, Michele!

This cute little house was perfect for us. The location was great. It was clean and ready and they even had a few snacks, drinks and food items in the fridge waiting for us! The gas fireplace is cozy. We had several snow and ice storms while we were there. Brian was fantastic! He was right there to shovel and snow blow. The rail trail was also convenient for us. My husband is a cyclist and he was able to get on his fat bike and go right out through the backyard. I would say the only negative and it was not an issue for us is to note - there is no bathroom upstairs with the bedrooms so if you gotta go at night you have to go downstairs. So you have to remember to PB4UGTB! LOl. Great host. Highly recommend! Kim&Joe

Brandon's apartment was beautiful! The photos do not do it justice. I envy Brandon's meticulous attention to detail and interior decorating ability. The apartment was spotless and so stocked with supplies (from cookware to snacks, spices, food staples, bakeing supplies, all necessities and cleaning items) it puts other Airbnbs to shame. I cannot stress how stocked it is enough. I highly recommend staying here.

It was a perfect place to stay for our mother & daughter weekend exploring Watkins Glenn and surrounding area(waterfalls, hiking, wineries, breweries, lakes).Can easily walk into town to shops, restaurants and WG state park. Apartment is fully stocked with all needed for our stay. It is a super cozy, comfortable & clean. Host is very helpful & responsive. It was a perfect fall getaway. Hope to return in the future.

We stayed there for a week of work. It was centrally located and close to everything we needed. The place was clean, comfortable and peaceful. Yes, we would like to do it again in the future.

Julia’s place was exactly what I needed for my visit to my Alma Mater: great location, awesome coffee steps away, access to downtown super easy (where all the restaurants and bars are located). Geneva is a wonderful city and Julia’s place makes it easy to enjoy. Highly recommended without reservation.

Mary is a lovely host and the space is very cozy! Thank you for your kindness and warm welcome

A very charming stay! We only needed one night, but would happily stay again, and for longer!

Shelly's place was so wonderful! It was just as she listed it, but really the pictures do not do it any justice. It's warm and inviting and everything you would need is there and easy to find in the space. We had never been to Geneva before and Shelly gave us some awesome recommendations for local restaurants and bars to check out. Everything that we wanted to do in Geneva was walkable from the front steps which was really great. We will definitely be back and will absolutely stay with Shelly again!

Beth’s place was spotless, tidy, well organized and very comfortable. It took about 20 minutes to walk to the little downtown area. Her instructions were clear and we had no issues at all. A very enjoyable stay!

Michael is a great host. The house is ideally close to Cornell.

We chose Villa Vino for our annual girls trip and were more than happy with our choice! The cottage is beautiful and cozy, with lots of amenities to enjoy and lots of places to visit close by. Dean was an incredibly responsive and helpful host. We had an amazing time!

There were 11 of us on a girls trip and we all had enough space to be comfortable! The lake view was amazing. It was also nice being so close to Two Goats Brewery for a quick drink and bite to eat within walking distance.

Clean, spacious accommodations. Great location near Cornell Lab of Ornithology.

We are a family of 7 and we absolutely loved our time at Jason and Emily's home. It was warm, inviting, and they were incredibly helpful and really went above and beyond. We didn't get a chance to enjoy all of the amenities due to inclement weather, but we were never bored. If you need to relax -- come here, it's just perfect.