Hotel holiday rentals in Finger Lakes

For the location, comfort, walkability, availability, utility and John's responsiveness, safe-accommodations and value/price...almost unbelievable & unbeatable! If you need a place to crash or you need to stay comfortably for some time (i.e. weeks) in Rochester, this is going to be one of, if not, your top option. For multiple people (more than two), it would be a little close quarters to stay more than a few days--like if you will have any others over or stopping by. For my purposes, being in town for two nights for a sporting event, John's place was 100% perfect! Gave me the feeling that my college dorm room (which I loved and re-requested multiple years) had been upgraded to a way better adult format! And with a very nice, immaculate bathroom, retro-design little refrigerator and everything I needed/wanted. Side note: Walk to Ugly Duck Coffee for the best in-town experience!! (Though there is good coffee & maker in the room.)

Great host and very nice clean place in the center of attractions

I'm so impressed with everything with this place!! just stayed for one night but wished I stayed longer!! had ny doggie with me and this place was so dog friendly even had supplies and treats for him and for us!! snores and Firestarter!! I will be back for sure!!

Beautiful hide away close to many pup friendly activities and thank you so much for making us feel so welcome! We will make the Grayhaven our go to stop in Ithaca.

Always so peaceful and yet another great stay

We loved our stay. This place has a fun and retro feel, it's conveniently located to lots of Ithaca coffee shops and restaurants, and we absolutely loved the big window looking out at the snow! The space was very peaceful and everything went smoothly from check in to check out! We would definitely recommend!

We thoroughly enjoyed our stay at Grayhaven. Our room was clean and comfortable. Alexis is a wonderful host. She was thoughtful with providing everything necessary to ensure her guests have a pleasant experience. We will definitely return and will be recommending Grayhaven to friends and family.

Charlton Farm was such a lovely place to stay at the start of a much needed vacation. Sitting on the porch, rocking, and reading a book while the crickets sang was so peaceful. It is a very spacious historic farmhouse with beautiful antique furniture, a well stocked library, a music/puzzle room, and a cheery dining room. Doug and Elaine were so accommodating for our diet, and breakfast was delicious. It was really fun to see the chickens, alpaca, and other animals at the farm. Plus, we took a mile hike around the pond at Twin Cedars Enviromental Area three miles east on Route 20. My only regret is we stayed just one night. I hope we can come again soon!

The Showboat is on the shores of Seneca Lake with a restaurant and bar right on site. The bar had a great vibe with a live band which was really fun to sit outside watch the sunset and listen to music. We visited the rescue farm right down the road and had a very informative and fun tour. The room was very clean and the bathroom was stocked with shampoo, conditioner and body wash. The beds were super comfortable and it was a perfect space for two adults and two kids (14 y/o and 9 y/o). There was no dresser or desk so it was kind of challenging having our belongings on the floor. With that said, the pictures are an accurate reflection of the space and I didn’t notice there was no dresser or desk, so again, a small thing that might make it easier to have a place to put keys, wallet, purse etc when you walk in. Overall - great experience and would definitely recommend!

beautiful and clean place. had everything we needed. Safe location and very peaceful. We would stay here again.

Wonderful place to stay right in Main Street in Geneseo. April was wonderful with communication and offered us the opportunity for a late checkout. Room was extremely clean and we would absolutely stay here again in the future. Thank you for the wonderful stay!

Great place to stay for a quick visit to see your kids or to spend some time visiting the area. Being right in the middle of Main Street, everything is walkable. Looking forward to our next stay for graduation.

My wife and I stayed at Jes' place for three nights. The house is is gorgeous, with the rooms impeccably decorated and furnished. All furnishings supported the heritage of this magnificent historical mansion. I had reserved the smaller room for our stay, but Jes was very kind to upgrade us to Room 2, a very large, well-decorated room with a beautiful and very comfortable king size bed. The bathroom is very large with two separate sinks and a large shower (and separate bath tub). We took advantage of the downstairs rooms, where there are comfortable chairs for reading or just relaxing. There are beverages available to have while relaxing. I highly recommend Jes' place if you're looking to stay in the Trumansburg/Ithaca/Cayuga Lake area. You will feel very at-home and not disappointed. Make your reservation early to try to get Room 2!

We absolutely adored this BnB. It truly felt luxurious between the amazing amenities and gardens, including the honor bar - such a nice touch! This historic home still has so much charm and has clearly been well kept over the years! We loved seeing old pictures and features of the home. We decided to have our engagement photos at the house and it was definitely the right decision. It made the most beautiful backdrop! We will be back!

We stayed in a room at 16 Elm for our anniversary. The room and house were exactly as described - beautiful, clean, and quiet. The location was great, perfect for walking to get a cup of coffee in the morning. It was convenient to the wineries, Taughannock Falls, and Ithaca. We took advantage of many of Jes' suggestions for things to do and places to eat. We would definitely come back here and highly recommend 16 Elm to anyone looking for a romantic retreat in the beautiful Finger Lakes!

Beautiful inn. Room was great. We ate dinner at the restaurant and that was excellent, too. Staff were friendly and helpful.